Good, Average, Pathetic

[RichosGuns]

GOOD:
Foley
Pettifer
Richo
McGuane
Tivendale
Hyde
Newman
Gasper

AVERAGE:
Tuck
Schultz
Moore
P Powden
Krakouer
Polak
Howat
Polo

BAD:
Deledio
Raines
Tamling
Pattison

PATHETIC:
J Bowden
K Johnson

 

[emperor]

I wouldn't say Raines was bad mate. He should be in the average column.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Good:

Foley
Tivendale
Pettifer
Newman

These 4 were actually the only players that were good, in my opinion.

A player that cannot handpass the ball or kick it when they are a professional $400,000 player does not deserve to be in the 'good' column no matter how well they actually defend.

WTF Darren Gaspar? You know how to punch the ball, ffs, put the thing on your hand and do the same thing. ****.

 

[Tigerland]

GOOD:
Foley
Pettifer
Richo
McGuane
Tivendale
Hyde
Newman
Gasper

AVERAGE:
Tuck
Schultz
Moore
P Powden
Krakouer
Polak
Howat
Polo

BAD:
Deledio
Raines
Tamling
Pattison

PATHETIC:
J Bowden
K Johnson

____________________________________

Hyde was a shocker - he turned it over numerous times and for a running player he didn't do enough of it. If he doesn't run he is useless.

Raines was alright - as was Tambling. Deledio was one of our better players. He fell away in the last.

Even though Pettifer kicked 4 goals he took a few dives which meant the ball come out of our forward line uncontested. I hate players that take dives.

 

[kendrick]

i would hardly rate Gasper as good.. imho a guy at his age, should be a rock. even if he has little influence, the times we need him.. he should be there to stand up, i just keep picturing the last few mins of q4.. ball goes to gasper on the mcc wing, he literally froze and turned it over..the guy is an absolute hack under any pressure at all..whenever he gets the ball, i get nervous.

 

[banzai]

GOOD:
Foley
Pettifer
Richo
McGuane
Tivendale
Hyde
Newman
Gasper

AVERAGE:
Tuck
Schultz
Moore
P Powden
Krakouer
Polak
Howat
Polo

BAD:
Deledio
Raines
Tamling
Pattison

PATHETIC:
J Bowden
K Johnson

Far too many players in the good range. How many players won their position? Foley had one good quarter, average for the rest of the game. Tivendale got run over by Nick Stevens, wasnt bad but again didnt win his position. Newman, Richo, Pettifer were all good, Gaspar stopped Whitnall but fumbles too much.

Way too harsh on Joel. Held the best forward in the comp to 3 goals despite pretty good delivery, ok Fev had a shocking first half, but if we were offered 3 goals at the start of the game we certainly would have taken it. Our setups from the kickouts are shocking, If Joel has nothing to kick to it aint really his fault.

 

[Stripes666]

GOOD:
Foley
Pettifer
Richo
McGuane
Tivendale
Hyde
Newman
Gasper

AVERAGE:
Tuck
Schultz
Moore
P Powden
Krakouer
Polak
Howat
Polo

BAD:
Deledio
Raines
Tamling
Pattison

PATHETIC:
J Bowden
K Johnson

I agree 100% except for Moore, put him in bad