Let's check the All Time AFL/VFL Ladder

[Footy Is Good]

How come Collingwood only win 35% of Grand Finals they play in?

It's all that's required.

 

[Magland]

How come Collingwood only win 35% of Grand Finals they play in?

To give the rest of you a chance

to be fair we've gotten some cod ordinary teams into Grand Finals but we're like an insurance salesman, we know we have to hit a certain number of GF's to get a result... we play a Grand Final every 2.6 years on average

It's the wildest ride in the competition

 

[frggr]

To give the rest of you a chance

to be fair we've gotten some cod ordinary teams into Grand Finals but we're like an insurance salesman, we know we have to hit a certain number of GF's to get a result... we play a Grand Final every 2.6 years on average

It's the wildest ride in the competition



View attachment 2298498

So you're winning less than chance dictates.

Sounds like you get into Grand Finals off the back of other advantages before getting found out by the best team in the comp

 

[Magland]

So you're winning less than chance dictates.

Sounds like you get into Grand Finals off the back of other advantages before getting found out by the best team in the comp

I've actually lived through it and it's something more indefinable, the massive spotlight on every player and the expectations of so many seems to have an effect, but like I said, you wouldn't want us to hit our average or we'd be pushing 25 premierships, it's more fun if you all have a chance to catch us.

 

[Footy Is Good]

So you're winning less than chance dictates.

Sounds like you get into Grand Finals off the back of other advantages before getting found out by the best team in the comp

10 flags lol in 129 years

 

[frggr]

I've actually lived through it and it's something more indefinable, the massive spotlight on every player and the expectations of so many seems to have an effect, but like I said, you wouldn't want us to hit our average or we'd be pushing 25 premierships, it's more fun if you all have a chance to catch us.

View attachment 2298505

Well, we don't have to worry about you "hitting your average" because you get found out on the big day time after time.

Didn't you even lose to St Kilda? Almost twice?

 

[Footy Is Good]

Days since Geelonk won a flag: 947 lol

 

[Footy Is Good]

Well, we don't have to worry about you "hitting your average" because you get found out on the big day time after time.

Didn't you even lose to St Kilda?

Nah, that was you

 

[Magland]

Well, we don't have to worry about you "hitting your average" because you get found out on the big day time after time.

Didn't you even lose to St Kilda? Almost twice?

And we have the most premierships, the most wins, best strike rate over 128 years and the most records


so how pathetic are the rest of you?

 

[frggr]

And we have the most premierships, the most wins, best strike rate over 128 years and the most records


so how pathetic are the rest of you?


View attachment 2298520

And you've won....3 since 1960?

 

[Chronz]

And you've won....3 since 1960?

Geelong - 5 premierships since 1953
Collingwood - 5 premierships since 1953

 

[frggr]

Geelong - 5 premierships since 1953
Collingwood - 5 premierships since 1953

Collingwood apparently superior in every though

Can't even best little old Geelong in the modern era, despite the numerous advantages handed to them

 

[Chronz]

Collingwood apparently superior in every though

Can't even best little old Geelong in the modern era, despite the numerous advantages handed to them

I forgot the Dank and Weapon era. In that case, we must take away premierships won in '07, '09 and '11.
That's two premierships since 1953.

 

[Magland]

And you've won....3 since 1960?

And the competition started in 1960?


Play with the numbers all you like but it will always add up to us being the GOAT! you can whine like a lil bitch about how we got there... but we got there!

You didn't!


And for some reason you are not 4th for flags despite being the 4th most successful club for strike rate

Sounds like someone chokes when it counts, you lost 4 Grand Finals in 6 years from 89 to 95 so don't be throwing too many stones, the only reason you snapped a 44 year drought was because you hired Dean The Weapon Robinson in late 2006 when he was partnered up with Stephen Dank... remind when you suddenly started beating everyone by a 100 points and winning flags? Wouldn't have started in 2007 would it? You escaped scrutiny because you're in sleepy hollow (unlike Essendon), but everyone knows you cheated for those flags.


Total domination below: And you're lucky it's 11 years old or it would show us even further ahead

 

[Saveloy Rockstar]

So you're winning less than chance dictates

Someone remind this flog that geeLOL have lost a record FIVE afl gfs