McMahon on Carr

[cussernaut]

Anyone see andy Maher on 10? What a d...head.
Nothing wrong with the tackle, why do media have to crap on about duty of care and bla bla bla.

 

[drewie_rama]

i just flicked over, have been watching the dogs game
please please dont tell me he thinks that mcmahon should be cited?
was a perfect tackle? arms pinned, unfortunate his head hit the ground

 

[cussernaut]

i just flicked over, have been watching the dogs game
please please dont tell me he thinks that mcmahon should be cited?
was a perfect tackle? arms pinned, unfortunate his head hit the ground

yeah chrisso was more 'theyll have a look at it" whereas maher implied he should be cited. Nothing wrong with the tackle

 

[GoBackToVFL]

carr-ma.... thug got what he deserved.

maher is a tool, always trying do put players away. nothing in it.

 

[drewie_rama]

yeah chrisso was more 'theyll have a look at it" whereas maher implied he should be cited. Nothing wrong with the tackle

if he goes for that
our game is finished
****ing perfect tackle...i could argue for hours
sigh..what is it coming too

 

[Truck Rutten]

At half time in the Crows vs Roos game when they were talking about the incident, I thought they must have been showing the wrong footage. Looked like a great tackle. Bad luck that Carr got injured, but that's footy.

 

[pjcrows]

Maher is a first-class tool when it comes to his attempts at "calling" for possible video suspensions.

 

[SBI]

I thought he did Freo a favour. Carr has been shite all season.

 

[Slamin]

Great tackle.

At half time of the Crows game when they mentioned it I thought it was something filthy.

As I said great tackle.

 

[legitimatic]

carr-ma.... thug got what he deserved.

maher is a tool, always trying do put players away. nothing in it.

What the **** are you on about?

 

[mr_cellotape]

Maher would have a point if McMahon had slung Carr into the turf. But he didn't. He just wrapped him up and his momentum carried them to ground. Perfect tackle.

 

[pazza]

Andy Maher has taken over from Garry Lyon when it comes to potential reports. Anyone who remembers Lyon's work from the Sunday Footy Show would know about how many blokes he fitted up.

It should have been called holding the ball (was it?)

 

[nooB]

One of the greatest tackles ever, was a like a bulldog all over Carr, downside was the guy being injured in the process but yeh, perfect tackle

 

[Aussie Assault]

Same as Byron's on Kane. It'll get tossed out. The game is turning to shit when they are even thinking about citing someone for that. Its the perfect tackle and how we're taught as juniors.

 

[Johnson#26]

Free kick, free to play next round, I'd hope. Great, strong tackle.

 

[Rob]

Black got reported for something similar. Without the impact.

Not that it should be mind you.

 

[Benno From Berwick]

Black got reported for something similar. Without the impact.

Not that it should be mind you.

Hello Rob.

Thank god for hand outs......

 

[mark west]

this is why people r turning off footy! so dissapointing to think we have issues with things that r just part of the game.carr brothers will learn from this.........never get to the ball first, as it makes it difficult to snipe........

 

[Freo Big Fella]

Maher is a peanut, great tackle with an awkward landing is all it was.

 

[Hap Hapablap]

mcmahon wont be cited. legal tackle just an unfortunate incident thats all.