Draft 04?

[GreatGutsAllmighty]

Any comments

1. Deledio
2. Griffin
3. Tambling
4. Roughead
5. Meeson
6. Franklin
7. Willitts
8. Monfries
9. Deluca
10. Eckerman
11. Lewis
12. Bain
13. Grundy
14. Kirkby
15. Wood
16. Toovey
17. Jackson
18. Barling
19. Gibson
20. E Shaw
21. McQualter
22. Pearce
23. Egan
24. Maric
25. Bate
26. Sherman
27. T Williams
28. Redden
29. Little
30. Attard
31. Moore
32. Hartlett
33. D Meyer
34. Batson
35. J Russell
36. Wilkes
37. Le Cras
38. Sharp
39. T Cloke
40. A Fischer
41. Blackwell
42. J W Smith
43. Gilham
44. Morton
45. C Young
46. Ezard
47. Pattison
48. N Ablett
49. Neaves
50. Becker
51. Van Berlo
52. R Bonson
53. Baird
54. McKee
55. Ware
56. A Walsh
57. Swallow
58. T Murphy
59. Juniper
60. T Hill
61. Ed Clarke
62. Bain
63. T Fleming
64. Newton
65. A Thompson
66. Sugars
67. Copping
68. M Lynch
69. Wells
70. Pass
71. Pass
72. Pass
73. Spriggs
74. Pass
75. Pass
76. Pass
77. Pass
78. Pass

 

[crowsarethebest]

Any comments

1. Deledio
2. Griffin
3. Tambling
4. Roughead
5. Meeson
6. Franklin
7. Willitts
8. Monfries
9. Deluca
10. Eckerman
11. Lewis
12. Bain
13. Grundy
14. Kirkby
15. Wood
16. Toovey
17. Jackson
18. Barling
19. Gibson
20. E Shaw
21. McQualter
22. Pearce
23. Egan
24. Maric
25. Bate
26. Sherman
27. T Williams
28. Redden
29. Little
30. Attard
31. Moore
32. Hartlett
33. D Meyer
34. Batson
35. J Russell
36. Wilkes
37. Le Cras
38. Sharp
39. T Cloke
40. A Fischer
41. Blackwell
42. J W Smith
43. Gilham
44. Morton
45. C Young
46. Ezard
47. Pattison
48. N Ablett
49. Neaves
50. Becker
51. Van Berlo
52. R Bonson
53. Baird
54. McKee
55. Ware
56. A Walsh
57. Swallow
58. T Murphy
59. Juniper
60. T Hill
61. Ed Clarke
62. Bain
63. T Fleming
64. Newton
65. A Thompson
66. Sugars
67. Copping
68. M Lynch
69. Wells
70. Pass
71. Pass
72. Pass
73. Spriggs
74. Pass
75. Pass
76. Pass
77. Pass
78. Pass

No offense but no-where near. At least you tried though. Meeson too early wood too late. Bate will be in top 20. Bain @ 12 is way too early. And thers more....

 

[mattyc2422]

No way will we take a ruckman at 5. At 7, maybe.

Dunno about McQualter at 21. I like him from what I see of him but he's not one of our great needs.

Jackson Barling at 18 is much, much too high.

 

[Slick]

Sorry mate, but no where near IMO! The Hawks will not take a ruckman, who will be there at 7, with pick 5! Franklin or Roughead will be selected! Pick 7 will be a Ruckman, either Wood, Deluca or Meesen. McQualter at 21 would be alright though I dare say we will go for a finishing midfielder with that pick, maybe a Jackson type! 26 will be another tall, so that rules out Sherman! There is no way Hawthorn will go for a recycled tall in the draft, they are implimenting a youth based policy and will go for a project KPP like Juniper/Pattison etc with 53!
Also, Barling will not figure so high, I doubt Jackson will either! Bate will not last till 25 nor Wood last till 15.

But, apart from that its... ahh, who am I kidding, it's no where near close!!

 

[Ford Fairlane]

I reckon you're closer to the mark with Port's #11 and #19 picks than most phantos I've seen so far. Meyer and maybe Redden as a smokey could be in the mix for Port early too.

 

[juDDa]

not the best one i have seen but good onya for havin a crack! the only real standouts are bain at 12, and jackson at 18. you have bain put down at pick 62 as well. is that were you meant to put him? barling will go around pick 60 as wel i think.

 

[Andrew Lovett]

Willits, Eckerman, and Barling, and Little wont go that early,Wood Pattison,T Murphy, Copping, Meyer, and Wells definetley wont go that late . Pattison to Richmond or Hawthorn, Deluca not to join brother, Fleming not to get picked up Jackson and Kirkby i agree with but you left out Limbach, Polo, Dunn, and Becker ??? Ezard and Clarke are big calls and Hill and Sugars wont get picked up apart from that its all good Phantom drafts are hard to do you dont know what will happen on Draft Day

 

[bozza]

Who is Ware?

 

[meownotroar]

Who is Ware?

Who's on second, Wheres on Third.

 

[Andrew Lovett]

The Best Phantom Draft Yet- Must Have a look

1-Richmond Brett Deledio
2-Hawthorn Richard Tambling
3-Bulldogs Ryan Griffen
4-Richmond Lance Franklin
5-Hawthorn Jarryd Roughead
6-Bulldogs Cam Wood
7-Hawthorn John Meesen
8-Adelaide Angus Monfries
9-Carlton Tom Williams
10-Collingwood Fabian Deluca
11-Port Adelaide Danny Meyer
12-Richmond Ryan Willits
13-Melbourne Heath Grundy
14-Essendon Roury Kirkby
15-Melbourne Jordan Lewis
16-Richmond Tom Murphy
17-St Kilda Andrew Mcqualter
18-Brisbane Ryan jackson
19-Port Adelaide Matt Bate
20-Richmond Ben Sharp
21-Hawthorn Adam Hartlett
22-Bulldogs Benet Copping
23-Collingwood Dean Polo
24-Adelaide Alan toovey
25-Carlton Earl Shaw
26-Hawthorn Ivan Maric
27-Brisbane Lions Beau Wilkes
28-Adelaide Ben Eckerman
29-West Coast Tom Redden
30-Essendon Danyle Pearce
31-Sydney Chad Gibson
32-Geelong Ryan Bain
33-St Kilda Clinton Young
34-Port Adelaide Justin Sherman
35-Port Adelaide Scott Mcmahon
36-Richmond Adam Pattison
37-West Coast Chris Egan
38-Bulldogs Jackson Barling
39-Collingwood Travis Cloke
40-Adelaide Adam Fisher
41-Carlton Luke Blackwell
42-Kangaroos Jesse W Smith
43-Melbourne Nick Becker
44-West Coast Mitch Morton
45-Brisbane Lynden Dunn
46-Essendon Nathan Van Berlo
47-Sydney Jordan Russell
48-Geelong Nathan Ablett
49-St Kilda Jayden Attard
50-Brisbane Jesse Wells
51-Port Adelaide Jarred Moore
52-Richmond Byron Murphy
53-Hawthorn Dean Limbach
54-Bulldogs Pat Garner
55-Collingwood Matt Rosa
56-Adelaide Jonathan Griffen
57-West Coast Marc Le Cras
58-Kangaroos James Newton
59-fFemantle Andrew Swallow
60-Essendon Ed Clarke
61-Sydney James Podsiadly
62-Geelong Matt Egan
63-St Kilda Andrew Gilham
64-Brisbane Marty Corrie
65-Richmond Matt Little
66-Collingwood James Mcleay
67-Fremantle Scott Delemenico
68-Kangaroos Paul Richardson
69-Fremantle Toby Stribling
70-Essendon Pass
71-St Kilda Eddie Betts

 

[Andrew Lovett]

Re: The Best Phantom Draft Yet- Must Have a look

Continuation from Pick 71
72-Richmond Tim Sheringham
73-Carlton Rowan Nayna
74-Kangaroos Brendan Van Shaik
75-Fremantle Elijah Whare
76-St Kilda Jesse D Smith
77-Carlton Mark Mcgough
78-Carlton Mark Porter
Others who may be close are Hill, Prismall, Hamill ,Mcguane ,Knights ,Jolley, May, Garrubba, and there will be quite a few passes on the late picks
Andrew Lovett

 

[ThatThis]

There is no way Collingwood will pick up DeLuca. Id put money on it.

And why does everyone have monfries going to Adelaide! Bloody **********... Let him slip through to us... they need a ruckman more than a midfielder.

 

[scooter600x]

At least it's original, rather than the regurgitated crap that every other phantom draft come out with.

FWIW, Hawthorn will take a ruckman with one of there first picks, probably Meeson, Alistar Clarkson said they would.

 

[grugman]

There is no way meyer will slip down that far to 33, hes is top 15 for sure.

 

[OldSchool]

There is no way meyer will slip down that far to 33, hes is top 15 for sure.

Agreed.

 

[crowsarethebest]

Eckerman @ 28 wont happen

 

[AROB_DEES]

Murphy at 58 is a joke,
he has been first round in every other phantom drafts