Johnstone VS Ottens

[chiliboy]

NO1 AND 2 IN THE 97 DRAFT??

The dees copped alot of flak early, but now, who's laughing?

 

[JUBJUB]

Ottens easily.

 

[chiliboy]

Ottens easily.

To all cats supporters:

MOLONEY EASILY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[JUBJUB]

To all cats supporters:

MOLONEY EASILY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Who ?
Oh,the bloke we were mean't to struggle without.

P.S Thanks for Kel and H.

 

[chiliboy]

Who ?
Oh,the bloke we were mean't to struggle without.

P.S Thanks for Kel and H.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!

IGNORENCE REALLY IS BLIIIIIS!!!

 

[Johnson#26]

Johnstone:

Pros:
-Classy
-Good pace
-Skilled
-Cool head under pressure
-Sets up the play
-Outside midfielder

Cons:
-Unaccountable
-Struggles one-on-one
-Not defensive

Answer:
Now: 7/10
Future: 7.5/10 - Very solid classy wingman


Brad Ottens:

Pros:
-Tall
-Skilled
-Great hands
-Strong
-Great kick for goal
-Rucks well

Cons:
-Struggles under pressure
-Inconsistant
-Struggles to take the match apart.

Answer:
Now: 7/10
Future: 8/10 - Possibly one of the best forward/ruckmen in the AFL

Winner: Ottens.

 

[jackson_rules]

OTTENS by a mile

 

[rick James]

ottens would be almost useless to melbourne considering his salary and the fact we have white for rucking and neitz as a FF.

Johnno would be useless for geelong, his style wouldn't fit thier gameplan at all. Funnily enough it fits the demons attacking style perfectly.

johnno is in many peoples opinions the best person to have kick to your forward on the lead... long, flat, lace out, almost everytime.

ottens get's paid about twice as much as johnno.

Value for money - johnno
Value for the demons - johnno
Value for the catters - ottens

Overall - who gives a rats clacker

 

[Souup]

Ottens Easilly

 

[Demonheart]

A good kkp is rare however TJ is playing better footy this year, and the last couple as well.

 

[Higgs Boson]

ottens would be almost useless to melbourne considering his salary and the fact we have white for rucking and neitz as a FF.

Johnno would be useless for geelong, his style wouldn't fit thier gameplan at all. Funnily enough it fits the demons attacking style perfectly.

johnno is in many peoples opinions the best person to have kick to your forward on the lead... long, flat, lace out, almost everytime.

ottens get's paid about twice as much as johnno.

Value for money - johnno
Value for the demons - johnno
Value for the catters - ottens

Overall - who gives a rats clacker

Good post, agree with everything you say.

BTW did you see Johnno's pass off the outside of the foot under pressure to the leading forward (Robertson?) on the weekend? Incredible.

 

[Awesome_Wells]

Johnstone

 

[Sylvia Saint]

A good kkp is rare however TJ is playing better footy this year, and the last couple as well.

"1 kick" Ottens isn't good though. Johnno >>>>>>>

Even Croad ********s on Ottens these days.

 

[Sylvia Saint]

Who ?
Oh,the bloke we were mean't to struggle without.

P.S Thanks for Kel and H.

Hey if you're claiming Kelly and Playfair for Bizzell (who has been awesome since crossing over), then we can claim Brad Miller for Brent "Superstar" Grgic.

 

[Trav 20]

If Johnstone's current form prevails it's a no brainer but it's a big if.

Against Carlton he rebounded from 50 7 times as well as having 11 inside 50's. Amazing. Not to mention his pinpoint disposal and peerless vision. He's an architect on the footy field.

He has to do it all the time though.

 

[superstar]

Croad > Ottens > Johnstone.

The latter is dime a dozen. Plenty of better midfielders at Melbourne alone.

 

[Hoola Hoops]

Ottens > Johnstoned

Not every team has a good tall key position player. Every team has an above average midfielder.

 

[rick James]

If Johnstone's current form prevails it's a no brainer but it's a big if.

Against Carlton he rebounded from 50 7 times as well as having 11 inside 50's. Amazing. Not to mention his pinpoint disposal and peerless vision. He's an architect on the footy field.

He has to do it all the time though.

Yeah, i hate eeing people talk him up too much.

He is genuinely my favourite player. As a bloke and a footballer.

Consistency is what he needs, but only a fool would doubt his skills, I swear, I have never seen anyone with as good a kick as him. It's just, as perfect, as a kick can get. He just doesn't fire enough.

 

[Super Demon]

Ottens easily.

Pfft


Ottens did a great job against the Dee's in round 3

1 Kick
7 handpasses

The mark of a true champion if ever I've seen


No Contest

Johnstone

 

[Leg_Spinning_Sensation]

"1 kick" Ottens isn't good though. Johnno >>>>>>>

Even Croad ********s on Ottens these days.

Croads a gun anyways
Ottens by a bit. THOUGH
different style players and at the time Melbourne couldn't afford Otto and Otto was clearly the best player in the draft then and is by a bit now. Af resh start has helped the big fella