Our best 22, 2009

[NathanMurray]

B: Morris Lake Hargrave
HB: Callan Williams Gilbee
C: Higgins Cross Addison
HF: Hahn Murphy Hill
FF: Grant Minson Johnson
F: Hudson Griffen Cooney

Int: Everrit Giansuracusa Ward Boyd

Emg: Ried Cordy Tiller

Going Going: Welsh, Stack Lynch

Also think Johnson Not in our best 22 but of course his going to be in there..
Obviously theres guys like Harbrow whos unlucky but his not really a consistent player and many others but who will play but its hard to pick a 22..
Your thoughts??

 

[Dogs4tilltheend]

yer good thread. um Tillers unlucky to miss out but i reckon Tom Hawkins would fit in nice there but out half backline does look a bit slow without Ray

 

[slapper]

B Callan Lake Morris
HB Hargreave Williams Gilbee
C Giansiracusa Boyd Cross
HF Aker Murphy Hahn
F Higgins Minson Johnson
R Hudson Cooney Griffen

Inter. Tiller, Hill, Ward, Addison

Emg. Everitt, Welsh, Eagleton

Very hard task when you assume all players are fit and healthy.

 

[.M a t t.]

yer good thread. um Tillers unlucky to miss out but i reckon Tom Hawkins would fit in nice there but out half backline does look a bit slow without Ray

Since when did Ray play backline?

 

[Bulldogs_6]

Did we pick Hugh Minson up out of retirement and put him on the bench? Or is the size of Will filling out 2 positions?
Rofl I can't believe a newbie from October 2008 is here!

 

[a_mac]

Obviously theres guys like Harbrow whos unlucky but his not really a consistent player and many others but who will play but its hard to pick a 22..
Your thoughts??

LOL, Harbrow showed during finals that he will be in our best 22.

 

[Dogs4tilltheend]

Since when did Ray play backline?

Half back use to play there with griffen.

 

[NathanMurray]

LOL, Harbrow showed during finals that he will be in our best 22.

Yer maybe when he could chase guys and get the ball given to him, but he loses his feet under pressure and still is a bit light..Id be happy to see that Jarrad Grants in the side over him,, not saying at all Harbrows a bad player just he needs to learn to work harder.

 

[doggies ftw]

get back Andrejes then and griffin can always play back there again

 

[a_mac]

Yer maybe when he could chase guys and get the ball given to him, but he loses his feet under pressure and still is a bit light..Id be happy to see that Jarrad Grants in the side over him,, not saying at all Harbrows a bad player just he needs to learn to work harder.

Joke of a post, talking about working harder & you have Hill in the team.

Harbrow works harder then most players in our team.

 

[LardDog]

Didn't we just do this a few weeks ago?

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=496782

 

[Pigdog]

Yer maybe when he could chase guys and get the ball given to him, but he loses his feet under pressure and still is a bit light..Id be happy to see that Jarrad Grants in the side over him,, not saying at all Harbrows a bad player just he needs to learn to work harder.

Stupid post here Nathan.

Harbrow is almost our hardest worker so to post otherwise is just plain silly.

 

[smilingassassin6]

doubt very highly welsh would b struggling for a spot next year if we dont recruit a key forward which we probably wont.

 

[jake17]

Harbrow should be in instead of Everitt and Boyd should be on the field. Everitt is sh1t

 

[Dogs4tilltheend]

Harbrow is almost our hardest worker so to post otherwise is just plain silly.

Ive been to every dogs game in vic this year and Harbrow is flashy, just coz u see him get guys holdin the ball doesnt mean his the hardest worker but he is good to have for forward libne pressure.
and would be happy to see Grant in the 22 over Welsh

 

[Butane]

Everitt is sh1t

Bookmarked.

And that's not how you spell shit.

 

[jake17]

Bookmarked???
I just thought that Everitt wasn't consistent throughout the season and Harbrow's offensive pressure was beneficial and helped us win games

 

[a_mac]

Bookmarked???
I just thought that Everitt wasn't consistent throughout the season and Harbrow's offensive pressure was beneficial and helped us win games

Everitt had a lot of interuptions during pre season & season proper, him and Williams were out for most of the first half of the year from memory.

 

[X_box_X]

OP didn't have Gian or Aker in the best side. Surely a mistake.

 

[jeemak]

B: Morris Lake Hargrave
HB: Callan Williams Gilbee
C: Higgins Cross Addison
HF: Hahn Murphy Hill
FF: Grant Minson Johnson
F: Hudson Griffen Cooney

Int: Everrit Minson Ward Boyd

Emg: Ried Cordy Tiller

Going Going: Welsh, Stack Lynch

Also think Johnson Not in our best 22 but of course his going to be in there..
Obviously theres guys like Harbrow whos unlucky but his not really a consistent player and many others but who will play but its hard to pick a 22..
Your thoughts??

What has Gia done to be omitted from the starting 22? He had a fantastic year, as did Aker apart from five games towards the end of the season. Did you leave them out because you think they will be traded by the club? Has Minson impressed you so much that you think he should be named twice?

Callan Ward did a good job in the games he played as a first year player, but to put him in the team ahead of Harbrow is I think a bit over the top.

 

[Code_Nerd]

Leaving Aker and Gia out is a joke, wake up to yourself!

 

[jeemak]

And to say that you think Johnson shouldn't be in our best 22 after kicking 50 goals this year and averaging the possessions and goal assists that he did shows a certain level of understanding of the game.

 

[NathanMurray]

And to say that you think Johnson shouldn't be in our best 22 after kicking 50 goals this year and averaging the possessions and goal assists that he did shows a certain level of understanding of the game.

Yer his a legend I agree, but he wont go much longer coz his just not that big and if were going to be hard on westy we have to be on Brad,his been solid but we just need a big forwrd. his still got another year in him but he wont be playing in 2010 ..

 

[jeemak]

Yer his a legend I agree, but he wont go much longer coz his just not that big and if were going to be hard on westy we have to be on Brad,his been solid but we just need a big forwrd. his still got another year in him but he wont be playing in 2010 ..

Alright, when you pull a KPF out of your jaxie and have him play in the best 22 kicking 50 goals a year we'll talk about not playing Johnno.

 

[NathanMurray]

look every club has had to do it. If we want a tilt at the premiership in the next 3 years we have to blood Guys like Jarrad Grant and Callan Ward.. and let Scott welsh and brad Johnson start moving to the side.. If Johnson was a bit taller he could go down back like Grant did (Chris).. but we have to change our forward line now and not keep waiting until we get a freack draft pick!