Free Agency Jack Silvagni - [Joins St Kilda as UFA]

[THE_GUN]

Which 'winning teams' would be after his services on a competitive contract?

Well the pies supporter said they would. Im only going by that

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Well the pies supporter said they would. Im only going by that

As I said, not too worried.

 

[jumperfan]

I want. Gives it his all every week.

 

[Andyy]

I'd have him at Richmond.

100% every contest, obviously a B grade player or there abouts, but more than anything he looks a bit of a leader and culture man.

But as someone else said earlier you have to wonder if that's also tied to him being a Carlton diehard. Personally I think not though. I think he's probably just that sort of bloke.

 

[Vindicater]

Will be getting some decent offers.

 

[Atomboy]

Will be getting some decent offers.

Reckon our offer for TDK is just a smokescreen for J-SOS

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Reckon our offer for TDK is just a smokescreen for J-SOS

Good luck with that one. As die hard Carlton as they come.

 

[Faz 2000]

I’ve always felt JSOS just isn’t quite good enough and lacks AFL attributes, but his form this year has been superb. Who knew a Silvagni in the backline could work? His desperation and competitiveness has absolutely translated.

All Blues fans have always wanted him to succeed, but not necessarily believed. He’s been just great this year, and think he’ll parlay that into a nice contract extension with the old dark navies.

 

[Atomboy]

Good luck with that one. As die hard Carlton as they come.

 

[THE_GUN]

North should make him a big offer

See if Carlton will match

 

[Bamboo Harvester]

North should make him a big offer

See if Carlton will match

He's unrestricted knackers

 

[SurreyBlue]

North should make him a big offer

See if Carlton will match

You spend a lot of time encouraging teams to make Carlton players big offers. You must like our list….

 

[THE_GUN]

You spend a lot of time encouraging teams to make Carlton players big offers. You must like our list….

Yes i think the List is sensational , Best i have seen since 1995 and should go close to winning the flag
and the coach is such a hard nut and cant fault his tactical nous

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

You spend a lot of time encouraging teams to make Carlton players big offers. You must like our list….

He only rates OOC Carlton players because he hopes they'll be forced to pay overs and nuke our salary cap or blow up the joint Ned Guy style.

 

[THE_GUN]

He only rates OOC Carlton players because he hopes they'll be forced to pay overs and nuke our salary cap or blow up the joint Ned Guy style.

What a strange way of thinking !!

Why would i care about Carlton's cap or even nuking it lol
we are all friends here and discussing our thoughts about player value's and my team is not winning any flags the next 5 years so why would i care who wins it.

 

[CCurnow3picks]

You spend a lot of time encouraging teams to make Carlton players big offers. You must like our list….

Any list would look amazing from down there…

 

[bluebaggerjuls]

im sure he wont leave. I would find it interesting tho if a team smells blood if we sign tdk and try to price us out of jack

 

[SurreyBlue]

Yes i think the List is sensational , Best i have seen since 1995 and should go close to winning the flag
and the coach is such a hard nut and cant fault his tactical nous

Hmmmmm, if I didn’t know better or was naive, I might just believe you.

 

[aussierulesrules]

Come to Papa! ️️

 

[Morro]

Heart and soul of the Blues IMO. Hasnt been appreciated much and yet still stuck around. They should reward him now or let him go with their blessing.

 

[Sarcoidevo]

Reckon our offer for TDK is just a smokescreen for J-SOS

Nah we will just take both

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Nah we will just take both

Given you're having to offer TDK who allegedly barracked for the Saints as a kid 700k above market rate to even get him to the table I'd hate to think of how many millions you'd have to offer JSOS a life long Blues diehard

 

[THE_GUN]

Given you're having to offer TDK who allegedly barracked for the Saints as a kid 700k above market rate to even get him to the table I'd hate to think of how many millions you'd have to offer JSOS a life long Blues diehard

Well if his dad said here in $800k x 5 years and if you dont accept then dont come to see your mum again

 

[Atomboy]

Given you're having to offer TDK who allegedly barracked for the Saints as a kid 700k above market rate to even get him to the table I'd hate to think of how many millions you'd have to offer JSOS a life long Blues diehard

I reckon the Saints should go hard at J-SOS just for the laughs.

If we get him it will set the Blues back another 20 years, just like when Hamill jumped ship.

 

[CCurnow3picks]

I reckon the Saints should go hard at J-SOS just for the laughs.

If we get him it will set the Blues back another 20 years, just like when Hamill jumped ship.

How many premierships did you win bringing Hamill across from Carlton?

How are Dow, Stocker(figjam) & Carroll coming along?

$1.7m for an oppo ruck when you already have a ruck & zero midfielders.

SOS forever chasing the big fish & ignoring other needs.

If we are set back 20 years, at least we can sit together .