Fevola v J. Brown

[Ilch]

I was talking to a mate who is also a Collingwood supporter and we were discussing who would be better in our team.
Jonathan Brown or Brendon Fevola?
Hypothetically, assuming both on their day, and Fev without his attitude problems in a game, who would suit our list better, and on the ground positionally in your oppinions?
I said Brown without really thinking, but a point my mate made was that Fev might suit better as it would allow Cloke to play up the ground as he does so well across CHF, and Fev could be our FF.
Whereas Brown we reckon is best at CHF, and with Cloke there already might be better suited that a Fevola would be a better option.

Only just a hypotheticall, so just wanted to see what others think?

 

[Optimax]

Fevola fits the bill as in we need a deep leading forward.

In saying that i dont think either would leave and neither would want to play for us either

 

[Ilch]

i agree neither would leave, but it was just a hypothetical conversation based on the fact how we always seem to be linked with these big names although we probably dont even make a play fr them.

However i did hear an SEN rumour that Fev was coming to collingwood..lol
Total Bullocks!

 

[Might-Pies]

I would say Fev, just because of the role that he plays and it would suit our line up better

 

[ShepBoy]

We will go for Fevola only if we feel we need a tossbag. Otherwise I wouldnt go near that cesspool of a human being with a barge pole.

Let him stuff up Carlton.

 

[thepies]

Fevola fits the bill as in we need a deep leading forward.

In saying that i dont think either would leave and neither would want to play for us either

Agree with you 100%, Would love to have Fevola but he woudnt play for us

 

[Brent24]

Fevola probably suits what we need more.

 

[beez]

I think we're all in agreeance, Fev would definitely suit our forward structure better

 

[Chase the Ace]

Let's see.
One would play his all for the team and the other would play totally for himself.
No that hard really

 

[hellfire]

Fev. Because we already have the big, marking forward.

But we don't have the midfield to deliver it to Fev.

 

[daics cousin]

I understand that Fev and Brown are both very good players,so if we went for either of them then how do we develop the likes of Reid,rusling,Anthony and Dawes,also considering that Rocca will be at the pies next year?
Getting one of these guys will sure up our forward line sure,but hopefully we won't have the injury problems we encounted this year with our tall timber.Then we will be in alittle bother won't we .A good bother at that,but it does stop the development of the youngens coming through.
Who's to say,that Reid,rusling,Anthony won't develop into a fev type of leading forward .
Or that Dawes won't develop into a Jonatahn Brown type,if you stop their development these young guys may move to other clubs and prove their
worth,now i wouldn't like that,plus they are young and they should all become 10 year plus players.
Whereas Brown would have maybe 3 years max before the game passes him by,and Fev probably the same.

 

[Mental Magpie]

I was talking to a mate who is also a Collingwood supporter and we were discussing who would be better in our team.
Jonathan Brown or Brendon Fevola?
Hypothetically, assuming both on their day, and Fev without his attitude problems in a game, who would suit our list better, and on the ground positionally in your oppinions?
I said Brown without really thinking, but a point my mate made was that Fev might suit better as it would allow Cloke to play up the ground as he does so well across CHF, and Fev could be our FF.
Whereas Brown we reckon is best at CHF, and with Cloke there already might be better suited that a Fevola would be a better option.

Only just a hypotheticall, so just wanted to see what others think

I'd take Brown and have him playing out of the square, rotating with Travis Cloke through CHF. The two best CHF's in the Comp.
Brown played out of the square will add years to his career.

 

[evo37]

I'll take Fev, at least that way he wont be able to kick 8 goals against us

 

[Brent24]

More i think about it, option C. Pavlich.

Wouldn't that be nice.

 

[The Dawes]

Fevola is a talented but erratic knobhead - Brown is a champion.

 

[Dave The Man]

More i think about it, option C. Pavlich.

Wouldn't that be nice.

Should of been at collingwood at the start but No Thanks to Judkins - It did not happen

 

[Optimax]

Should of been at collingwood at the start but No Thanks to Judkins - It did not happen

we would never have drafted him dave, and this may surpise you but Judkins still works for and still chooses players FFS