Coughlan or Polo?

[Runandhyde]

From a Supercoach perspective which of the two do you think will be the more valuable pick up?
Both are similar prices (Polo is slightly dearer), but from the sounds of it Polo has been tearing it up this pre-season however we have yet to see either of them on the track in a practice match (that I'm aware of)
I think they will both increase in value considerably, i am curious to think what others feel, as i think many tigers supporters will find themselves in a similar boat in having to choose between the two in their supercoach/dream teams.

 

[Jisha]

From a Supercoach perspective which of the two do you think will be the more valuable pick up?
Both are similar prices (Polo is slightly dearer), but from the sounds of it Polo has been tearing it up this pre-season however we have yet to see either of them on the track in a practice match (that I'm aware of)
I think they will both increase in value considerably, i am curious to think what others feel, as i think many tigers supporters will find themselves in a similar boat in having to choose between the two in their supercoach/dream teams.

I have not done my supercoach yet, but I am kinda shocked Polo is worth more than Coughlan. I do understand the whole injury side, but out of the two I would think Coughlan would step up more than Polo this year (thats not saying I would not love Polo to do fantastic).

Coughlan just is a brilliant footballer, Polo was still working his way into AFL I feel.

 

[camsmith]

From a Supercoach perspective which of the two do you think will be the more valuable pick up?
Both are similar prices (Polo is slightly dearer), but from the sounds of it Polo has been tearing it up this pre-season however we have yet to see either of them on the track in a practice match (that I'm aware of)
I think they will both increase in value considerably, i am curious to think what others feel, as i think many tigers supporters will find themselves in a similar boat in having to choose between the two in their supercoach/dream teams.

Cogs for sure, but he'll probably miss the first 2-3 weeks so perhaps hold off (although I have him on the bench atm). Cogs always gathers stacks of possessions, especially handballs. Polo however more often plays a tagging role.

So imo I wouldn't go near Polo, he may have a good year, but he doesn't tend to get much of the ball and especially with so many young attacking midfielders in our team there will be less of a role like that for him, he is probably best as our main tagger (behind Johnson perhaps).

Plus unfortunately shoulder injuries reoccur often and easily, he may miss a few weeks thanks to that (lets hope not!).

But if its a question of who will probably deliver more points consistently I'd go with Cogs.

 

[hagansbull]

Both?

 

[richois god]

how many games do you think angus Graham will play this season, for my supercoach team between him and meesen im thinking graham but not sure.

 

[tugga]

Speaking of polos.....
What's the go with the online shop on the RFC website??????
No 2008 media cap, no polos or training shirts, singlets etc????? No shorts.
Lift your game.
(whinge over)

 

[riggers_rulz657]

how many games do you think angus Graham will play this season, for my supercoach team between him and meesen im thinking graham but not sure.

I personally believe Graham won't play many games due to fact that he got injured late last year and he isn't quite ready yet. Meeson might be Melbourne's second ruckman depending how Jamar goes.