Remove this Banner Ad

News NWM stays at Saints (Will Faulkner wrong about being crows bound)

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well it was all very well played by Williams. I'd say Nas has always been prepared to stay there and Williams has got him an extra 1 million per year from St Kilda's first offer. Good for them.

Hope your other players do the same.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

No biggie, we have had plenty of good players come here, just can’t be utilised due to poor coaching, gameplan and no winning culture. Let’s fix those first.
 
2.5 million for a guy that got moved out of the midfield against Essendon and he wasn't even being tagged..

Extremely disgusting offer, and would probably destroy our club paying someone that much
 

Remove this Banner Ad

I'm not devestated by this. Would have been nice to nab him, but it's abig unknown with Carr coming in as an untried head coach. You have to have your game breeakers but is NWM winning St kilda a Premiership? We've had Butters, Rozee and JHF as phenomenal individual talents and not been able to get us over the line. We need to uplift our average. Our top end has stagnated over the last 2 months and some of our second tier talent have gone backwards. Ken was never able to solve our forward issues, so for me, that's Carr's biggest challenge. Sinking so much captial into a single player when we have no idea what the effect of a new coach will be on the group is a gameble we don't nessesarily need to make at this time. Had we had Carr coaching this season we'd at least have some idea what kind of hit, poitive or negative we would be getting and could make a better assessment of where our list is actually at.
 
We’ll come knocking again in two years, hopefully Carr will have the Club in a better position by then. It’s great news for the Saints, but two years tells me he’s keeping an open mind & hasn’t completely closed the door on a future move back home.
 
Last edited:

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I'm ok with this, we were always going to pay overs, I wasn't ok with that for position not of great need.

I'd much rather use the resources on backs and forwards.

If he is ready to move in 2 years time, we do it then as we will know our midfield situation better by then.
 
The funniest thing in all this, who was the master troll who got all the media outlets onboard in the last 24h that he was crows bound only for it to emphatically fall over less than a day later?

Lol someone was telling intentional porkies.
 
The funniest thing in all this, who was the master troll who got all the media outlets onboard in the last 24h that he was crows bound only for it to emphatically fall over less than a day later?

Lol someone was telling intentional porkies.
Chewy did say that it was coming out of West Lakes and was unreliable info.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top