Herald Sun SuperCoach 2008

[nodders08]

any saints members know whats going on with goddard?

any eagles members know whats going on with butler?

injury-wise?

will they be ready for round 1?

butler or gibbs or R.Griffen

goddard or gram or hurn(plus $$$)

any thoughts???

 

[nodders08]

Who Will Play more Games??

jetta Or l.hansen

who Will Have More Points @ Season's End?

pavlich or B.johnson

In Other Words

jetta/b.johnson Or Pavlich/l.hansen

any thoughts???

 

[nodders08]

Does anyone think S.Dew is worth a gamble at 279 k

if he is selected for round 1 i would consider it..have u got thompson or edwards?

 

[dazy]

i got 200k left and i was thinking to upgrading either nathan van berlo or andrew embly to a kane cornes do u think this is a good move

 

[foxy_dal]

Goddard will be back around round 2 or 3 i think maybe even round 1. Do not expect much from him this season particularly early. I would hope by the end of the season his average will probably represent his price at the moment. In other words maybe pick him up somewhere around rounds 7-11 if he is getting some decent game time and playing well. Hopefully i'm wrong and he returns round 1 and dominates!

 

[nodders08]

did anyone else finish in top 200 last year in SC?

i did but im changin the way i go about it this year...should be interesting

i.e trade later, pick middle range players e.t.c instead of awseme and young players..not in between shit

 

[Spartan]

i got 200k left and i was thinking to upgrading either nathan van berlo or andrew embly to a kane cornes do u think this is a good move

Embers is decent value if you want to risk him being injury free.

 

[dazy]

ohkk but i was asking if i should upgrade nathen van berlo or andrew embly to a kane cornes

 

[nodders08]

thanx foxy might hold off for a bit maybe swap him with hurn round 8 im guessing.

 

[nodders08]

ohkk but i was asking if i should upgrade nathen van berlo or andrew embly to a kane cornes

it depends...have u got any other midfielders (like 2- 3 around 200k - 400k) who will be good value for money? if u already do..might aswell go for cornes cos u only get 20 trades(can't trade everyone).

 

[sacka]

if he is selected for round 1 i would consider it..have u got thompson or edwards?

yea got thompson

 

[nodders08]

out of the players below Dew in $$$$ i reckon only 1 player might end up getting more points then him...

i won't say who but i'll give u a clue...not in a victorian-based team

 

[sacka]

out of the players below Dew in $$$$ i reckon only 1 player might end up getting more points then him...

i won't say who but i'll give u a clue...not in a victorian-based team

Thanks mate

 

[cwebb(go_fish#14)]

Hunter(wce) or Newman(rich)???????

 

[nodders08]

Thanks mate

no worries...

pm me if u think u know who it is

 

[nodders08]

Hunter(wce) or Newman(rich)???????

Probably newman..but saying that i would stay away from tigers..if ur looking for a good backman maybe a waters, johnson or kennelly will be better value then hunter or newman (down the track)..

 

[shags83]

Thanks for the opinion Spartan like Reimers as is cheap and think he will play is very hard at it and will win own footy only thing may give away some frees. Should play 15+ games and yes is a bomber.I like Franklin think he has obvious upside but is inconsistent and therefore risky i suppose but will be keeping him. May trade Hawkins for rookie as was not to keen on him anyway but could be value he is a big question mark. Kozi has been in and out of my side about 6 times since i started doing my team a couple of weeks ago have had him as a ruck and a forward will probably keep but interesting to hear your opinions on him just have a feeling he could have a big year but could be very wrong. I f i downgrade Hawkins need to decide witch young forward witch is where I get stuck finding a really cheap forward who will play oh well i am sure i will work it out also thinking about trying to upgrade Palmer but that is another issue all together.

 

[nodders08]

If i downgrade Hawkins need to decide witch young forward witch is where I get stuck finding a really cheap forward who will play oh well i am sure i will work it out also thinking about trying to upgrade Palmer but that is another issue all together.

there's only 1 forward that will get be worth getting below the hawkins price and no it's not nathan thompson

AND HE WILL PLAY OVER 11 GAMES (if pre season form is anything to go by) SO WILL BE GREAT VALUE!

 

[Frrost11]

Waters or birchill as my 4th DEF?

i hav 540k...should i go with one of them and then upgrade elsewhere or should i jst spend tht all on a 4th DEF?

 

[nodders08]

waters for me...he will play more of a midfield roll with judd & cousins gone...but birchall is very consistant and is playing in a very young and promising team....thats why i have both!

 

[Frrost11]

my 5th n 6th are mattner and symes. should i get rid of 1 of them and then hav both waters and birchall?

 

[nodders08]

my 5th n 6th are mattner and symes. should i get rid of 1 of them and then hav both waters and birchall?

yeah i think so... or keep mattner and trade symes for hurn if u don't have him already

 

[Biggie]

Forget about Lynch.

Tsk Tsk.

Under rated by all.

A good thing.

 

[nodders08]

Tsk Tsk.

Under rated by all.

A good thing.

do u mean quinten? a little over priced but will keep an eye open for him later on maybe swap him with kosi round 5 - 8 im guessing

 

[nodders08]

...........