- Joined
- Jul 25, 2006
- Posts
- 3,819
- Reaction score
- 3,363
- Location
- Adelaide
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Norwood
Our defense looks so much more assured and dangerous without Reilly in it. Loving the work of Hendles
I remember Sando and Harley etc talking about geelong's young defense back in the early 2000s with Sanderson, Harley, Scarlett, Rooke, Enright, Mackie and Milburn. They were all young and developing together at the same time. They grew really close and after playing 30-50 games together they became a powerhouse defense.
I see Milburn building a similar unit in our defense. We have:
- the 2 small defender positions covered (Brown & Laird) they're already doing a good reliable job and will be unbelieveable with another 20-30 games each.
- 2 mid sized running half backs (Hendo & Smith). Their size is important and gives greater flexibility rather than having a 180cm player in that role. It means they have enough height to play as loose man and effect the aerial contest as well as ground level. Also means they can play on a A.Walker type or Chris Mayne etc. if required. it's important having 2 guys capable of the attacking quarterback roles (like Geelong) because if one gets tagged we have someone else who can do it.
- 2 reliable KPD (Talia & Rutten). Hartigan will replace Rutten IMO and I like what I see. I'm not too worried about that. We also have Siggins developing who I also think will be a genuine KPP who can play at either end like Hurley (big call but I believe it).
- then we have Shaw and Otten to fight it out for 3rd tall. Personally I think an in form Shaw would be the best case because he always has high rebound 50 numbers and is quick and athletic which provides the defense with greater flexibility (like Mackie).
The real temptation is to move Smith into the midfield but if we manage to get Polec next year I think he could play on the wing and we could afford the luxury of leaving Smith at half back. If he continues to get 20+ possessions from half back I think it would be great to leave him there. If however we do move him into the midfield next year maybe Reilly goes back to half back and Hendo & Reilly team up across half back. I'd probably rather see Hendo & Smith and hopefully see Polec on the wing.


Just needs a few more years playing at the top level to adjust to the game.