Grimes vs. Grimes

[mr tickle]

Which one would you take draft now if you had the chance?

 

[KAYNE]

Voted Jack, Dylan will be very good as well though.

 

[Groupie_]

Dylan. Is a gun defender with only a handful of games under his belt.

Hope he stays hammy free after he was injected with cows blood in Deutschland.

 

[juss]

Depends if Dylan can stay on the park or not.

 

[Schulzenfest]

Dylan. Good key defender > Good half back flanker. Jack's a bit overrated IMO. Needs a hell of a lot of work on his kicking from what I've seen (although I've seen very little of the Dees this year, so maybe he has).

 

[Tulip]

Jack came second in the B&F in his first full year. Also our captain. Dylan is a good player none the less.

 

[Bardo State]

Voted Dylan based on needs.

Both going to be great players though.

 

[tigers_of_old_08]

Dylan

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

If I'm a doctor, ill really earn my money that's for sure.

Fragile the lot of em

 

[MiloStedman]

The monkeys who voted Dylan oughta be rounded up

 

[Groupie_]

The monkeys who voted Dylan oughta be rounded up

Doubt you've even seen him play.

Always spoils it, very good in traffic, great hands and really good disposal. Way better kick than Jack too. I agree with the post above, Jack is overrated.

 

[Slattery_20]

Jack played pretty good footy this year - he takes it, comfortably.

Dylan looks good, but 17 games in 3 years says it all, really. It's just bloody hard to judge a guy who hasn't been able to get on the park; this is no exception.

 

[00Stinger]

Depends if Dylan can stay on the park or not.

Jack couldn't stay on the park for his first 4 years, so they both have their injury problems

 

[juss]

Jack couldn't stay on the park for his first 4 years, so they both have their injury problems

Agreed. Must be something genetic, here's hoping they can put it behind them for good. Both are quality players.

 

[00Stinger]

Agreed. Must be something genetic, here's hoping they can put it behind them for good. Both are quality players.

Jacks was back related and Dylan hamstring related so they are both around the same area

 

[ZAAHAARAKIS!!!!!]

i'd take jack. quite impressed with his work when he goes into the midfield and more exposed form

 

[Tulip]

Doubt you've even seen him play.

Always spoils it, very good in traffic, great hands and really good disposal. Way better kick than Jack too. I agree with the post above, Jack is overrated.

Love the Dylan Grimes myth, grows with every game he misses. Played 17 games, but is apparently in Talia's sphere as the best young KPD in the league. Take him over Grimes, who finally had a full season, and came second in the best and fairest as club captain?

Not on your life.

 

[The Prosecutor]

Love the Dylan Grimes myth, grows with every game he misses. Played 17 games, but is apparently in Talia's sphere as the best young KPD in the league. Take him over Grimes, who finally had a full season, and came second in the best and fairest as club captain?

Not on your life.

So Grimes finally had a full year, yet this apparently rids him of the questionable injury status?

Being captain of Melbourne at the moment isn't exactly a grand achievement, he's the best of a bad lot. In your own words, he couldn't even get a full season together yet was made captain.

 

[Tulip]

Irrelevant point, I take Jack on exposed form. Easy to comprehend, rather than start another bout for nothing.

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

Love the Dylan Grimes myth, grows with every game he misses. Played 17 games, but is apparently in Talia's sphere as the best young KPD in the league. Take him over Grimes, who finally had a full season, and came second in the best and fairest as club captain?

Not on your life.

Dylan was top 4 or 5 in Richmond's (a far better club this year) BnF before he went down with injury.

 

[raymagoo]

Jack easily, Lols to the Richmond fans voting Dylan, sure he started well but 1 horse race so far

 

[Dwight Schrute]

Jack, his season was pretty underrated.

 

[MightyTiger]

Jacks was back related and Dylan hamstring related so they are both around the same area

Dylan was sent overseas to treat his hammies, the doctor said the club had been treating his hamstrings wrongly as his issues started with his back.

Definitely something that runs in the family.

I haven't voted but my point goes to Dylan, young KPP who plays with an experienced head on his shoulders despite being undersized the majority of the time.

And lol to the Demons fans who constantly bring up the co-captaincy and his B&F, last time I checked Melbourne had one of the worst years in the history of the game, only saved by the fact that the 2 new franchise clubs finished below them thus elevating them from the bottom.

 

[Slattery_20]

Dylan was top 4 or 5 in Richmond's (a far better club this year) BnF before he went down with injury.

So? We all know he played 7 or 8 good weeks.
That's not a season though, is it?

 

[a_fighting_fury]

Gimme Dylan, loved his music!