Lance Is Gone

[blangerang]

what would you guys require from West Coast for Lance (hypothetically of course as he would have to move west)?

chad fletcher would be good

 

[Silvagnis]

Selwood and a draft pick will go nicely with Joel next year.
No Chad Fletcher!

 

[andrew_embley]

chad fletcher would be good

I like, I like

 

[andrew_embley]

Selwood and a draft pick will go nicely with Joel next year.
No Chad Fletcher!

how high a pick?

 

[blangerang]

I like, I like

so you would rather a fat useless slow lance whitnall, over a player who was all australian last season?

 

[WTTF]

Make It Whits And Houla for Lockyer and Taz

Not going to happen mate..........give it a rest.

 

[WTTF]

Selwood and a draft pick will go nicely with Joel next year.
No Chad Fletcher!

Agree, 1st Round & Selwood would do the trick.............I can't see Lance wanting to leave Melbourne though. I think he'd like it at West Coast though.........aren't HUNGRY JACKS their major sponsor?

 

[Silvagnis]

how high a pick?

Get another first round pick in the range of 12 - 16 for Gardiner and we'll talk.
Apparently the Eagles are now after Fev according to someone on a Carlton forum.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Agree, 1st Round & Selwood would do the trick.............I can't see Lance wanting to leave Melbourne though. I think he'd like it at West Coast though.........aren't HUNGRY JACKS their major sponsor?

 

[HBF]

Fev is staying put - end of story.

As for Lance, we need to take the best available deal, however, if it means we get Luke Power in the PSD, i'll gladly take the bullogs pick at 11 and Sam Power.

 

[Silvagnis]

Fev is staying put - end of story.

As for Lance, we need to take the best available deal, however, if it means we get Luke Power in the PSD, i'll gladly take the bullogs pick at 11 and Sam Power.

Power's a dud and I'd only do that if they take Karl Norman.

 

[HBF]

Power's a dud and I'd only do that if they take Karl Norman.

Cypher, i'm assuming your taking about Sam. To get Luke Power would be sensational, and who knows about Sam. Change of club where he'll get a regular game and playing with his brother could make him a better player. I'm prepared to take that chance if we can get Luke.

 

[bibi01]

Cypher, i'm assuming your taking about Sam. To get Luke Power would be sensational, and who knows about Sam. Change of club where he'll get a regular game and playing with his brother could make him a better player. I'm prepared to take that chance if we can get Luke.

didn't we pick up cameron croad late in a draft hoping it may convince trent to come to carlton from freo?

 

[mojo31]

didn't we pick up cameron croad late in a draft hoping it may convince trent to come to carlton from freo?

2 words.

SHANE HARVEY.

 

[Pivot]

I would want Luke Power to play for teh club and his teammates, not just his brother. If the only attraction would be to come to Carlton if his brother is there then no thanks. Good player and all but not worth a Carlton jumper if they possibly are his motives.

 

[HBF]

I would want Luke Power to play for teh club and his teammates, not just his brother. If the only attraction would be to come to Carlton if his brother is there then no thanks. Good player and all but not worth a Carlton jumper if they possibly are his motives.

All i'm saying is that if Luke wants to come back to Melbourne and doesn't have any preferance where he plays, it may help us if Sam is on our list. And anyway, have a look at Nick Stevens. He wanted to play at Collingwood, but he seems to be playing well at Carlton.

 

[andrew_embley]

so you would rather a fat useless slow lance whitnall, over a player who was all australian last season?

personally i would mate. Obviously we have heard countless amount of times about the forward line woes and all that , and IMO we need to bite the bullet and make a move.
IMO, Fletcher is the more expandle one of the midfield and you have to give quality to get it, however yeah i do doubt Lance would want to move interstate and secondly that Fletch would want to move interstate as well.

 

[stefoid]

dogs not interested in whitnal if you are prepared to believe Eade on SEN today.

thats a relief, we should be chasing Watts, Gilham, Polak, and maybe even McDougal.

 

[Pivot]

All i'm saying is that if Luke wants to come back to Melbourne and doesn't have any preferance where he plays, it may help us if Sam is on our list. And anyway, have a look at Nick Stevens. He wanted to play at Collingwood, but he seems to be playing well at Carlton.

Dont get me wrong mate, would love Lukey Power at teh BLues next year but what I am saying is that I want him to want to be at Carlton for reasons. I just don't want Carlton bending over backwards to get Sam Power and so we can get Luke. We may end up giving up too much to get them both unless Luke goes into the PSD, don't know if that will happen though.

 

[spanky ham]

dogs not interested in whitnal if you are prepared to believe Eade on SEN today.

thats a relief, we should be chasing Watts, Gilham, Polak, and maybe even McDougal.

I wouldn't be placing too much faith in the players you've listed.

 

[mojo31]

dogs not interested in whitnal if you are prepared to believe Eade on SEN today.

thats a relief, we should be chasing Watts, Gilham, Polak, and maybe even McDougal.

Gilham and McDouggal? Wow. Good luck with that.

 

[HBF]

Dont get me wrong mate, would love Lukey Power at teh BLues next year but what I am saying is that I want him to want to be at Carlton for reasons. I just don't want Carlton bending over backwards to get Sam Power and so we can get Luke. We may end up giving up too much to get them both unless Luke goes into the PSD, don't know if that will happen though.

I think the club that will chase Luke Power hard will be the bombers. Sheedy has said they will be prepared to do what it takes to get a quality mid into their team. Power certainly is that.

Not to sure whether the magpies would be prepared to give up pick 5, which i'm sure the Lions would ask for in exchange for Power. Will be interesting!!

 

[Effes]

Power has re-signed with the Lions (ch7)

 

[Da Bull]

Thank f$#@, that means Doggies fans will stop trying to push Sam Power onto us. If I hear Bogan 4 life offer us S Power one more time I'll do a Jack Nicholson in The Shining.