hypotheticals/what if's thread

[RisingPhoenix]

What if in 2003 or 2004 (cant remember which, but it was before Judd signed his second contract at WC) we had taken up Hawthorns offer of Buddy and Mark Williams for Chris Judd?

Would we of still won in 06 (Minus Judd, but with Buddy?)

Would we of then gone on and won more flags?

 

[Patron]

What if instead of trading Judd to Carlton for there offer, Kennedy and picks 3 (Masten) and 20 (Notte) we instead took up Richmonds offer of pick 2 (Cotchin) and pick 18 (Rance) ?

wow close but kennedy is just way too important to our side i wouldn't really trade him for anyone, cept maybe buddy.

 

[jknothimjustafan]

"What if instead of trading Judd to Carlton for there offer, Kennedy and picks 3 (Masten) and 20 (Notte) we instead took up Richmonds offer of pick 2 (Cotchin) and pick 18 (Rance) ?"

Cotchin is a star but a quality CHF is more valuable that a quality midfielder (just my opinion anyway).

"What if in 2003 or 2004 (cant remember which, but it was before Judd signed his second contract at WC) we had taken up Hawthorns offer of Buddy and Mark Williams for Chris Judd?

Would we of still won in 06 (Minus Judd, but with Buddy?)

Would we of then gone on and won more flags?"

Having Buddy at WCE. Hell yeah! Probably would have won more premierships.

Im surprised people are saying no to Mick. I know there was some controversy when he left and with John a few years ealier but having the best coach in the AFL(again only my opinion) on our coaching panel would be invaluable.