Game Day Match Discussion - RD 17 vs. Carlton. Fri 04/07 @ 7:20pm (MCG)

[unplugged]

Maynard surely back in...

 

[TradeDraft]

Love West to stay in the Side I think he be Dropped as 4 Talls did not really work

Unless there is a Injury or Resting the Older Player when West play again

 

[PiCkLeJuiCe]

Maynard and Mitchell in.
Dean and Sullivan out

 

[Bianconeri]

Out: Membrey/Mihocek (managed) Markov, Pendlebury/Sidebottom (managed)
In: Maynard, Hill, Mitchell
Sub: WHE

Out of the sets of managed players the other can get managed on the trip to Gold Coast.

 

[frizzle]

Outs - Dean, West, Sullivan
In’s - Maynard, Mitchell, Hill

 

[Kes1984]

Just beat them!

 

[Peters_Nuts]

Outs - Dean, West, Sullivan
In’s - Maynard, Mitchell, Hill

I think this is it and it’s not that West deserves to be dropped but I think it’s clear that as of today, MMM is our best forward line combo

 

[satty]

Sorry charlie dean, but he cannot play

 

[Pendles!]

Hayes and Hill in

 

[Run n Spread]

In Mitchell Hill De Mattia Maynard Parker
Out N Daicos Pendles Side B Miochek Moore (rest)

 

[No SPIN]

In Mitchell Hill De Mattia Maynard Parker
Out N Daicos Pendles Side B Miochek Moore (rest)

Believe me I’ve tried - but I honestly can’t understand what people see in De Mattia
You’ll need to help me.

 

[cityslick1]

Pendles is a freak.

Nick is a gun.

4 points.

Let’s get better now…

Go Pies

 

[gtrain23]

Out: dean
In : anyone that doesn’t make me want smash the TV

 

[Run n Spread]

Out: dean
In : anyone that doesn’t make me want smash the TV

A few shaky moments. But played the Frampton stoppage role and none of their kpfs got away really. We're his moments or game any worse than Frampton?
Give him a go against curnow see if he can a hold up in finals
B worth persisting with
C See if we need that stoppage kpd role or we just go Howe and Moore as talls and try a Markov type.
Top 2 sewn up can't hurt

 

[3rdMan]

Don't think its time for resting. We are close to almost locking away top spot, or top two, so should not be risking losses. If we can push through the next few then we have the remaining games to manage players and not worry about losses.

out: West, Dean, Markov
in: Maynard, Hill, <third player>*

* Will see who is available. Options of those already healthy: Hayes, Mitchell, Steele, Ryan.

 

[Run n Spread]

Love West to stay in the Side I think he be Dropped as 4 Talls did not really work

Unless there is a Injury or Resting the Older Player when West play again

Looked lost but the way their defence set up and our clunky foward line was disorganised did him no favours.
Got into good spots but was ignored or out zoned. Leave him in for 3 weeks rest the talls one by 1 and see how he goes

 

[Finnishpie]

Love West to stay in the Side I think he be Dropped as 4 Talls did not really work

Unless there is a Injury or Resting the Older Player when West play again

Could rest one of the Ms each week for the next 6 and give him a block of games. Problem is he doesn’t look ready. But I’d still be happy to see him play and get some experience.

 

[satty]

Hold of on resting players until the freo and richmond game.

 

[Run n Spread]

Don't think its time for resting. We are close to almost locking away top spot, or top two, so should not be risking losses. If we can push through the next few then we have the remaining games to manage players and not worry about losses.

out: West, Dean, Markov
in: Maynard, Hill, <third player>*

* Will see who is available. Options of those already healthy: Hayes, Mitchell, Steele, Ryan.

Already locked in. Or good as with Richmond and Melbourne (last round) basically certs
Rest now as last month you need to be beat 23 and clicking into form.
Can be too dodgy to leave it too late.
Need everything humming near finals. Risk.peaking too early

 

[Finnishpie]

Out: dean
In : anyone that doesn’t make me want smash the TV

He played the Frampton role perfectly. A dash of doubt, effort without result, gave me few heart attacks, and three nice things. That’s how Billy started out….

 

[Finnishpie]

Believe me I’ve tried - but I honestly can’t understand what people see in De Mattia
You’ll need to help me.

Good hair. I see that.

 

[3rdMan]

Looked lost but the way their defence set up and our clunky foward line was disorganised did him no favours.
Got into good spots but was ignored or out zoned. Leave him in for 3 weeks rest the talls one by 1 and see how he goes

Why though? It's pretty important for us to win for now, don't think we should intentionally weaken our team.

 

[JoinDate]

Out: Membrey(managed), Dean(omitted), Sullivan(omitted)
In: Hayes, Maynard, Mitchell
Sub: WHE

 

[Run n Spread]

Why though? It's pretty important for us to win for now, don't think we should intentionally weaken our team.

It's not weakening. He could have debuted 7 weeks ago. The older forwards need a rest.
Leave him in and as they come back and unless he tears it up he will be omitted come finals.

 

[Mollythedolly]

Don’t think there’ll be too many changes. Hill will obviously return. Maynard the only real chance from the injured players, Schultz a long shot. Mitchell, Cochran, Steele, Cox and Hayes the pick of the VFL win. I’d give West another crack.

On the flip side, looks like we got away with a clean bill of health so that’s a strong positive out of that game, but it makes selecting players to omit a tougher call. Sullivan and WHE the most vulnerable along with Markov who was a late in.