Cotchin BOG again....

[CoggaRules]

calling all experts....this cotchin dude, he plays for the Knights correct? where does he play? Like is he on the ball, when a dominant ruckman is dominating the whole comp? Beware dudes.

 

[jackson_rules]

I got an infraction for saying a lot less on the Carlton boards. Where is weaver?

i got a red card for saying less

 

[want2spoodge_pettifer]

eating your own shit and piss > carlton

 

[lids2004roar]

calling all experts....this cotchin dude, he plays for the Knights correct? where does he play? Like is he on the ball, when a dominant ruckman is dominating the whole comp? Beware dudes.

Nah, Kreuzer is an average tap ruckman from what I've read.

He is rated the next #1 pick because of what he does around the ground, not his tap work.

 

[Kyusss]

its sad when we have to argue with carlton supporters
their club in 3 years has won what half the amount of games we have?
let calrton be carlton and pretend they are the old powerful arrogant navy blues and everyone cares about them ... unfortunately for them they are a joke and have been for years. The facts are they got pick 1 , 3 because they need them more than us! yes its a crap system but CMON its carlton they arent going to be a threat any time soon (unless they break the salary cap rules again) let them be ! let them dream

 

[jackson_rules]

Nah, Kreuzer is an average tap ruckman from what I've read.

He is rated the next #1 pick because of what he does around the ground, not his tap work.

from all reports ive read, he has a handy little habit of taping the ball down the throat of cotchin

 

[Supertiger]

From what ive seen- Cotchin is a half forward flanker at AFL level. I have doubts that he can become an elite midfielder. Hes struggling to break tags at TAC level. Only played limited games at TAC level anyway this year when the standard of the Victorian kids is under serious question. We need to find a player that we can be pretty certain can mix it at the higher level.

 

[Tambo]

Because of these carlscum/ carltank fwits I don't get my question answered.

I don't mind a bit of banter like this. It brings a bit of fun to the forum. But to think I am suspended from every bigfooty board for doing excactly this is a shame.

Life ticks on....

(in other words im pissed i can't start this sorta banter in the carlton board )

 

[richoatthedisco]

From what ive seen- Cotchin is a half forward flanker at AFL level. I have doubts that he can become an elite midfielder. Hes struggling to break tags at TAC level. Only played limited games at TAC level anyway this year when the standard of the Victorian kids is under serious question. We need to find a player that we can be pretty certain can mix it at the higher level.

5 games, 2x 3 votes, 2x 1 vote for morrish medal.

 

[richoatthedisco]

from all reports ive read, he has a handy little habit of taping the ball down the throat of cotchin

does that make cotchin a choker?

 

[jackson_rules]

does that make cotchin a choker?

nope it makes you a dumb f uck

 

[CoggaRules]

Nah, Kreuzer is an average tap ruckman from what I've read.

He is rated the next #1 pick because of what he does around the ground, not his tap work.

ahh i get it. He has won everything but the kitchen sink in the TAC, because he plays like Patto.
All i am saying is that the tiges need to beware with players who are at the feet of the dominant big man of the comp. Havent seen Cotchin, dont know anything about him apart from what is spruiked here.

 

[YellowandBlackBlood]

ahh i get it. He has won everything but the kitchen sink in the TAC, because he plays like Patto.
All i am saying is that the tiges need to beware with players who are at the feet of the dominant big man of the comp. Havent seen Cotchin, dont know anything about him apart from what is spruiked here.

He has been one of the most talked about juniors in Victoria since Judd. If Deledio is a Ferrari, he's more like a Rolls Royce or Mercedes Benz. All class.

 

[CoggaRules]

He has been one of the most talked about juniors in Victoria since Judd. If Deledio is a Ferrari,he's more like a Rolls Royce or Mercedes Benz. All class.

Yeah he might be. Big deal. The ones that are paid to see what most cant, have to work out if they will be the most talked about when they mix it with the big boys, without someone there, that they have roved to since they were 12. Comprende Compadre?

 

[richoatthedisco]

nope it makes you a dumb f uck

don't get nasty just cos u can't spell

 

[Weaver]

from all reports ive read, he has a handy little habit of taping the ball down the throat of cotchin

Considering that Cotchin played 5 TAC games, and that Kreuzer isn't a dominant tap ruckman I'd be a bit suprised about what you are reading. His ruck work is no better than Pattison's. That is not what the fuss is about.

 

[YellowandBlackBlood]

Yeah he might be. Big deal. The ones that are paid to see what most cant, have to work out if they will be the most talked about when they mix it with the big boys, without someone there, that they have roved to since they were 12. Comprende Compadre?

I've heard Essendon followers that have seen Neil Daniher and co. play as school boys say that this kid plays at a much higher level than even they did! No one really knows how any kid will go against the big boys until they are actually thrust there!!!! Anyone that tells you that can is just a blatant lier! Of course, if their name was Nostradamus or if they had a crystal ball, that would be different! Do you understand my friend?

 

[Tambo]

Considering that Cotchin played 5 TAC games, and that Kreuzer isn't a dominant tap ruckman I'd be a bit suprised about what you are reading. His ruck work is no better than Pattison's. That is not what the fuss is about.

any chance you are able to answer my question on page 4 i think it is?

 

[CoggaRules]

I've heard Essendon followers that have seen Neil Daniher and co. play as school boys say that this kid plays at a much higher level than even they did! No one really knows how any kid will go against the big boys until they are actually thrust there!!!! Anyone that tells you that can is just a blatant lier! Of course, if their name was Nostradamus or if they had a crystal ball, that would be different! Do you understand my friend?

Yeah, but they are getting paid big bucks because they are deemed to be he, thats all.

 

[Deledio2Conca]

This year, how bout we, the Richmond Board, say collectively who we would have taken at each pick straight after the draft. See if we can do better than the recruiters without watching any of 'em.

 

[richoatthedisco]

You have probably said it somewhere Weaver, but who would you select at pick 2 and why?

I know you have stated it may be an idea to trade our pick backwards in trade week.... but lets say that doesn't happen and we are ready to call a name out come draft day?

In other words, would you have a brief top 5 or top 10 on your mind ready for you phantom draft?

weaver has said elsewhere he would pick masten at 2 for the tiges

 

[Tambo]

Cheers mate... anywhere where I can have a read of it?

 

[richoatthedisco]

click on weaver's name and search for posts by him

 

[jackson_rules]

Considering that Cotchin played 5 TAC games, and that Kreuzer isn't a dominant tap ruckman I'd be a bit suprised about what you are reading. His ruck work is no better than Pattison's. That is not what the fuss is about.

thats bull, you would be stupid to sign a ruckman who cant ruck, esp with pick 1, re patto he will be an average tap ruckman thats it who goes alrite around the ground, so your basically saying if he get kruezer he a slight upgrade on patto?

 

[jackson_rules]

don't get nasty just cos u can't spell

oh im sorry sir, but i dont spend all day on the internet proof reading what i write because you cant handle a little spelling error, grow some balls mate its a footy forum not an english class