Remove this Banner Ad

Libba could lose Brownlow

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Joined
May 15, 2006
Posts
6,794
Reaction score
12
Location
Werribee
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Tony Liberatore's Brownlow caught in marriage split


BULLDOGS legend Tony Liberatore is facing demands to sell his 1990 Brownlow Medal as part of a bitter marriage split.

A treasure trove of football memorabilia belonging to Liberatore is being valued for sale after legal moves by his estranged wife, Jane.

She wants the proceeds to be kept in a trust for the education of the couple's three young children.

A source close to the dispute said Ms Liberatore had been left with no choice but to pursue the sale of the medals.

Liberatore, 42, is the only player to win the Brownlow Medal, Gardiner Medal (1986, 1988) and Morrish Medal (1984) as the league best-and-fairest in seniors, reserves and under-19s.

Prominent Melbourne sports memorabilia expert Rick Milne yesterday confirmed he had been engaged to price the medals, but declined to comment.

Liberatore said he was getting valuation advice, but had no intention of selling his Brownlow or any other football medals.

"They won't be sold. I'm not selling them," he said.

"I would never, ever sell them, even if it was the last thing I did just before I died."

Asked if his wife was entitled to half of the value of his medals, the 283-game veteran replied: "I don't know, to be quite honest."

Independent experts have predicted Liberatore's rare medal collection could fetch up to $200,000.

But one leading valuer, who would not be named, said a spate of bad publicity surrounding Liberatore in recent months could see their value plunge below $100,000.

"He's had a lot of bad press and that has a very dampening effect on value," the valuer said.

"When they get the bad press, it usually sticks."

Memorabilia prices for items involving troubled North Melbourne champ Wayne Carey have tumbled in recent times, he said.

The record price for a Brownlow Medal was $74,000, paid at auction nine years ago for the 1972 medal won by the late Collingwood ruckman Len Thompson.

Lawyers for Ms Liberatore, a school teacher, are also believed to be examining the value of other assets owned by the former Western Bulldog.

The couple's Essendon home recently sold for $1.3 million.

Liberatore, who is coaching Sunbury in the Ballarat Football League, has since purchased a property in Moonee Ponds in a deal involving former Bulldogs teammate Jose Romero.

The 163cm former midfielder rocked the football world on the eve of this year's AFL season by suggesting Carlton, where he was an assistant coach until this year, deliberately lost games in 2007 to obtain a priority draft pick.

A month earlier, Liberatore caused a furore by claiming that Bulldogs CEO Campbell Rose was more concerned with the club's finances than with winning matches.

Liberatore, known as "Libba", was recruited from Brunswick City to North Melbourne, where he played under-19s and reserve grade football.

He moved to Footscray in 1986, playing 283 games in a career that included 13 finals, life membership, and selection on the interchange bench in the club's Team of the Century.
 
____ing women. How exactly would she have helped him win the Gardiner, Morrish and Brownlow medals??

1.3m for the sale of their home recently. Take half buy another home for $400,000, leaving $250,000 from each parent in the trust fund.

$500,000 in a trust fund aint half bad. No need to go after stuff she had nothing to do with.
 
I will defend the woman here........what if he did wrong by her? I would think she has every right to do what she wants for the betterment of their childrens education.
You sound bitter Borgsta.
 
I will defend the woman here........what if he did wrong by her? I would think she has every right to do what she wants for the betterment of their childrens education.
You sound bitter Borgsta.
Then she can obtain the money elsewhere, she just sounds bitter trying to get back at him.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

A source close to the dispute said Ms Liberatore had been left with no choice but to pursue the sale of the medals.

Look there is always two sides to a story. They are going through a divorce. Therefore I feel to make a judgement based on an article is ridiculous. The quote above from the article is one I took out because in isolation maybe Tony has been nasty with the money side off things and is hiding money undervaluing items. They sold the house for 1.3m does she have half off that? Not enough info to make a judgement as to why she feels that those items need to be valued or sold.

Don't like this stuff in the public media as there are no winners from this only losers.

Personally I cannot judge from where I sit until I here a lot more information from both sides.
 
Selfish woman, I'm sure the kids would love to inherit those medals and football memorabilia to pass on to their children and their children's children.

That sort of stuff is a family heirloom in the making, once you sell it, it's gone for good.

Bitter, twisted woman, regardless of what Tony may or may not have done, she is really only going to hurt her own kids when Tony passes on and they start a long and arduous pursuit of their Father's footballing memories.

Get over yourself Jane, you're coming out of this with a lot more than when you went into it.
 
So we believe everything that's written in newspapers do we? Personally I don't think it's anyone's business but the Liberatores. We all know that journalists twist things around to make a good story, especially when there's not much else happening.
 
Selfish woman, I'm sure the kids would love to inherit those medals and football memorabilia to pass on to their children and their children's children.

That sort of stuff is a family heirloom in the making, once you sell it, it's gone for good.

Bitter, twisted woman, regardless of what Tony may or may not have done, she is really only going to hurt her own kids when Tony passes on and they start a long and arduous pursuit of their Father's footballing memories.

Get over yourself Jane, you're coming out of this with a lot more than when you went into it.

Exactly, they should stay in the family: Their children should have them.
With respect to Jane, she had Christopher ( from another relationship) and married Tony after he won his Brownlow medal
 
I will defend the woman here........what if he did wrong by her? I would think she has every right to do what she wants for the betterment of their childrens education.
You sound bitter Borgsta.

What do you mean, done wrong by her? From a legal point of view that is not a factor.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Now we know why Libba has been making a tool of himself in the media recently with his attack on the Bulldogs and his tanking claims at Carlton - it was all a calculated ploy to tarnish his reputation and drive down the value of his medals, thus reducing the amount he may have to pay to his wife (representing half their value) in the divorce proceedings. Ingenious.:thumbsu:
 
Look there is always two sides to a story. They are going through a divorce. Therefore I feel to make a judgement based on an article is ridiculous. The quote above from the article is one I took out because in isolation maybe Tony has been nasty with the money side off things and is hiding money undervaluing items. They sold the house for 1.3m does she have half off that? Not enough info to make a judgement as to why she feels that those items need to be valued or sold.

Don't like this stuff in the public media as there are no winners from this only losers.

Personally I cannot judge from where I sit until I here a lot more information from both sides.

Of course she got half of the money from the house sale.

If she didn't she should sue her lawyer.

Still I should have started my reply with.

'If true...."
 
He's not having a good run with relationships is he.

Must be doing it tough when you break up with your wife and then lose support from your former footy club.

I guess there is a lesson here for all of us.
 
I think that the best outcome for Libba is just to leave her and not come back to her. Unfortunately she reminds me of Heather Mills wanting all the money in the world.....
 
As i read it, it is up to libba wether he sells the medal or not. There is no court order forcing him to.

Personally I think it would be sad if libba sold sold it.

Even if he did sell it we all know he won those medals, he was the best player in those particular years and you or she can't take that away from him!
 
I've been reading alot of casework lately on these family law proceedings..Man some women are total biatches..she'll get half of everything plus 5% per child. Libba will keep the medals unless he decides he's the one who needs the cash.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

In cases like this I think the outcome should be simple.

A brownlow medal is your own property, even if you are married. It is like a university diploma. It is something made individually for you. It should always be in the possession of the person who has won it.

Other memorabilia is a different story. These items may not be made specifically for you. They also hold a monetary value. In my mind these items are fair game.
 
Not sure about all the legal stuff thats their business BUT it certainly has put Libbers comments reg Bulldogs and Carlton in a different light for me anyway.

Libber may have acted under extreme pressure with what is going on in his personal life. People often behave in weird ways when under extreme pressure especially emotional pressure.

Im not excusing what he said but it may be an explanation.
 
I don't think his misses understands what that Brownlow means to Libba or how valuable this memorabilia is to obtain.

Poor bloke worked his backside off to get that medal and to have it be sold due to a selfish wife isn't on in my books. :thumbsd:
 
Not sure about all the legal stuff thats their business BUT it certainly has put Libbers comments reg Bulldogs and Carlton in a different light for me anyway.

Libber may have acted under extreme pressure with what is going on in his personal life. People often behave in weird ways when under extreme pressure especially emotional pressure.

Im not excusing what he said but it may be an explanation.

I agree, as soon as I saw it I thought that it explained to some extent why he's been so weird in the media lately. It doesn't excuse it, but he's obviously going through a tough time.

I don't know the family's situation or financial situation, but if they just sold their house for over a million dollars I don't know why there is a need to sell his medals- the decision should be up to him regardless, I don't know how she helped him earn them.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom