Toast Our defence

[TheDyerLegacy]

the thing with chaplin is that he is just horrible one on one, but i rate him as a third man in, he needs to do the nick maxwell role. and get astbury back to that form last yr

I cannot stand Chaplin in the side.. everything he does wrong I see it to be 10 times worse cause I dislike him that much.. although I feel that is a fantastic comparison..

He is our Nick Maxwell.. Horrible 1 on 1 but he does read the play fairly well and provide somewhat of a chopout.. and without being within the 'four walls' I guess his 'leadership' is highly regarded and 'needed'.

 

[jc12]

I cannot stand Chaplin in the side.. everything he does wrong I see it to be 10 times worse cause I dislike him that much.. although I feel that is a fantastic comparison..

He is our Nick Maxwell.. Horrible 1 on 1 but he does read the play fairly well and provide somewhat of a chopout.. and without being within the 'four walls' I guess his 'leadership' is highly regarded and 'needed'.

He probably is a good leader . But remember Nick Maxwell played the role well , I don't get why there was so much hate when he led the team to a flag . Chappy just needs to play third man up , he's a better kick than Maxwell too so he can set up attacks .

 

[TheTigerArmy]

I cannot stand Chaplin in the side.. everything he does wrong I see it to be 10 times worse cause I dislike him that much.. although I feel that is a fantastic comparison..

He is our Nick Maxwell.. Horrible 1 on 1 but he does read the play fairly well and provide somewhat of a chopout.. and without being within the 'four walls' I guess his 'leadership' is highly regarded and 'needed'.

Dont Agree..our dfence is weaker when he is out of side..

 

[TiggerMan22]

Weakest link is Chaplin , I really cant see any value in this bloke

Love to replace him with a 190 cm super quick half back flanker with silky skills (dyson Heppell like but faster)

As they said after the game, Chaplin organizes our backline, he makes every defender play better and makes our structure a lot better. Theres a reason Rance and others always look worse with Chaplin out.

 

[TheDyerLegacy]

Dont Agree..our dfence is weaker when he is out of side..

I think you took my post in the wrong way.. I agree our defence is better with him.. the reference to Nick Maxwell was signalling his importance to the side..
I don't like him as a footballer and he does make many mistakes but I feel we are a better side with him in there...

 

[TheTigerArmy]

I think you took my post in the wrong way.. I agree our defence is better with him.. the reference to Nick Maxwell was signalling his importance to the side..
I don't like him as a footballer and he does make many mistakes but I feel we are a better side with him in there...

Agree

 

[TheDyerLegacy]

He probably is a good leader . But remember Nick Maxwell played the role well , I don't get why there was so much hate when he led the team to a flag . Chappy just needs to play third man up , he's a better kick than Maxwell too so he can set up attacks .

Yeah I think a couple people have taken my post in the wrong way.. I intended to say his leadership is extremely valued within our team.. I feel Maxwell was a very important cog in the Magpie premiership side..