Most over rated player

[HawksForever]

Curious on who the football world think is the most over-rated player going around at the moment? I know Daniel Kerr may be a harsh one, but i just don't think he can cut it without his good mates Juddy and Cousins around. Remember how high he is regarded and his output in last 2 years (taking into consideration injuries last year also). Feel free to post any other nominees.

 

[Ron]

How is Luke Hodge not in this poll? He would win it by a street.

 

[a_fighting_fury]

Yup, Luke Hodge

 

[Kaladin Stormblessed]

Hodge.

 

[half_back_flank]

fatty.....i mean Hodge

 

[Fitz roos]

Cox by far

 

[Main Man]

The flogs suggesting Hodge are just showing their lack of football knowledge! What else should I suspect from fat flogs that sit behind their keyboards all day!

 

[Big Nasty]

The flogs suggesting Hodge are just showing their lack of football knowledge! What else should I suspect from fat flogs that sit behind their keyboards all day!

The truth hurts.

 

[Damon_3388]

Without turning it into a big argument, I'd like to know just who is rating Dale Thomas so highly that he can be classed as 'overated'? I do realise he is in the media a lot, but that has nothing to do with his football ability. He obviously has a good manager who sees marketing or media opportunities for him, and lines them up for him. Without sounding too biased as a Collingwood supporter, I think he's a pretty good young player who has a bright future. He might not have quite kicked on as expected, but he's definitely got time on his side. I think people forget just how young he still is (not even 22 yet), because he's been in the senior side at Collingwood from the word go, and didn't do one or two years in the VFL, keeping his spot on the list on 'potential'. He was in there, playing pretty well, from the word go, and it's a credit to him considering how skinny he was when he debuted in 2006.

 

[Andy_Mac]

Well I'm a flog too!

Hodge is a monty for this award.

Common even as Hawthorn supporters if you’re putting Kerr on the list Fat boy has to at least get a run! god knows he needs it

I also rate that Col Sylvia is even on anyone other than the vic police radar!

 

[thebigboy]

How does Thornton get in there?

Who out there rates him that highly anyway?

 

[tigers_of_old_08]

Hodge, and how convenient he was left out by the OP - a hawkers supporter

 

[Headless]

If I had a dollar for every biased Hawthorn supporter in this thread, I would have $2.

Luke Hodge.

NOTE: I don't actually think Hodge, just wanted to jump on board the train. I'd probably say Josh Fraser. Well actually, that's just because I don't like him. =]

 

[Demonheart]

I don't really understand why Sylvia is in this poll, not even Melbourne fans rate him anymore

 

[00Stinger]

Who ever said Hodge has no clue. the guys a gun hes just been struggling this year with injuries.
Thomas wins hands down.
End thread......

 

[TheOldThreads]

Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge Hodge

 

[SwampCreature]

Luke Hodge is the most overrated player in the AFL.

 

[Carlton_Blues]

Hodge.

Second that, Hodge!

 

[Big Nasty]

Voted Thomas only cause Hodge isn't on the list.

 

[Jatz]

hard to split thomas and hodge

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

On that list: Daisy
Overall: Hodge

 

[crawf_legend]

Dale Thomas.

Luke Hodge is underated if anything. He might not be getting 40+ disposals every game but hell, without his knowledge, Hawthorn would be struggling. And the way he commands the field in the defence especially is outstanding. You all hate him because hes a great player.

 

[Karl Pilkington]

Who ever said Hodge has no clue. the guys a gun hes just been struggling this year with injuries.
Thomas wins hands down.
End thread......

Perfectly said.

Hodge is a great player who is struggling with injury right now.

No idea why Sylvia is on the list, Melbourne fans don't even rate him. Aaron Davey would be a way better choice.

 

[Muji]

Hodge!

 

[Karl Pilkington]

Is the polls board just part of Bay 13 or what? Hodge is a bonafide gun. You people are seriously well, there's a word that starts with "r" that I can't use to describe people anymore, but it rhymes with wee-****, if you think Hodge is anything other than a gun.