Garlett or Yarran

[parrot]

Both. Garlett should be promoted now. I don't care if he's 68kg. He has talent and a lot of it. The guy floats across the turf. Missing a few easy shots, but his kicking technique is excellent - brilliant timing, just needs to get the radar adjusted a little and he'll kick bags. His development will benefit from being in the senior team. Ditto Yarran.

 

[joe stalin]

Yarran by a mile at this stage .

Garlett needs time in the VFL . Some of the hardheads he will meet in the H&A stuff would make mincemeat of him at the moment . 2010 onwards he will be much better .

Yarran will play against ninthmond . He won't let us down .

 

[1981]

Both. Garlett should be promoted now. I don't care if he's 68kg. He has talent and a lot of it. The guy floats across the turf. Missing a few easy shots, but his kicking technique is excellent - brilliant timing, just needs to get the radar adjusted a little and he'll kick bags. His development will benefit from being in the senior team. Ditto Yarran.

I really don't see the point in promoting Garlett this year. If you don't believe the hype, you'll see he has shown he has definite talent, but his kicking is below average and the time will come in 2009 where his skinny body will give up and scream for a rest. He's just not ready for senior footy week in week out. It's not just about elevating those who show they have some talent, whether they're ready for it is another issue altogether.

Bentley can't kick either, but he's built like a brick sheethouse and could give us something in the clinches, and do it all year. Not saying I would elevate him, rather just showing the thought out other alternatives.

For me it'd be Jacobs, and Jospeh.

I heard that Warnock is still limping, so chances are we will not see him until mid year at best, so it stands to reason we need a in-form ruckman elevated and that's Big Red Mark 2.

And Joseph showed on the weekend he has the pace and strength to do a decent job on a star like gazz Jnr, and this is the sort of player we are screaming out for.

Hill - not yet no thanks
Pfeiffer - already can play I believe
Ellard - OK but there's better options to elevate
Stanton - no way
Bentley - no thanks but not as bad as some say
Garlett - too skinny so will tire and can't kick