Remove this Banner Ad

Ins and Outs

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Walker is not ready but our options are limited so that's a fair enough selection. Mullins was ok for Willi on the weekend so he's porbably the local replacement for Nixon. Nixon can't get a kick and needs to play a full game so that's a good exclusion. Tarrant will be missed. Cloke can consider himself lucky Tarrant is injured and Wakelin is in doubt. Rocca must fire big time or we lose, it is that simple. I'm wraped to see McGough in there but he's probably the Buckley insurance. I hope he playes regardless. King had to get a try some time but I can't why now on form myself. I don't think he adds much anyway. Johnno is better at whatever role King is capable of at present.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I don't mind those Inclusions, Blooding one or Two Youngsters this week could be the go. Or so i Think.

Williams is Definately in The Side and so is Walker, if Anyone else to go out it woul bring in Mullins, King or McGough.

I still beleive McGough will be able to play for collingwood and be a permanent Player. He's just got to stick to it and prove himself this season by gettin a definate Spoit in the Team.

Mullins is a Good Player and King, is a Good solid Body. I dunno but i would hope Shaw and someone else gets ommitted so we can atleast blood one youngster this weekend.

Cloke should Take Wakelins position Down Back and Walker should play as the Third tall, I'd Kill For Davidson Right Now. I Think we'd all love him to be playing this weekend.
 
i hope mcgough gets a game, im a fan, he can find the footy although his disposal is so so
walker im not sure should be playing for the pies at the moment, still a bit raw, but with tarrant out and wakelin in doubt, we need some back up and he has 10-15 games experience compared to cam cloke who has none, mckee who is to slow for key back, and jase cloke who doesn't seem to have to much idea at all at the moment
im glad jason cloke is playing, but if wakelin is late withdrawal i would be very worried for our backline
i see no point in playing david king, i would have thought his form with Willie didnt warrant selection (?)
mullins i dont know much about, so i wont comment on that

im not all that worried if buckley plays or not
 
Word is that King WILL play, and his selection is an interesting one - it seems as though the coaching staff were just waiting for him to play 1 above-average game to pick him.
I'm a huge wrap for him, and surely this means Shaw will get chopped (yet again), as I cant see the logic in having 5 running backs in the team: King, Shaw, Cole, Johnson, Lonie.

The interesting one will be to see who replaces Buckley if he pulls out - McGough or Mullins? Wouldn't mind either way personally, though it'd be good to see if Goughy has improved. Though going on form (which MM and Co. clearly aren't) Mullins should get the nod - he was terrific last week for Willy.
 
Considering King is in the starting 18 he is obviously in the side which means the other 4 inclusions will fight with Cole, Lonie and Shaw to make the 4 on the bench.

My bench would be as follows.....

McGough, Lonie, Williams (but not at ****ing full forward), Mullins/Cole.

Clement wouldn't be at full forward, he'd be on Pavlich imo.

Why not have Matty Lokan at full forward? He impressed last week, he just needs to learn when to lead for the ball. Because he is so quick on the burst he tends to go too quickly past where he should be marking it.

Rocca - CHF
Lokan - FF

Clement - Pavlich
Holland - Hasleby
Johnson - Farmer
Lonie - Medhurst
Prestigiacomo - J.Longmuir

Cloke as loose man pleeeeeeeeeeeeease.

Would go something like that I reckon.
 
Good i atleast wanted to blood one youngster this week, i'm hoping Mullins and Nixon come in in a few weeks. Though Mullins wouldnt be to shabby.

I want McGough to prove himself, and see if he cant stick in the lineup, but i'd love to see mullins replace Buckley if he Can't play..

But i would go on the bench: Lonie, Williams, Walker (Would Love to Have Mullins Here but we need another Tall and MM will do this move), McGough.

Mullins and McGough are in there because of Buckley, if he pulls out one fo teh two or maybe both will come in.

Go Pies!
 
Okay first of all I think that Williams is a certain starter because he did play really well for Williamstown last weekend and has definitely earned his stripes.

I watched the news tonight and they said that Buckley is definetly a non-starter. By the sounds of it they have ear-marked Mullins to take his spot. I don't mind that. No matter who we bring in we aren't going to be able to replace Bucks, so why not use his absence to blood a new kid who, if he works out, is going to be around for the next ten years.

From what they said Walker is basically in the squad if Wakes doesn't play, in other words if Wakelin doesn't play Walker will otherwise he won't.

I wouldn't mind McGough or King (or even both) getting a run too. McGough has been doing pretty well for Williamstown from what I've heard and I've heard big things about King as well, so why not give them a go too.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Good to see Mullins in. I watched the Willy game last week and was surprised that Williams got 30 possessions, it kind of crept up on me but he was decent.
 
Good Inclusions in My View, but the Outs are too Big for us to Cover, or any team for that Matter.

Two Debutants, it hinkwe're looking to give atleast 5 players some experience this year.

Feeling a bit sorry for Old McGough.

Watched the Willi Game Last week and Williams was Very Good, Warranted Selection, lets just hope he plays a half decent game.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Ins and Outs

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top