- May 1, 2007
- 88
- 0
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Banned
- #1
In the middle of taking potshots at Graham Cornes in today's article, he also claimed Bob Dylan played Adelaide last night.
Try again in 2 months, Rooch.
And you tell Cornesy to think again!
http://www.news.com.au/adelaidenow/story/0,22606,21935013-21543,00.html
Try again in 2 months, Rooch.
And you tell Cornesy to think again!
Time a-changin'
BOB Dylan played Adelaide last night. No matter how big his star shines in the entertainment industry, the critics will not be holding back their punches in their reviews.
Australian football was once recreation. Then it became a sport. And now it is a billion-dollar part of the entertainment industry competing with Dylan and his stagelight trippers.
AFL umpires have been represented by a union that also deals for circus clowns.
Now there is the big debate - started by colleague Graham Cornes on The Advertiser website - on whether we mere mortals, who never played an AFL game, can criticise AFL footballers.
Cornes has taken issue with how the criticism of footballers has become more scathing in the media . . . and, in some cases, defamatory on websites that need to be held to account as demanded by Australian law.
"I blame the media," says Cornes. This is an interesting verdict. There is no question the media scrutiny of AFL football and footballers is greater than ever before (and why media rights have generated 55 per cent of the AFL's cash reserves today).
At times it can be considered harsh. In the SA market, there is at least one Port Adelaide player and one Crows footballer whose on-field form has been significantly compromised by off-field drama.
These off-field issues remain private - and are not well known by all the media.
But their on-field performances are very public - and subject to the same basis of critique Dylan will get for last night's performance at the Entertainment Centre.
At a time when so many football fans - the majority of whom have not played AFL - are being asked to make a heavy emotional and financial commitment to their teams, it requires critical assessment of player performances, good or bad.
Fairness, as demanded by Adelaide coach Neil Craig, who also has never played AFL, is imperative.
Surprising in Cornes's blogging was his line that "most of the true stars and legends of any sport don't criticise in a negative sense".
The computer-fascinated Cornes might want to hit the refresh button on his memory. Former St Kilda player and coach Grant Thomas is taking no prisoner, as emphasised with his remarks about Fremantle captain Matthew Pavlich and Carlton skipper Lance Whitnall on Melbourne radio recently.
Premiership coaches Malcolm Blight and Robert Walls have not held back in their criticism of players.
Collingwood captain Tony Shaw does not even bother with family lines when it comes to being critical of players, including his nephews Rhyce and Heath Shaw. They are paid to call it as it is. Take note of Walls' assessment of former Port and St Kilda ruckman Cain Ackland as he stumbled into the mire while playing for Carlton against Hawthorn at Telstra Dome on Friday.
"He's not a good player," said Walls on Melbourne Radio 3AW where he is known to carry a "baseball bat" in his commentary.
"And they gave him a three-year contract, which is ridiculous."
And who can forget how Cornes's former Crows players have unloaded in the media? There is Andrew Jarman with his infamous -1 rating of Nick Lower in last year's Showdown. And Cornes's FIVEaa colleague Stephen Rowe's staggering remarks about the thinking (or supposed lack of it) by untried Crows midfielder Darren Pfeiffer.
Think again, Graham.
http://www.news.com.au/adelaidenow/story/0,22606,21935013-21543,00.html





