Drafts And Trades

[WaynesWorld19]

We have a CHF. Perrie wouldn't be enough to get Waters or Butler.

IMO waters and Butler are not on an even field - Waters would be worth more

 

[Gunnar Longshanks]

IMO waters and Butler are not on an even field - Waters would be worth more

Obviously. I don't reckon Perrie would be worth parting with either.

 

[Stiffy_18]

Obviously. I don't reckon Perrie would be worth parting with either.

Thats where you would be wrong.

Perrie would most certainly be worth Sam Butler. Not sure he would be enough to get Waters.

Waters >>>> Butler.

 

[Gunnar Longshanks]

Thats where you would be wrong.

Perrie would most certainly be worth Sam Butler. Not sure he would be enough to get Waters.

Waters >>>> Butler.

That's where we differ.

I reckon Butler will develop into a very handy on-baller. Perrie has 3-4 years left.

And where would he play?

Hansen would remain our first-choice CHF, and Perrie is not a good enough set shot to make FF his own. Not when we have Brad Smith lined up for next season.

I just don't know what Perrie's role would be if he came to WC.

 

[Stiffy_18]

That's where we differ.

I reckon Butler will develop into a very handy on-baller. Perrie has 3-4 years left.

And where would he play?

Hansen would remain our first-choice CHF, and Perrie is not a good enough set shot to make FF his own. Not when we have Brad Smith lined up for next season.

I just don't know what Perrie's role would be if he came to WC.

OK lets put it this way,

Perrie is a 26 year old KF who can play both FF and CHF or on the HFF or FP. He has played those roles before and done well in them. He has 4-6 years left in him.

Where he plays for you, I am not sure. Thats up to your coach to decide. He can rotate through a number of forward positions.

You say Butler will develop into a very handy on-baller and I agree but there is a difference between a star on-baller and a very handy on-baller. Key forwards will always have more value in the open market than midfielders. Its a proven fact of life. Chances of picking up a quality midfielder in the draft are MUCH higher than picking up a quality on-baller.

If your offer was Butler alone, I am not sure AFC woudl consid that. Butler is a kid with talent but he hasn't proven himself at the AFL level. He has potential but potential doesn't guarantee you a good AFL career.

If Sarge does go home, time will tell where he ends up and what we get for him. I would be very surprised if we can't get a mid first round pick or equivelant for him. VERY surprised.

 

[Gunnar Longshanks]

If Sarge does go home, time will tell where he ends up and what we get for him. I would be very surprised if we can't get a mid first round pick or equivelant for him. VERY surprised.

Why do they call him Sarge?

 

[Stiffy_18]

Why do they call him Sarge?

Because he stood to attention whenever Blighty addressed the players

 

[birdmanptr]

Because he stood to attention whenever Blighty addressed the players

I thought it was because he used to be a copper