Most impressive?

[DeadlyAkkuret]

I will. The people who recruited **** aren't the people who recruited Cummings. Nor J. Cloke actually. Travis Cloke is going to be a very good player.

Goodo.

Wow, 1 out of 3, i'd call that luck, not good recruiting. You must know an awful lot about Collingwood if you know who their recruiting team is, and when they started at Collingwood. I think you're trying to appear as though you know what you're talking about, but i guess i could be wrong.

 

[HighReeve]

So because I corrected information you got wrong, I must be 'appearing as though i know what i'm talking about'. Riiight.

You could actually say that it was unlucky that the game changed to become more pace based (J. Cloke's weakness). You could also say it was unlucky that he was trying to get a game in a very good back line.

You could also say it was unlucky Cam Cloke got injured so often. You could also say it unlucky he grew too tall to play as a KP forward or back, and not quite tall enough to be a good tap ruckman.

How about Sydney's recruiting. Josh Willoughby. First round pick, delisted and now playing in the SANFL. Does that make Sydney's recruiting bad?

Maybe Josh had some back luck too.

It doesn't really matter, Collingwoods recruiting team spots are professionals. You aren't. Your trying to write off a first year player as a "dud" before he's played a senior game, yet are willing to give Vogels "more time" in his third year.