Head to head records

[The Old Dark Navy's]

I used to take pride in Carlton having a winning record over every other team many moons ago. Port were the first to come along and change that. Fremantle also reversed our early record against them to have a better record. We also just manage to stay in front of the Pies and Bombers, but sustained success by them will always threaten those bragging rights.


Carlton vs

Adelaide - Played 29 - Won 15 - Lost 14 = + 1

Brisbane Bears - Played 17 - Won 13 - Lost 4 = + 9

Brisbane Lions - Played 22 - Won 10 - Lost 12 = - 2

Collingwood - Played 241 - Won 123 - Lost 114 - Drawn - 4 = + 9

Essendon - Played 232 - Won 118 - Lost 110 - Drawn - 4 = + 8

Fitzroy - Played 197 - Won 120 - Lost 72 - Drawn - 5 = + 48

Fremantle - Played 23 - Won 10 - Lost 13 - Drawn - 0 = - 3

Geelong - Played 210 - Won 116 - Lost 92 - Drawn - 2 = + 24

Hawthorn - Played 157 - Won 102 - Lost 55 - Drawn - 0 = + 47

Melbourne - Played 202 - Won 112 - Lost 88 - Drawn - 2 = + 24

North Melbourne - - Played 147 - Won 94 - Lost 53 - Drawn - 0 = + 41

Port Adelaide - Played 21 - Won 8 - Lost 12 - Drawn - 1 = - 4

Richmond - Played 205 - Won 119 - Lost 84 - Drawn - 2 = + 35

St Kilda - Played 206 - Won 157 - Lost 47 - Drawn - 2 = + 110

Sydney/South Melb - Played 214 - Won 125 - Lost 83 - Drawn - 6 = + 42

University - Played 14 - Won 13 - Lost 1 = + 12

West Coast - Played 35 - Won 19 - Lost 16 - Drawn - 0 = + 3

Western Bulldogs - Played 137 - Won 85 - Lost 48 - Drawn - 4 = + 37


Our leading head to head record is under threat against Adelaide, West Coast, Essendon and Collingwood.

We need to catch up to Fremantle, Port and Brisbane Lions.

 

[Banga19]

Got a funny feeling that by the end of the first week of September, we'll be only 1 down on Freo...

 

[gbatman]

it used to be really good 10 years ago, it's copped a flogging over the last 10 years this record. At this stage this is what gives us the advantage over Essendon as the best all time team in the AFL.

 

[invinciBlues]

We need to catch up to Fremantle, Port and Brisbane Lions.

Just freo and port in my eyes. brisbane inherited fitzroy's record along with their flags as far as I'm concerned.

 

[OnceWeWereKings]

Loved being able to point this out as fact.

Most Premierships and a better win / loss record against every team.

Those were the days.....

OWWK

 

[Sin City]

Hopefully we'll be able to get the advantage back comfortably enough over Port and Brisbane in the next few years. Freo, who the hell knows what'll happen with them week to week, hopefully we'll have two more wins over them before the season's out.

 

[Roylion]

Just freo and port in my eyes. brisbane inherited fitzroy's record along with their flags as far as I'm concerned.

Not according to the AFL.

Brisbane Bears / Lions: 3 flags
Fitzroy: 8 flags

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Loved being able to point this out as fact.

Most Premierships and a better win / loss record against every team.

Those were the days.....

OWWK

And zero wooden spoons on top of that.

 

[blueboy25]

I have always been pleased with our record against West Coast especially with our last decade. We seem to play pretty well at subi against them.

 

[OnceWeWereKings]

And zero wooden spoons on top of that.

And the best jumper

And the best.....

It could go on and on.....

 

[Claypigeon]

I missed this fact. .. we'll get there again soon me hopes

 

[RobGal]

Is an assumption that most teams got to "catch-up" on the win-loss ratio in the past 5 to 10 years considering on our declining on-field performances in those years.
Therefore the "newer" exapansion teams who we played with in fewer games before then were able to catch up and overtake us.

 

[Blue Dawn]

AFAIC our record against Brisbane is 23 wins from 39 = +7.

 

[Jabba73]

Don't dismiss the theme songs as well, ours is much better than that Heave ho crap.

Don't get me started on the colours of the jumpers .....

 

[agro]

That part made me laugh, just for a moment.

Despite the fact that we hadn't beaten them in the last 10 years - it will take them 50 years for them to catch us if they had kept winning at the same rate.

They were shite, are shite and will always be shite.

 

[Zolli8]

That part made me laugh, just for a moment.

Me too, seeing as though the Saints have won the last 10 years against us and still cant break the ton!

 

[SurreyBlue]

And zero wooden spoons on top of that.

Don't start me on this ODN ..