Dayne Beams

Remove this Banner Ad

Re: Dane Beams

So what players would be available and please don't throw in spuds that no one would touch.

Wonder whether Bucks will want players or picks and sounds like players might be the go if Tippett is in the market.
 
Re: Dane Beams

Mick Malthouse seemed to have a very different opinion of Banfield compared to you paddy wacker. He had quite a few high praises for the youngster during last year's IR series against Ireland. Banfield is valuable to the Lions in his own way and Mick identified that. If we get pick 16 from Freo, would happily trade that for Beams. He is not elite, he is a very good player.
 
Re: Dane Beams

Jubair said:
Mick Malthouse seemed to have a very different opinion of Banfield compared to you paddy wacker. He had quite a few high praises for the youngster during last year's IR series against Ireland. Banfield is valuable to the Lions in his own way and Mick identified that. If we get pick 16 from Freo, would happily trade that for Beams. He is not elite, he is a very good player.
Click to expand...

Based on the guy we have apparently gotten in the GWS trade Banfield is no longer an option..as the kid is a replica of Banfield but can play midfield and has better hair ;)
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Re: Dane Beams

cotter101 said:
Pick 16/compo pick and Griffin to Collingwood

Clark to Fremantle

Beams to Brisbane
Click to expand...

Griffin wants to go home to SA for personal reasons so looks like he is ruled out.

Could get interesting if Toovey goes as he could be added into the mix also.
 
Re: Dane Beams

morgoth said:
Griffin wants to go home to SA for personal reasons so looks like he is ruled out.

Could get interesting if Toovey goes as he could be added into the mix also.
Click to expand...

Giffin is from WA. His wife is from SA.

He wanted home last year, his wife may want to go home. He most likely would like to get regular games. If Jolly retires that would happen.
 
Re: Dane Beams

TheLastCall said:
Giffin is from WA. His wife is from SA.

He wanted home last year, his wife may want to go home. He most likely would like to get regular games. If Jolly retires that would happen.
Click to expand...

I reckon we would be keen but he has said SA is his destination so unless he changes that we are not in the race.

In our case we could swap Toovey if he decides to go.
 
Re: Dane Beams

cotter101 said:
Pick 16/Compo pick+Polkinghorne for Beams would be close to fair.
Click to expand...

Adding a fringe player who struggled to get games at a bottom 4 side & is no chance at getting games at the potential new club doesn't really sweeten the deal.
 
Re: Dane Beams

JonoNash said:
Adding a fringe player who struggled to get games at a bottom 4 side & is no chance at getting games at the potential new club doesn't really sweeten the deal.
Click to expand...

Polkinghorne played 22 games in 2011 and is a solid footballer.

Polkinghorne + pick 16 wouldn't be that far off Beams. Sounds quite reasonable to me, to be perfectly honest.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Re: Dane Beams

JonoNash said:
Adding a fringe player who struggled to get games at a bottom 4 side & is no chance at getting games at the potential new club doesn't really sweeten the deal.
Click to expand...

LOL .Um..Polkinghorne played all 22 games in season 2011..might want to know the facts prior to mouthin' off...;)...I wouldn't trade Polks
 
Re: Dane Beams

cotter101 said:
Pick 16/Compo pick+Polkinghorne for Beams would be close to fair.
Click to expand...

Polkinghorne is solid, but is not the sort of player we need at all, and we'd be looking for players rather than picks I imagine.

The only two players on the Lions list other than the untouchables (RRR + Brown/Merrett/Luey) who could make a serious impact next year are Banfield and Adcock. If neither of those can be included, it'd have to be a 3-way. Drummond possibly too, but his age and injury history make him tough to value accurately.

So in all likelihood, if the worst case scenario happens and Beams requests a trade to the Lions, it'd need to be a 3-way deal.
 
Re: Dane Beams

mdc said:
Polkinghorne is solid, but is not the sort of player we need at all, and we'd be looking for players rather than picks I imagine.

The only two players on the Lions list other than the untouchables (RRR + Brown/Merrett/Luey) who could make a serious impact next year are Banfield and Adcock. If neither of those can be included, it'd have to be a 3-way. Drummond possibly too, but his age and injury history make him tough to value accurately.

So in all likelihood, if the worst case scenario happens and Beams requests a trade to the Lions, it'd need to be a 3-way deal.
Click to expand...

If you lost Beams to us Polkinghorne could play a Beams type role, How ever I agree a 3 way trade would have to be done.
 
Re: Dane Beams

cotter101 said:
I would trade him(reluctantly) for another young quality player in Beams who is better.
Click to expand...

May well be...but no way pick 16 & Polks.. that's paying way over for a player with off field baggage...Still got that lingering nasty aroma called Fev...;)
 
Re: Dane Beams

MrJimmy said:
Why is collingwood trading Beams again? :confused:
Click to expand...

Jaxson Barham is coming back to the club.
Well known fact Jax & Beamer had a falling out.
One has to go....see ya later Beamer!
 
Re: Dane Beams

What would collignwood fans want from us
Including pick 19?
Please refrain from putting ridiculous suggestions
eg. Hurley, heppell etc
 
Re: Dane Beams

HurleyTheFuture said:
What would collignwood fans want from us
Including pick 19?
Please refrain from putting ridiculous suggestions
eg. Hurley, heppell etc
Click to expand...

I personally like the look of Myers. Could swing a deal somehow with a mix of picks.

In saying that, if the rumours that Beams wants to leave are true, those same rumours say he wants to head back to Gold Coast. He could possibly get to Brisbane.

I'd think any Beams trade will be linked to our ability to score a player in the mini-draft.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top