Ideas for all australian

[discotrain]

want to see some ideas for all australian aprt from mike sheehan and co!


B: J.Drummond D.Glass D.Fletcher
HB: A.McCleod C.Cornes H.Shaw
C: N.Lappin J.Bartel S.Burgoyne
HF: M.Pavlich J.Brown S.Lucas
F: B.Johnson M.Llyodd G.Ablett

R: D.Cox C.Judd D.Kerr


inter: L.Hodge A.Carazzo M.Richardson P.Chapman

Coach: N.Craig

 

[SMUU28]

want to see some ideas for all australian aprt from mike sheehan and co!


B. Campbell Brown Matthew Scarlett Andrew McLeod

HB. Heath Shaw Chad Cornes Scott Thompson

C. David Wojcinski Jimmy Bartell Nigel Lappin

HF. Brent Harvey Matthew Richardson Scott Lucas

FF. Brad Johnson Matthew Pavlich Paul Chapman

FOL. Hamish McIntosh Gary Ablett Daniel Kerr

INT. Sam Mitchell Nathan Foley Andrew Carrazo Graham Polak Lance Franklin

Coach. Dean Laidley

 

[Master of Cooks]

B. Campbell Brown Matthew Scarlett Andrew McLeod

HB. Heath Shaw Chad Cornes Scott Thompson

C. David Wojcinski Jimmy Bartell Nigel Lappin

HF. Brent Harvey Matthew Richardson Scott Lucas

FF. Brad Johnson Matthew Pavlich Paul Chapman

FOL. Hamish McIntosh Gary Ablett Daniel Kerr

INT. Sam Mitchell Nathan Foley Andrew Carrazo Graham Polak Lance Franklin

Coach. Dean Laidley

Judd not good enough to sneak ahead of Foley or Carrazo???
No backup for McIntosh???
Sorry to criticise without offering my own team, but give me some time to think and I'll come back to you with one.

 

[SMUU28]

Judd not good enough to sneak ahead of Foley or Carrazo???
No backup for McIntosh???
Sorry to criticise without offering my own team, but give me some time to think and I'll come back to you with one.

He was in my list of 30 but he has been missing for a couple and i think it hasn't been his best year... early on he was on fire, but i think he has just been consistent this year. Problem being i suppose he is that good we just expect 25 touches every week

 

[donkey kong 43]

want to see some ideas for all australian aprt from mike sheehan and co!


B: J.Drummond D.Glass D.Fletcher
HB: A.McCleod C.Cornes H.Shaw
C: N.Lappin J.Bartel S.Burgoyne
HF: M.Pavlich J.Brown S.Lucas
F: B.Johnson M.Llyodd G.Ablett

R: D.Cox C.Judd D.Kerr


inter: L.Hodge A.Carazzo M.Richardson P.Chapman

Coach: N.Craig

Drummond and brown!!!! You are kidding yourself!! Go smoke some more drugs.

 

[donkey kong 43]

B: Wojcinski Glass Fletcher
HB: Mcleod Cornes Shaw
C: Carrazzo Bartel Lewis
HF: B.Harvey Lucas Pavlich
F: Ablett Johnson Chapman

R: Mcintosh Judd K. Cornes

Int: Dal Santo, Edwards, Foley, Kirk.

 

[springydistricts07]

[quote=donkey kong 43;8062518]
B: Wojcinski Glass Fletcher
HB: Mcleod Cornes Shaw
C: Carrazzo Bartel Lewis
HF: B.Harvey Lucas Pavlich
F: Ablett Johnson Chapman

R: Mcintosh Judd K. Cornes

Int: Dal Santo, Edwards, Foley, Kirk.[/quote]

Looks like you just went through best players on the weekend.

 

[xxscubaxx]

glad someone put kirk in there.

 

[Master of Cooks]

B: J.Drummond D.Glass D.Fletcher
HB: S.Fisher C.Cornes H.Shaw
C: B.Harvey B.Kirk T.Lockyer
HF: S.Thompson S.Lucas G.Ablett
F: B.Johnson M.Pavlich S.Johnson

R: D.Cox C.Judd J.Bartel


Inter: H.McIntrye D.Kerr M.Richardson P.Chapman

Coach: M.Malthouse

Unlucky in no order:
A.Carazzo L.Montagna M.Egan J.McDonald A.McLeod T.Edwards L.Hodge N.Lappin N.Malceski

 

[donkey kong 43]

B: J.Drummond D.Glass D.Fletcher
HB: S.Fisher C.Cornes H.Shaw
C: B.Harvey B.Kirk T.Lockyer
HF: S.Thompson S.Lucas G.Ablett
F: B.Johnson M.Pavlich S.Johnson

R: D.Cox C.Judd J.Bartel


Inter: H.McIntrye D.Kerr M.Richardson P.Chapman

Coach: M.Malthouse

Unlucky in no order:
A.Carazzo L.Montagna M.Egan J.McDonald A.McLeod T.Edwards L.Hodge N.Lappin N.Malceski

Just one question: how can people be putting drummond in when he has only played 7 games for the year?

 

[Master of Cooks]

Just one question: how can people be putting drummond in when he has only played 7 games for the year?

Becuase in those 7 games he has dominated. Averaged over 25 touches and more than 10 rebound 50's per game.
Why Wojcinski?

 

[godistricts]

glad someone put kirk in there.

I wouldn't have him in front of any of the following midfielders:
Judd,Bartel,G.Ablett,Mitchell,S.Thompson,Swan,B.Harvey,Foley,Ling,Lockyer &
Montagna.

 

[xxscubaxx]

why not? i would hold him in the same league as each of those players based on performance this year.
he almost matches the likes of bartel and swan on overall possessions and i doubt any fan out there will dispute his influence on a game.
but the reason i think he is better than some of the players above are his contested possessions and tackling ability.

Tackles
kirk 94
bartel 79
mitchell 57
foley 57
montagne 48
judd 47
swan 47
ling 46
lockyer 41
harvey 30

i spose you could say it is due to sydney's style of play but st kilda are very similar in stoppages and montagne only has 48 and collingwood have said they pride themselves on their tackling and contested footy swan and lockyer 47 and 41 a piece.

 

[godistricts]

why not? i would hold him in the same league as each of those players based on performance this year.

he almost matches the likes of bartel and swan on overall possessions and i doubt any fan out there will dispute his influence on a game.
but the reason i think he is better than some of the players above are his contested possessions and tackling ability.

Tackles
kirk 94
bartel 79
mitchell 57
foley 57
montagne 48
judd 47
swan 47
ling 46
lockyer 41
harvey 30

i spose you could say it is due to sydney's style of play but st kilda are very similar in stoppages and montagne only has 48 and collingwood have said they pride themselves on their tackling and contested footy swan and lockyer 47 and 41 a piece.

You may pick Under 9 sides of tackling but not the elite of elite & if he got the footy 1st more he wouldn't have some many tackles, he does not the opposition so they are happy to let him have 25 because he doesn't hurt with them

 

[discotrain]

Drummond and brown!!!! You are kidding yourself!! Go smoke some more drugs.

Thats right not many back pockets are dominating like drummond is at the moment for the lions and how can you question jonathon brown, he is by far the best true centre half forward going around, not many teams have a bloke that has 2 players on him on a weekly basis. I barrack for the bombers but think brown is still better than lucas who is on fire this year.

 

[xxscubaxx]

mate that is coupled with 20 odd possessions a game did you totally miss the first thing i said? hes worthy of all-australian and youve done nothing to convince me otherwise.

 

[i carnt spel]

C BROWN, B HARRIS, D FLETCHER
H SHAW, C CORNES, A MCLEOD
D SWAN, J BARTEL, A COONEY
G ABLETT, M PAVLICH, L FRANKLIN
P CHAPMAN, B JOHNSON, B HARVEY,
H MCINTOSH, C JUDD, B SEWELL

T LOCKYER, J WHITE, S WEST, S PENDELBURY

unlucky: M PRIDDIS, D KERR, S MITCHELL, S THOMPSON, J LEWIS, J WAITE, S LUCAS, J BOWDEN, J HIRD, A MCPHEE, J MCODONALD, D COX, J ADCOK, G POLAK

big improvers by the end of season...

T KENELLY, G JOHNCOCK, L HAYES, B MCLEAN, D WIRRAPUNDA

 

[donkey kong 43]

Becuase in those 7 games he has dominated. Averaged over 25 touches and more than 10 rebound 50's per game.
Why Wojcinski?

You have to be consistant throughout the whole year not just for 6 or 7 games. Wojcinski has killed teams with his run out of defence. Has only averaged 17 possies but what he has done with those is what counts (has also kicked 10 goals from a back pocket). His improvement this year has been a catalyst for geelong's resergence along with bartel, ablett and chapman.

 

[Master of Cooks]

Thats right not many back pockets are dominating like drummond is at the moment for the lions and how can you question jonathon brown, he is by far the best true centre half forward going around, not many teams have a bloke that has 2 players on him on a weekly basis. I barrack for the bombers but think brown is still better than lucas who is on fire this year.

I agree with you. Brown is a way better CHF than anyone in the league, however he hasn't had as bigger impact as Lucas has this year. All Australian is current form, not previous or potential form.

 

[discotrain]

Drummond and brown!!!! You are kidding yourself!! Go smoke some more drugs.

drummond has been in the best every week he has played except the weekend when the ball was hardly down back and J.Brown lazy 10 whose smoking drugs now!!

 

[donkey kong 43]

drummond has been in the best every week he has played except the weekend when the ball was hardly down back and J.Brown lazy 10 whose smoking drugs now!!

I'll guarantee you he will not be in the all aust. team. The selectors meet 3-4 times a year and he wasn't even playing until round 8!!! I know he is a good player but all-australian, not yet. You have jumped on his bandwagon cause he has played 5 or 6 good games. If he plays the same for the WHOLE year next year then yes but as for this year, no chance!!