Ins & Outs - Carlton vs Geelong

[BlueBelle]

Teams just named on Channel 10:

Carlton
In: Sporn
Out: Murphy

Geelong
IN : Prismall,Mackie,D Johnson,McCarthy
OUT : Kingsley,Kelly,Callan,N Ablett

Thoughts on Sporn coming in?

 

[BlueWorld]

Make or Break. If he doesn't perform & gets dropped again he'll be Gorn!

 

[BLUEBOY1]

Teams just named on Channel 10:

Carlton
In: Sporn
Out: Murphy

Geelong
Kelly has been dropped but didn't get the rest

Thoughts on Sporn coming in?

S H I T.
I am just glad that the young fellas are still in and didn't get dropped.

 

[BlueBelle]

Yes I agree. Great to see Kennedy and Russell still in (Blackwell was never a chance to be dropped, as you all know!!!)

 

[Hirdy!!]

Yay! Kennedy is still in

 

[HBF]

Teams just named on Channel 10:

Carlton
In: Sporn
Out: Murphy

Geelong
Kelly has been dropped but didn't get the rest

Thoughts on Sporn coming in?

Surely his very very last chance. Maybe he can take some inspiration from the chief, and the way he has played since he has been back in the seniors.

 

[Silvagnis]

Is Lappin still in the team?

 

[BlueBelle]

Is Lappin still in the team?

Skinny has been named but I would expect him to be a late withdrawl

 

[Jeremias]

who are the emergencies? Lappin still in the team? maybe a late change...

Don't like the selection of Sporn, even though I think he has talent, I dont see him as having a future at Carlton. This is his last chance to show something. Would have preferred to see another young kid come in ike Edwards. Edwards, Raso, Hartlett, Bower and Jackson will all get a gig before the end of the year.

Great to see the likes of JR, JK, Carlos and Blackers (of course) still in the team. Maybe they have finally got the messageLAY THE KIDS!

 

[BlueBelle]

who are the emergencies? Lappin still in the team? maybe a late change...

Don't like the selection of Sporn, even though I think he has talent, I dont see him as having a future at Carlton. This is his last chance to show something. Would have preferred to see another young kid come in ike Edwards. Edwards, Raso, Hartlett, Bower and Jackson will all get a gig before the end of the year.

Great to see the likes of JR, JK, Carlos and Blackers (of course) still in the team. Maybe they have finally got the messageLAY THE KIDS!

Not too sure who the emergencies are but will post as soon as I hear

 

[Lance]

Teams just named on Channel 10:

Carlton
In: Sporn
Out: Murphy

Geelong
IN : Prismall,Mackie,D Johnson,McCarthy
OUT : Kingsley,Kelly,Callan,N Ablett

Thoughts on Sporn coming in?

F.....g SPORN, NOT HAPPY JAN.

 

[stokesy]

The best thing that can happen with Sporn in the side, is he just plays his usual crap and that'll be the end of him.

Would have preferred to of seen a rookie or something in the side instead of Sporn.

 

[parrot]

Not that happy with Sporn's selection. Denis has sent the message to the Rookie's saying there's a spot available. Hoping we'll elevate Jackson from the rookie list. Would far rather him in the side than Sporn.

 

[Blah Blah Blue]

Teams just named on Channel 10:

Carlton
In: Sporn
Out: Murphy

Thoughts on Sporn coming in?

1.
not overly happy with this at all
2.
agree with the 'last chance' view

 

[audas]

is this actually final......if it is then its pox !
Or is it channel ten / blues foxing around ?

Sporn.....SPORN.

 

[Funkalicous]

Sheesh. You guys are harsh. At least give Sporn the chance to save his career. We gave Wiggo that much.

Good to see O'hAilpin, Russell, Kennedy, Blackwell, and the others getting another run. We really have adopted the youth policy these last few rounds. We're doing the right thing.

 

[Kooley]

i vividly remember after his 2nd or 3rd year most carlton people were predicting sporn to be a 200 game player for the blues. he offered so much early on and it's been a real disappointment to see him fall away like he has.

personally i'm glad he gets another crack and fingers crossed like wiggins he can show us something. put it this way i'm much happier sporn's in the team than teague or chambers.

go trent

 

[BlueBelle]

who are the emergencies? Lappin still in the team? maybe a late change...

Don't like the selection of Sporn, even though I think he has talent, I dont see him as having a future at Carlton. This is his last chance to show something. Would have preferred to see another young kid come in ike Edwards. Edwards, Raso, Hartlett, Bower and Jackson will all get a gig before the end of the year.

Great to see the likes of JR, JK, Carlos and Blackers (of course) still in the team. Maybe they have finally got the messageLAY THE KIDS!

Jeremias - Here is the team inc. the emergencies

CARLTON
B: Carrazzo, Thornton, McLaren
HB: Scotland, Whitnall, Walker
C: Houlihan, Bentick, Simpson
HF: Lappin, Kennedy, Wiggins
F: Deluca, Fevola, Betts
FOLL: French, Stevens, Blackwell
I/C: Bannister, O'hAilpin, Russell, Sporn
EMG: Bryan, McGrath, Teague
IN: Sporn
OUT: Murphy (shoulder)

 

[Mr.Kennedy]

Had Bower.Hartlett,Waite,Fisher,Kouta and Murphy been fit I dont think Sporn would even be considered.

 

[gandaal]

Mid for mid even if Sporn has been a major disappointment. Makes sense.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

we're kidding ourselves ... Sporn is going to be shown the door after this season.

 

[gandaal]

we're kidding ourselves ... Sporn is going to be shown the door after this season.

The reality is that we haven't got much choice in the matter. We need to replace Murphy with another mid for team balance reasons. The fact that our next best mid is Sporn just shows how little depth we really have. There was literally no other choice.

 

[BlueBelle]

The reality is that we haven't got much choice in the matter. We need to replace Murphy with another mid for team balance reasons. The fact that our next best mid is Sporn just shows how little depth we really have. There was literally no other choice.

That's crap!!! How about playing Walker in the middle and promote Macca and play him at HBF?? Macca > Sporn

 

[gandaal]

That's crap!!! How about playing Walker in the middle and promote Macca and play him at HBF?? Macca > Sporn

Who?

 

[BlueBelle]

Who?

McGrath