Next week's Jesse W. Smith thread

[blaisee]

dont know who to trade smith for

have

Bowden
Adcock
Mcphee
Kosi
Gilbee
Polak
Clarke

Ellis
Riggio

Clarke could get more time getting cheap kicks with goddard going down, Polak Kosi and Ellis have more to rise?

who to trade

I feel like maybe jumping the gun and trading polak, but I really dont want to!

 

[thebod]

dont know who to trade smith for

have

Bowden
Adcock
Mcphee
Kosi
Gilbee
Polak
Clarke

Ellis
Riggio

Clarke could get more time getting cheap kicks with goddard going down, Polak Kosi and Ellis have more to rise?

who to trade

I feel like maybe jumping the gun and trading polak, but I really dont want to!

Trade him for Riggio - not likely to play much, gives you solid backup as an emergency or alternative to your starting backs - also Ellis isn't a certainty to be named each week so you're covered there as well.

 

[Hodges]

Depends on how much money you have in the bank. If you dont have much, trade Polak for Smith. If you have a fair bit, trade Ellis for him.

 

[Mr.Jingles]

is it worth trading out adcock or kosi for jesse smith to free up 120-130k for an upgrade at another position? if so, which one?

my backline right now is very strong so could be worth it.
heath shaw, chad cornes, mcphee, milburn, goddard, bowden, adcock
(kosi, riggio)

GODDARD OUT FOR SEASON MATE.........!!!

 

[reedy619]

yer get rid of goddard 4 smithyyyy then upgrade to westyyyyyy

 

[footyfan_25]

I'm considering taking a big risk and doing the following trade:

IN: SMITH
OUT: C.BOLTON

Smith would then be in my starting 22 and would free u alot of cash.

C. Bolton had a good first coupe of rounds, but has only been averaging about 60 since in S.C. Therefore i'm sure Smith can at least match this and would free me up some cash.

Big risk starting SMITH, but who knows, might pay off.

 

[SouthPHXBombers]

Had smith in my team 2 yrs back and wanted to get on him this yr... but the ankle was a worry...

My backline consists of:

McLeod
McPhee
Cornes
Bowden
Kosi
Jacobs
Milburn

Ellis
Everitt

I also have Wells so that is a forced trade...

Im thinkin

Cap: 32k
IN: Goodwin, JWS
OUT: Wells, Ellis

What do you guys suggest?

 

[Benno_900]

I'm considering taking a big risk and doing the following trade:

IN: SMITH
OUT: C.BOLTON

Smith would then be in my starting 22 and would free u alot of cash.

C. Bolton had a good first coupe of rounds, but has only been averaging about 60 since in S.C. Therefore i'm sure Smith can at least match this and would free me up some cash.

Big risk starting SMITH, but who knows, might pay off.

Not a risk, Bolton is not a DTer.

 

[sante]

OUT: Maxwell
IN: Smith

 

[Hawkmad]

Not sure which way to go. 10 trades left & $107k in bank.

Out Brennan In J. Smith (9 trades left & $281k in bank) or
Out Tyler In Smith & have 2 playing people on the bench (9 trades left & $93k in bank)

 

[jbomb3000]

i jumped on the bandwagon this morning

ended up trading ellis for him

Good to see some people still continue to trade early in the week despite the Petterd situation from last week showing perfectly why you shouldn't

 

[footyfan_25]

Not sure which way to go. 10 trades left & $107k in bank.

Out Brennan In J. Smith (9 trades left & $281k in bank) or
Out Tyler In Smith & have 2 playing people on the bench (9 trades left & $93k in bank)

Option 1. Free up the cash and you still have a playing option on the bench.

 

[Ray Ball]

In goodwin, smith
out gibbs, goddard

Is smith good enough to start? if not, i dont really want to make this trade just to end up trading him again later on....effectively using a trade to make 100k+. Is a trade worth making 100k?

 

[Butane]

That really is the question isn't it. Is Smith good enough to start on the field?

 

[Ray Ball]

how was he playing in VFL?