jack riewoldt???

[Brad Pearce]

Should we consider him?
http://afl.com.au/default.asp?pg=news&spg=display&articleid=275912

 

[FieryNayta]

No, i dont think so. I know the name Riewoldt is very tantalizing, but hes a tall forward which we have plenty of talent in right now.

I think too often players are given too much credit for their name alone. Id like to see carlton take the absolute BEST TALENT AVAILABLE. From what i hear of this years draft, hes not going to be in our striking range, likely to go pick 11 or 12. Supposedly we'd be crazy not to take gumbleton, hansen or sellar.

Id love to get a top class ruckman and defender and of course another midfielder.

 

[HBF]

No, i dont think so. I know the name Riewoldt is very tantalizing, but hes a tall forward which we have plenty of talent in right now.

I think too often players are given too much credit for their name alone. Id like to see carlton take the absolute BEST TALENT AVAILABLE. From what i hear of this years draft, hes not going to be in our striking range, likely to go pick 11 or 12. Supposedly we'd be crazy not to take gumbleton, hansen or sellar.

Id love to get a top class ruckman and defender and of course another midfielder.

At this stage, I would be happy with either Hansen or Gumbleton. Perhaps Hansen just in front.

 

[Mr.Kennedy]

At this stage, I would be happy with either Hansen or Gumbleton. Perhaps Hansen just in front.

I have just watched the Under18s.I know its just one game but also for me Hansen is just in front

 

[Kooley]

I have just watched the Under18s.I know its just one game but also for me Hansen is just in front

just got back from the under 18's. gibbs well in front

 

[WTTF]

Reiwoldt can play, but for me so far it's Gibbs, Hansen, Gumbleton, Thorp.

 

[cfc05]

Hansen or Gumbleton for me either way.

Up until the changes to the F/S rule Gibbs was all but signed by Adelaide, and has said many times he is a very proud South Australian... massive doubt over wether he'd remain in Victoria, so i dont think its worth it.

Love Hansen or Gumbleton to hold down a kep position in 2 years.

 

[The Grover]

I would take Hansen over Gumbleton, as Hansen would give you more run from CHB and his kicking looked better.

Gumbleton showed he could play back or forward, but may be better suited up forward ( very similar player to Josh Kennedy ).

I think if we take Hansen we can still get 1 or 2 good midfielders or ruck with our 2nd round pick & priority 2nd round if we get one.

Still early days 2 more games to go, Foxtel not televising midweek games.