Remove this Banner Ad

Matt Burgan's Phantom Draft

  • Thread starter Thread starter bloods01
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

bloods01

Club Legend
Joined
Sep 10, 2007
Posts
1,393
Reaction score
2
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Sydney
Matt Burgan's annual phantom draft has been released on the AFL website.

At pick 11 he has us selecting Alex Rance
Swan Districts, WA, Tall defender, October 9 1989, 192.3cm, 87.6kg

Rance is one of the most difficult players to place in the top echelon, as he is highly rated by all clubs from No.5-13 including the Swans. It won't surprise where he is chosen, but any later than West Coast (No.13) would raise an eyebrow. Jack Grimes, who is similarly rated to Rance, is also a strong tip for No.11. Lachlan Henderson, Ben McEvoy and Patrick Dangerfield could come into play, and don't be surprised if Tony Notte, Tayte Pears, Andy Otten or Brendan Whitecross bolts here.

Bio: Strong, hard running tall defender noted for his dash off the backline. His father Murray played 97 matches with the Western Bulldogs and West Coast from 1986-1990. Alex was a leading player in rebound 50s with Western Australia, averaging 17 possessions at the 2007 NAB AFL U18 Championships, earning him All-Australian honours.

At pick 26 he has us selecting Andy Otten
Oakleigh Chargers, VIC, Tall forward, May 15 1989, 191cm, 88.8kg

Otten has continued to firm as a top 30 selection and could even be a first-round selection. Don't rule out the Sydney Swans at No.11, as they rate him highly. This will be the Swans last “live” pick, as Craig Bird (No.59) has already been claimed through the NSW scholarship program. Others in the mix at No.26, depending on availability, include Harry Taylor, Callan Ward, Steven Gaertner, Jarrhan Jacky, Marlon Motlop and Chris Mayne. One recruiter believes Otten is similar to Collingwood's Scott Pendlebury.

Bio: A prolific ball winner, he averaged more than 26 possessions and six marks per game with the Oakleigh Chargers in 2007 and capped off an outstanding season by taking out the best and fairest award and TAC Cup Team of the Year honours. He recorded strong results at the 2007 NAB AFL Draft Camp, ranking in the top 2 per cent for the vertical leap (92cm) and the top 20 per cent for the beep test (14.2).

And Craig Bird has alreay been penciled in at 59
Nelson Bay, NSW, Small midfielder, January 21 1989, 178cm, 76kg

For the first time, two New South Wales scholarship holders have been claimed in a draft meeting – Bird and Adelaide's Taylor Walker (No.75). Bird was pre-listed by Sydney with its third and final choice in October. This time last year he was right in the mix to be chosen as a bottom age pick, but instead was overlooked and subsequently snapped up under the new scholarship program, introduced in 2006. He has been the standout player in New South Wales for the past two years.

Bio: Small ball-winning midfielder who had outstanding 2007 NAB AFL U18 Championships, winning the Harrison Medal (Div 2 B & F) and back-to-back All-Australian honours. He also captained NSW/ACT to Div 2 title and accumulated 85 disposals (third most overall) at an average of 28 per match. Also won Alan McLean Medal in 2005 NAB AFL U16 Championships (Div 2 B & F). Graduate of the AIS/AFL Academy.

http://www.afl.com.au/Default.aspx?tabid=208&newsId=53455
 
i think we'd go for talent with the first rounder, and then a tall with the #26.

i'm not complaining, i'd love to see Rance at Sydney

..or Vezpremi or Gourdis or...

TWO DAYS!
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I would have thought that most would expect us to draft tall, however according to Roos "..On who the Swans are hoping to snare on Saturday, Roos said the club was seeking to add some speed to their rather workmanlike midfield." :confused:

http://www.afl.com.au/Season2007/News/NewsArticle/tabid/208/Default.aspx?newsId=53477

That suprises me. Surely our need for height in key positions outweighs our need for pace in the midfield. Reading between the lines it looks like we will select one tall and one pacey midfielder tomorrow. I would be happy with that.
 
That suprises me. Surely our need for height in key positions outweighs our need for pace in the midfield. Reading between the lines it looks like we will select one tall and one pacey midfielder tomorrow. I would be happy with that.

Exactly, and didn't we draft the likes of Moore and O'Keefe to fill that need? I would be extremely disappointed if we didn't use our first round pick on a tall. They always like us to buy the theory that midfielders should be drafted early since KP prospects are much harder to judge in terms of how they are going to turn out.

But the fact is that all the early picks we spend on drafting small/mediums: - Fosdike, Bolton, Crouch, Willougby, O'Keefe (I'll add him in for now) are not exactly great successes either.

The trend that our late picks/rookie list players seemed to have developed into better players than our early picks may suggest that this strategy isn't working. The fact is that LRT is the only KPP that have hold down a senior spot, that we nutured - and that's really something we should try to fix.
 
Exactly, and didn't we draft the likes of Moore and O'Keefe to fill that need? I would be extremely disappointed if we didn't use our first round pick on a tall. They always like us to buy the theory that midfielders should be drafted early since KP prospects are much harder to judge in terms of how they are going to turn out.

But the fact is that all the early picks we spend on drafting small/mediums: - Fosdike, Bolton, Crouch, Willougby, O'Keefe (I'll add him in for now) are not exactly great successes either.

The trend that our late picks/rookie list players seemed to have developed into better players than our early picks may suggest that this strategy isn't working. The fact is that LRT is the only KPP that have hold down a senior spot, that we nutured - and that's really something we should try to fix.

including the likes of malch being moved closer to the ball, and with dan o'keefe coming through, the signing of mattner, and a few others in the seconds, i'd have thought we had that midfield pace thing reasonably covered if the coaches would take the punt and GIVE THEM A GO

we surely need some height, certainly in defence, as a deposit on the future
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom