Most Underrated Players

[bruce29]

McVeigh IMO anyone else you can think of?

 

[David_Hilley#19]

David Hille, without him we normally struggle.

 

[monty1104]

For Essendon or league wide?

If it is league wide, then J.McDonald, Robert Harvey and Simon Black definitly spring to mind.

I know Harvs and Black have both won Brownlows, but they just never get put into the same category as Hird, Voss, Judd etc.

And JMAC has been so good for Melbourne, even this year while they struggled, but he doesnt get the accolades that Bruce, Green and McLean all manage to get.

 

[monty1104]

Hille and McVeigh are very underrated for us. You could also chuck NLM in there. People still query his ability, but he always makes a difference when he plays.

 

[bruce29]

For Essendon or league wide?

If it is league wide, then J.McDonald, Robert Harvey and Simon Black definitly spring to mind.

I know Harvs and Black have both won Brownlows, but they just never get put into the same category as Hird, Voss, Judd etc.

And JMAC has been so good for Melbourne, even this year while they struggled, but he doesnt get the accolades that Bruce, Green and McLean all manage to get.

Preferably Essendon, but if you really believe someone elsewhere in the league!

 

[monty1104]

Well you've got my answers either way. We're all happy

 

[bruce29]

Much appreciated!!

 

[Shane Hird]

Danny Chartres

 

[bruce29]

Danny Chartres

Who? Essendon or other? Any details on hime?

 

[Shane Hird]

Who? Essendon or other? Any details on hime?

Essendon rookie listed player.

from Peel Thunder WA.

 

[hulld]

danny is one of nobby's favourites

with good reason i must add

 

[Jono B]

Most of the list below the age of 27 by the general footballing public.

 

[~RFM~]

Monfries, Stanton, Winderlich...I could go on...

 

[wasupwidat]

henry slattery

 

[stander]

Monfries, Stanton, Winderlich...I could go on...

Sorry pal- Monfries is overrated at the moment.

 

[donvito]

Allan Ezard

 

[Daytripper]

Damien Peverill by the length of the Flemington straight.

 

[Boris_Bewick]

Sorry pal- Monfries is overrated at the moment.

How? No one is saying he is dominating at the moment, or even playing that well. When he has had a good game, he gets the credit. But most people here are disappointed with his year so far.

I think he is rated just right.

 

[billylid]

Sorry pal- Monfries is overrated at the moment.

Underrated
Nash , Mcveigh, adn Jobe Watson

overrated - McPhee if he stop worrying about trying to look good and just played footy would be a gun gets enough of it

 

[kinna]

andrew welsh he is so underated

 

[Margim]

andrew welsh he is so underated

Agreed.

 

[Longy413]

andrew welsh he is so underated

He's actually underrated in how underrated he is.

 

[Bombers 4 premiership]

David Hille is one of Essendon's most valuable players because we struggle without him.
He doesn't get enough credit.


And Mark McVeigh is a superstar and isn't given enough recognition
So he is underrated as well.

 

[rigby116]

jay nash by far...no one had heard of him last year and has flown under many others radars so far this year, will do plenty of damage in the run to finals

 

[Minglis]

How could Pev be underrated?

I swear a week does not go by where you can see him get visibly scared of getting a contested ball and back out of the contest.