NAb Cup vs Geelong: Squads

[ChrisL#12]

28 man squads for this week from AFL website.

ST KILDA v GEELONG
NAB Cup quarter final
Saturday, 3.40pm AEDT, Manuka Oval

Geelong
1 - Jason Davenport, 4 - Andrew Mackie, 5 - Travis Varcoe, 7 - Harry Taylor, 8 - Josh Hunt, 9 - James Kelly, 10 - Kane Tenace, 11 - Joel Corey, 12 - Trent West, 13 - Tom Lonergan, 14 - Joel Selwood, 15 - Ryan Gamble, 17 - Shannon Byrnes, 18 - Nathan Djerrkura, 21 - Cameron Mooney, 22 - Scott Simpson, 24 - Mark Blake, 26 - Tom Hawkins, 27 - Matthew Stokes, 28 - David Johnson, 32 - Brent Prismall, 33 - Max Rooke, 37 - Jeremy Laidler, 39 - Darren Milburn, 41 - Shane Mumford, 42 - Liam Bedford, 44 - Corey Enright, 45 - Cameron Ling.

St Kilda
1 - Jason Gram, 3 - Xavier Clarke, 6 - Leigh Fisher, 8 - Max Hudghton, 9 - Fraser Gehrig, 10 - Steven Baker, 11 - Leigh Montagna, 15 - Michael Gardiner, 17 - Aaron Fiora, 19 - Sam Gilbert, 20 - David Armitage, 22 - Shane Birss, 23 - Justin Koschitzke, 25 - Sam Fisher, 26 - Nick Dal Santo, 27 - Jason Blake, 28 - Charlie Gardiner, 29 - Michael Rix, 30 - Brad Howard, 32 - Andrew McQualter, 34 - Jack Steven, 36 - Jarryd Allen, 37 - Eljay Connors, 38 - Clint Jones, 39 - Luke Van Rheenen, 40 - Robert Eddy, 41 - Glenn Chivers, 42 - Jarryn Geary, 44 - Stephen Milne, 45 - Luke Miles.

 

[the_berger]

hopefully jones will have another good game

would he be in your best 22?

 

[sainter]

hopefully jones will have another good game

would he be in your best 22?

He receives a lot of criticism because of his poor disposal.

I was impressed with his form early last season and after returning from his broken collarbone failed to reproduce that kind of form.

I love his work ethic and I've got no doubt that's the reason why Lyon is such a fan. It remains to be seen whether he can force his way into the team and he'll need to take his opportunity during the pre-season games.

 

[goodie23]

hopefully jones will have another good game

would he be in your best 22?

Close call.

Lyon's obviously a fan, but with the likes of Schneider and C. Gardiner being picked up, and the elevation of Geary means (hopefully) there's less dead weight in our squad and there'll be tighter competition for spots this year. Should Robert Eddy be elevated at some point he might also provide further competition.

He's a week-to-week proposition depending on injuries and opposition, but right now no, he's not in my best 22. Of course that could change by season's end.

 

[35Harvs]

Article on realfooty suggesting M Gardiner might not play due to soreness, this could allow Van Reenan to play who I'd like to see a little more of

http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/ne...aths-with-rucks/2008/02/22/1203467388090.html

 

[Rough_Edges]

I doubt Gardiner will play going from everything i am hearing.

 

[foxy_dal]

Gardiner and x clarke out according to sen