No Polak

[#1 Tigers Fan]

Why are Richmond considering going for Polak. The guy has pertential but i would much rather see richmond draft a good CHB in the "Super Draft" and have thusfeild at FB. I don't think Polak has enough pertential for Richmond to give up anyone that we wern't going to delist anyway. If we were going to trade someone like Rodan, Roach or someone like that it would be fine, but to trade someone that is in our starting line-up aint worth it.

Thoughts?

 

[strauchy]

Why are Richmond considering going for Polak. The guy has pertential but i would much rather see richmond draft a good CHB in the "Super Draft" and have thusfeild at FB. I don't think Polak has enough pertential for Richmond to give up anyone that we wern't going to delist anyway. If we were going to trade someone like Rodan, Roach or someone like that it would be fine, but to trade someone that is in our starting line-up aint worth it.

Thoughts?

great post mate! but i dont think thursfield will be the anser 4 our backline which means we will strugle again next yr coz of the backline. only time will bring us into a good side,, lets just draft a key backman 4 once!

 

[Bentleigh]

Thoughts?

We have FA all KPPs aged 20-25 and even less with alot of talent. Paddy Bowden was a good pick up but we need a Polak type to strengthen this area. More so with Richos not having too many years left, AK getting the ass, Stafford hanging up the boots and Gaspar old, average and injury prone.

Polak is young, has alot of potential, was rated as the #4 player in the 'best draft ever' and is a great size and comming into his prime. Very stronh contested mark.

Would be what the doctered ordered.

I'd love us to get him.

He won't come cheap - but I think it'd be a good gamble.

Polak >>> Aka

 

[brown_2000au]

Personally i would rather make a play at Brett Thornton from Carlton. He seems to be by far the safer option. He is consistent and acountable and i feel he and Will Thursfield would complement each other nicely.

 

[Richo Rules]

i would of liked polak at the club but now that thornton is available i would prefer him

unfortunately i believe miller as already had dealings with freo regarding polak but maybe they should make a play for both and mal michael

we would have a pretty good backline then

B- Gasper - Michael - Raines
HB- Thornton - Polak - Bowden

we can dream cant we

 

[Tambo]

Thoughts?


We have 100 other threads on this topic, you could have posted it in there

 

[Darth_Tiger]

lets make another polak thread and discuss it in there.