How many weeks for Caddy?

[1990crow]

2 or 3?

Deliberate right arm cheap shot to the head knocked out Mackay for rest of match. Pretty simple suspension?

 

[NSWCROW]

None acording to Roos.....


****ing HATES us


OHHH GET ****ED LYON

 

[The Joker]

ZERO, Complete accident!

The open hand is all the evidence needed to prove he was going for the ball!

 

[M_I_G]

shouldnt get a week, but might get one or a fine imo

Was trying to hit the ball, open hand/wrist hit the player. was a football act

 

[HumanMeatball]

It was a footy act ball was there open hand. Nothing or a fine at most

 

[HumanMeatball]

2 or 3?

Deliberate right arm cheap shot to the head knocked out Mackay for rest of match. Pretty simple suspension?

No

 

[LFC2010]

A fine at most.

 

[BF Tiger]

Was attempting to spoil IMHO, but has to take responsibility for Mackay ending up knocked out. Would've fallen under the old reckless classification I think (sitting between careless and deliberate). How the one guy who gets to decide views it is anyone's guess, but if Caddy doesn't get a week I'm expecting a major meltdown from some Adelaide fans.

 

[Punchy Bassett]

Douglas was a footy act and he went. Mackay didn't play rest of the game, suspension coming. Oh wait big four Vic club nothing to see here.

 

[Tex9798]

I think 1 week, the ball has already gone over his head as he swings his arm around.

I think it should be 0 but history shows that careless spoils that concuss or draw blood get a week.

Look at Sloane a couple of years ago, cljmsy spoil that merely cut Eberts cheek, 2 down to 1.

 

[radiojake]

There is a few things at play here

1) - I've never seen the Crows get such of the rub from the umps before - Mark my words tonight will go down in the same realm as v Fitzroy 1991 Jameson goal after siren - The Vics will scream blue murder but then point out that Richmond played harder in the GF and tradition dictates that finishing 3rd gets you a home GF

2) - Tonight shows why home GFs should never happen as interstate sides get too much of an advantage, so we will always have to play GFs at the home of football at the MCG

3) Josh Caddy was reckless and lazy with his coathanger - In all honesty do I think he should be rubbed out? No way - But Douglas got rubbed out for a football collision - and Merrett didn't even miss a game!?

 

[M_I_G]

Douglas was a footy act and he went. Mackay didn't play rest of the game, suspension coming. Oh wait big four Vic club nothing to see here.

The two are a little different, but i reckon we might see the same outcome. Will be interesting thats or sure. I hope the incident isnt a suspension

 

[HairyO]

Was a sloppy hit, open hand or not. Back in the 80s and even 90s would have been okay. But you cant take out an opposition player and expect to get away with it.

Should get a week.

 

[Ricky Vaughn]

0.

this thread is a joke.

 

[Punchy Bassett]

The two are a little different, but i reckon we might see the same outcome. Will be interesting thats or sure. I hope the incident isnt a suspension

Nope clearly it's not the act it's the injury caused zero difference in that. Neither should go but consistency states he goes.

 

[troymakepeace]

5

 

[radiojake]

0.

this thread is a joke.

In part, I agree

But there has been a ridiculous precedent set

it's all about the outcome

 

[CrowsFlag2018]

Should get 1 as disgusting as that will be.

Cant move the goalposts again for the tiges.

Tbh I would rather Nankervis go though- that shit was proper dirty and can **** a blokes spine.

 

[NSWCROW]

****s sake they had Douglas off to the Hague by 3QT last week

 

[Lsta062]

My guess is 2 weeks down to 1. I don't see him getting off after Mackay didn't play for the rest of the night.

 

[WeeBlake]

Sloane got a week for a spoil

 

[schmuttt]

Fine for carelessness, ridiculous if he gets suspended for that. He was clearly trying to smother the handball.

 

[BG32]

he knew what he was doing, wanted to get the footy and some of the head. You dont swing that hard

 

[NSWCROW]

There is a few things at play here

1) - I've never seen the Crows get such of the rub from the umps before - Mark my words tonight will go down in the same realm as v Fitzroy 1991 Jameson goal after siren - The Vics will scream blue murder but then point out that Richmond played harder in the GF and tradition dictates that finishing 3rd gets you a home GF

2) - Tonight shows why home GFs should never happen as interstate sides get too much of an advantage, so we will always have to play GFs at the home of football at the MCG

3) Josh Caddy was reckless and lazy with his coathanger - In all honesty do I think he should be rubbed out? No way - But Douglas got rubbed out for a football collision - and Merrett didn't even miss a game!?

And we havent had a " run "with em in Melbourne ever since !!!
Well-and-Truly in the red !!!!


Don Scott and Ian Robertson melting though lol

 

[GreyCrow]

Any vision yet? No replay at the ground so I havent seen anything