Guy Richards is Gone ???

[SingaporeSling]

Would Richards or Fanning be better than McLaren and Deluca at Carlton in your opinion?

I'm worried that we will be left with no ruckman next year (save for an 18 year old in the draft) and have to minimise the damage somehow.

Honest answers please.

Richard best year was 2004 and again he missed out with injuries , he has since gone backwards every year.

Lucky to play 5-10 games a year becuase of injuries.

Fanning almost mature age who has also regressed after some promising signs.

Richards is better but more injury prone. Most frustarting player injury wise on our list.

Personally I'd go for a Brogan type and hope to find a ruck in the draft.

I'd cut both Richards / Fanning and play cameron cloke and hope his shoulder holds ups. and try to find a VFL ruckman. anything is better than those two duds.