Gibbs

[tigertiger]

I like seeing good young players develop from any team I just don't know if he is going to be a champion like Deledio and Cotchin will be or just a good player.

Whats his stengths? Speed, reading the play? kicking? marking?

Would prefer a balanced assessment if anyone can provide one

 

[douls]

I like seeing good young players develop from any team I just don't know if he is going to be a champion like Deledio and Cotchin will be or just a good player.

Whats his stengths? Speed, reading the play? kicking? marking?

Would prefer a balanced assessment if anyone can provide one

Never seen him play or what?
you're asking like he is some kid from the u18's that no-one has heard of

 

[Silvagnis]

I love lamp.

*edited for accuracy*

 

[tigertiger]

Never seen him play or what?
you're asking like he is some kid from the u18's that no-one has heard of

I don't generally watch Carlton games I know he has been in the system for 2 years and gathers a few possisions and Carlton supporters talk him up like he is part of the 2nd coming but I havent read or seen anything to convince me of this

 

[Kooley]

I like seeing good young players develop from any team I just don't know if he is going to be a champion like Deledio and Cotchin will be or just a good player.

Whats his stengths? Speed, reading the play? kicking? marking?

Would prefer a balanced assessment if anyone can provide one

Just get a hold of the dvd when we beat you in round 14. Gibbs tore you a new one.

 

[tigertiger]

*mindless editing*

edited for accuracy

 

[douls]

I don't generally watch Carlton games I know he has been in the system for 2 years and gathers a few possisions and Carlton supporters talk him up like he is part of the 2nd coming but I havent read or seen anything to convince me of this

Here's the tip - If you don't watch Carlton games you aint gonna see him play to form an opinion. Anyways, enjoy your day

 

[tigertiger]

Just get a hold of the dvd when we beat you in round 14. Gibbs tore you a new one.

not a great night for us so id rather not, didnt Cotchin break his attempt at tackle turn him inside out and drill a pass to someone 30 metres out from goal

 

[tigertiger]

Here's the tip - If you don't watch Carlton games you aint gonna see him play to form an opinion. Anyways, enjoy your day

doesnt mean I cant enjoy watching a good player I like seeing judd play and the highlights that come from it and have been able to form an opinion

 

[Kooley]

not a great night for us so id rather not, didnt Cotchin break his attempt at tackle turn him inside out and drill a pass to someone 30 metres out from goal

It was a day game and Gibbs kicked 3 and had a heap of the pill. In the end he was the difference.....

 

[Kooley]

doesnt mean I cant enjoy watching a good player I like seeing judd play and the highlights that come from it and have been able to form an opinion

Keep searching idiot because there aint many good players at the tigers.

 

[douls]

doesnt mean I cant enjoy watching a good player I like seeing judd play and the highlights that come from it and have been able to form an opinion

You're asking for an assesment of a player that went number one in the draft. Did you wake up today and thought, this should be a good thread to start? This is brilliant. I'll ask the good folk at BF cos i can't be stuffed watching him play. Fken genious

 

[Faz 2000]

not a great night for us so id rather not, didnt Cotchin break his attempt at tackle turn him inside out and drill a pass to someone 30 metres out from goal

Cotchin did that to Murphy. Was a nice move.

I'd be worried about Murph, but he managed to scraped together 542 touches this year so I think he'll be OK.

Gibbs was BOG against you guys. Are you sure you're not thinking about someone else? He was the tallish, lean midfielder dancing through the middle, slotting and setting up goals at will. Clean hands.... nice disposal. Wearing #4, in navy blue...?

You're damn right he's the second coming.

 

[tigertiger]

It was a day game and Gibbs kicked 3 and had a heap of the pill. In the end he was the difference.....

I remember Fev tearing it up in the last qrtr and Stevens smashing us in the clearnences but thats about it

 

[Bosun]

not a great night for us so id rather not, didnt Cotchin break his attempt at tackle turn him inside out and drill a pass to someone 30 metres out from goal

It was a day game, Cotchin broke Murphy's tackle and Gibbs tore Deledio apart in the 2nd half showing the gulf between the two former number 1 picks

 

[Bee]

If you haven't seen him play how can you make an assessment?

Why do I get the feeling that this is a subtle attempt at a troll?

 

[tigertiger]

You're asking for an assesment of a player that went number one in the draft. Did you wake up today and thought, this should be a good thread to start? This is brilliant. I'll ask the good folk at BF cos i can't be stuffed watching him play. Fken genious

It wasnt the first thing on my mind but thought it was worth asking,

 

[douls]

It wasnt the first thing on my mind but thought it was worth asking,

You're pretty shit at this aren't you?

 

[walking star]

I don't generally watch Carlton games I know he has been in the system for 2 years and gathers a few possisions and Carlton supporters talk him up like he is part of the 2nd coming but I havent read or seen anything to convince me of this

if u don't generally watch carlton games why are u starting this thread that he wont be as good as lids and cotchin? pathetic attempt of a subtle troll

 

[bendigoblues]

another pathetic attempt by a richmond supporter to troll on another teams page.

perhaps you should spend more of your time focussing on your own teams affairs rather than starting trouble here.

id love to start several richmond threads if i could, much like yours, just for the sake of healthy discussion, do you think richmond supporters would mind a thread like

"terry wallace, can a leather armchair actually coach or should we ask a tree stump for better advice"

"brett delidio, i dont know if he was worthy of the number one pick, i mean hes just a flanker, no speed, no skills, but ive never seen him play, not trolling..."

"richard tambling...." enough said

oh and my favourite thread to start on a richmond page

"they got it right, de shitio and trembling were much better picks than roughhead and franklin... good luck to the hawks, those guys are rubbish"

but starting threads like that would be not so nice of me

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

So based on Deledio's first real season showing why he went number 1 and a decent first season by Cotchin, they are going to be champion's, but Gibbs who had a sensational season of his own hasn't really shown anything to suggest he will be a champion?

I reckon there is enough subtle slurs in there to wonder about the phrasing on the Blues board.

In this scenario we usually get complaints about us being precious when someone only wanted to ask a question, while they head off back to their private boards and backslap each other on the genius of their attempted troll.

Answer: Gibbs has shown nothing ......... to suggest he will not be AT LEAST as good as Deledio or Cotchin.