Ladder by preference

[BOND 007]

My eldest came home from school the other day and asked me to create a rd 22 home and away ladder based on how I WANTED the teams to finish.
I found it difficult to create such as list as I tended to view teams in either a positive, neutral or negative way. Below is how I separated the teams and I would like to know from other posters their views. I am particularly interested to know whether the anti-Freo rhetoric is real or put on.

West Coast
Carlton
Geelong
North Melbourne - All positive
Richmond
Brisbane
Adelaide
Western Bulldogs

Melbourne
Hawthorn
Fremantle - All neutral
Port

St Kilda
Collingwood
Essendon - All negative
Sydney

Despite all the qulaity games between the 2 teams over the last 3-4 years, I cant help but want the Swans to come stone motherless

 

[bali-dog]

My eldest came home from school the other day and asked me to create a rd 22 home and away ladder based on how I WANTED the teams to finish.
I found it difficult to create such as list as I tended to view teams in either a positive, neutral or negative way. Below is how I separated the teams and I would like to know from other posters their views. I am particularly interested to know whether the anti-Freo rhetoric is real or put on.

West Coast
Carlton
Geelong
North Melbourne - All positive
Richmond
Brisbane
Adelaide
Western Bulldogs

Melbourne
Hawthorn
Fremantle - All neutral
Port

St Kilda
Collingwood
Essendon - All negative
Sydney

Despite all the qulaity games between the 2 teams over the last 3-4 years, I cant help but want the Swans to come stone motherless

a curious exercise 007..
westcoast
adelaide
sydney
brisbane
port.adelaide
geelong
st.kilda
west bulldogs
nth.melbourne
hawthorn
richmond
fremantle
melbourne
carlton
collingwood
essendon
dont ask me to explain why..a gut reaction.
the swans annoy me,as theyre always around us in cycles etc ..cant seem to shake them..the pies annoy me as their mission seems to be to give all teams a hard time on the way to the grand final,always in the top 8 it seems,always the bridesmaid,but never the bride.
essendon..well, thats obvious, theyre the enemy!
fremantle..nup, draws a blank, nothing...(my anti freo rhetoric is as real or put on as theirs is!? )

 

[smiths]

West Coast
other 15 teams


Dont care where the other teams all end up as long as were on top

 

[Marlin01]

1) West Coast
2) North
3) Brisbane
4) Adelaide
5) Sydney
6) Geelong
7) Hawthorn
8) Essendon
9) Richmond
10) St Kilda
11) Bulldogs
12) Fremantle
13) Melbourne
14) Carlton
15) Port Adelaide
16) Collingwood

 

[Truckosaurus]

1. West Coast
2. Adelaide
3. Western Bulldogs
4. North Melbourne
5. Brisbane
6. Geelong
7. St Kilda
8. Melbourne

9. Richmond - would have them higher but my amusement at seeing them finish 9th would outweigh my positive attitude towards them
10. Hawthorn
11. Sydney
12. Essendon
13. Collingwood
14. Port Adelaide
15. Carlton
16. Fremantle - always good to have some more ammunition come Derby week

 

[tesseract]

What's with the Port Adelaide hate? I don't understand it. I'm neutral towards them.

 

[Truckosaurus]

I used to not mind them until it seemed that they would approach every game with the main goal of smashing the shit out of our players. Never ever forgiven them for the spear tackle on Kerr. They don't do it as much these days but the hate lingers.

That's my reason for disliking them anyway.

 

[faisan]

West Coast
other 15 teams


Dont care where the other teams all end up as long as were on top

what he said

 

[Quinz]

1) Carlton
2) West Coast

The rest

Wait what?

 

[Crooza]

1. West Coast
2. Brisbane
3. Collingwood
4. Richmond
5. Adelaide
6. Carlton
7. Footscray
8. Hawthorn
-------------------
9. North Melbourne
10. Essendon
11. Geelong
12. Port Adelaide
13. Sydney
14. Fremantle
15. Melbourne
16. St Kilda

 

[fryzie]

1. West Coast
2. Brisbane (lived in Qld from 2000-2005)
3. Collingwood (Housemate and Aunty go for them so I think the more competitive they are the better the rivalry)
4. Fremantle (See Collingwood, closer games make rivalry more fun)
5. Sydney (2005 and 2006 were great grand finals, 2006 moreso)
6. Adelaide
7. Hawthorn
8. St Kilda
-------------------
9. North Melbourne
10. Essendon
11. Geelong
12. Port Adelaide
13. Richmond
14. Western Bulldogs
15. Melbourne
16. Carlton (Thanks for JK though)

 

[WCErevival]

1. West Coast
2. Brisbane (lived in Qld from 2000-2005)
3. Collingwood (Housemate and Aunty go for them so I think the more competitive they are the better the rivalry)
4. Fremantle (See Collingwood, closer games make rivalry more fun)
5. Sydney (2005 and 2006 were great grand finals, 2006 moreso)
6. Adelaide
7. Hawthorn
8. St Kilda
-------------------
9. North Melbourne
10. Essendon
11. Geelong
12. Port Adelaide
13. Richmond
14. Western Bulldogs
15. Melbourne
16. Carlton (Thanks for JK though)

1st qualifying final - western derby.

 

[Cuzz09]

1. West Coast
2. Brisbane
3. Collingwood
4. Geelong
5. Hawthorn
6. North Melbourne
7. Bulldogs
8. Richmond

9. Melbourne
10.St.Kilda
11.Adelaide
12.Carlton
13.Sydney
14.Fremantle
15.Port Adelaide
16.Essendon

1st Qualfying Final: West Coast Vs Geelong @ Subiaco
2nd Qualifying Final: Brisbane Vs Collingwood @ Gabba
1st Elimination Final: Hawthorn Vs Richmond @ MCG
2nd Elimination Final: North Melbourne Vs W.Bulldogs @ MCG

1st Semi Final: Geelong Vs Hawthorn @ MCG
2nd Semi Final: Collingwood Vs W.Bulldogs @ MCG

1st Preliminary Final: West Coast Vs Collingwood @ Subiaco
2nd Preliminary Final: Brisbane Vs Geelong @ Gabba

GRAND FINAL: West Coast Eagles Vs Brisbane Lions @ MCG

PREMIERS: WEST COAST EAGLES

WCE: 19.12.126
BRIS: 9.15. 69

Goal Kickers: Kennedy 5, LeCras 4, Hansen, McKinley 3, Embley, Masten, Lynch, Naitanui.

Norm Smith Medallist: Q.Lynch (41 possesions, 15 marks)

 

[EaglesFlyingHigh]

1. West Coast
2. Brisbane
3. Collingwood
4. Geelong
5. Hawthorn
6. North Melbourne
7. Bulldogs
8. Richmond

9. Melbourne
10.St.Kilda
11.Adelaide
12.Carlton
13.Sydney
14.Fremantle
15.Port Adelaide
16.Essendon

1st Qualfying Final: West Coast Vs Geelong @ Subiaco
2nd Qualifying Final: Brisbane Vs Collingwood @ Gabba
1st Elimination Final: Hawthorn Vs Richmond @ MCG
2nd Elimination Final: North Melbourne Vs W.Bulldogs @ MCG

1st Semi Final: Geelong Vs Hawthorn @ MCG
2nd Semi Final: Collingwood Vs W.Bulldogs @ MCG

1st Preliminary Final: West Coast Vs Collingwood @ Subiaco
2nd Preliminary Final: Brisbane Vs Geelong @ Gabba

GRAND FINAL: West Coast Eagles Vs Brisbane Lions @ MCG

PREMIERS: WEST COAST EAGLES

WCE: 19.12.126
BRIS: 9.15. 69

Goal Kickers: Kennedy 5, LeCras 4, Hansen, McKinley 3, Embley, Masten, Lynch, Naitanui.

Norm Smith Medallist: Q.Lynch (41 possesions, 15 marks)

Good luck

 

[WCErevival]

Norm Smith Medallist: Q.Lynch (41 possesions, 15 marks)

Midfield in the GF?

 

[Truckosaurus]

Midfield in the GF?

He was playing on Staker.

 

[Cuzz09]

Good luck

This is my preference - sorry if you dont like it

Midfield in the GF?

Yeah, In the GF he will play a "Richo" type role and be everywhere that day

 

[paran]

WCE
BL
AC
PAP
FD
SS

NMK
HH
WB
RT
GC
SKS
MD
EB
CB
CM

In case you didn't notice, scr3w the pr!ktorians

 

[tcwaters]

1. West Coast
2. Brisbane
3. Richmond
4. Essendon
5. Western Bulldogs
6. North Melbourne
7. Melbourne
8. Adelaide

9. Sydney
10. Hawthorn
11. Geelong
12. Port Adelaide
13. Collingwood
14. St Kilda
15. Fremantle
16. Carlton


I think that's everyone

 

[joeyavalanche]

West Coast
Melbourne (had a soft spot since 2000 grand final)
Western Bulldogs (good underdog club, great to watch)
Geelong (good, honest club. admirable)
Richmond (harmless underdogs)
North Melbourne (good honest club)
Adelaide (interstate, remind me of SA west coast)
Sydney (interstate club. used to like them more, that was before the GFs)

Hawthorn (good footy club, recent arrogance though has seen them slip)
Collingwood (apart from all the usual we hear, they are great to watch)
Essendon (dont mind them when they crap, hate them when playing good)
St Kilda (living in melb for a year now ive noticed how shit supporters are)
Port Adelaide (between choco and the sly tactics, just hate them)
Brisbane (mate is so against west coast and goes for them. pure hate)
Fremantle (no comment)
Carlton (corrupt. judd)

 

[NYJetsfor2029]

West Coast
Essendon - rest of the family goes for them
Sydney - respect, good games and reminder of the glory days
Adelaide - well run club, always very competitive
Brisbane - love Black and Brown
St Kilda - ok
North Melbourne - ok
Melboune - ok

Geelong - ok
Port Adelaide - ok
Footscray - ok
Richmond - becoming embarrassing
Hawthorn - Arrogant club
Collingwood - hold the league to ransom regularly
Fremantle - angry little people
Carlton - dishonourable cheats

 

[HeBeast]

Just hate Freo, Sydney, Collingwood and Essendon. The rest all just look like crash test dummies to me.

 

[CharlieM]

I used to not mind them until it seemed that they would approach every game with the main goal of smashing the shit out of our players. Never ever forgiven them for the spear tackle on Kerr. They don't do it as much these days but the hate lingers.

That's my reason for disliking them anyway.

I hope you all don't feel this way.
West Coast is my second team and was my first in the AFL prior to us getting the AFL.
Goes back to the days of David HYNES, Shane BOND and Brayden LYLE etc plus loved the fact a non-vic team was kicking arse.
I think the general consensus amongst Port supporters is that the tingles, Collingwood, Carlton and Freo would be the least adored.

 

[Sandy Grouper]

1) West Coast
2) Brisbane
3) Sydney
4) Adelaide
5) Port Adelaide
6) Geelong
7) St Kilda
8) North

9) Bulldogs
10) Hawthorn
11) Richmond
12) Essendon
13) Melbourne
14) Carlton
15) Collingwood
16) Fremantle


that was pretty hard...apart from WC #1 and Freo last.

 

[jazou]

I hope you all don't feel this way.

Hate is such a strong word, but I don't like them. Tredrea & the Cornes boys always seem to walk around with such a swagger, it just p's me off. Brogan as well, he's all huff & puff.
But I like the 'new' brigade - Cassisi is a champ, and I'm a big fan of Salopek for some reason...

But anyway:

1. WCE
2. St. Kilda (seeing them come second again would be funny....)
3. Adelaide (once again, close but no cigar)
4. Richmond (just for kicks)
5. Melbourne (as per Richmond)
6. Nth Melbourne (I'm a fan of Drew Petrie)
7. Hawthorn (meh...)
8. Brisbane (also meh... I'm over the whole Fev thing - they're only this high because I'm a huge Simon Black fan, the others I don't like)
9. Freo (teasing their fans)
10. Sydney (Roos gives me the sh1ts for some reason - i'm probably the only one...)
11. Port (see above, average...)
12. Western Bulldogs (Hall & Aker? lame...)
13. Carlton (on the way down)
14. Essendon (used to really hate them, not so much now, but still....)
15. Collingwood (end of the line for Mick)
16. Geelong (teehee.....)