PieMan!'s 2014 Phanton Draft

[PieMan!]

Updated 15/11.

Round 1.

1. St Kilda Christian Petracca
2.Melbourne Angus Brayshaw
3. Melbourne Patrick McCartin
4.GWS Jarrod Pickett
5 Collingwood Jayden Laverde
6.GWS Jake Lever
7.GWS Peter Wright
8.Gold Coast Lachie Weller
9.Collingwood Darcy Moore - Father Son
10.Geelong Sam Durdin
11.West Coast Nakia Cockatoo
12.Richmond Corey Ellis
13.Fremantle Hugh Goddard
14.Adelaide Caleb Marchbank
15.Gold Coast Jordan De Goey
16.North Melbourne Liam Duggan
17.Essendon Connor Blakely
18.Sydney Isaac Heeney - Academy
19.Carlton Kyle Langford

End of Round 1

20.Essendon Jarrod Garlett
21.St Kilda Reece McKenzie

Round 2

22.St Kilda Tom Lamb
23GWS Connor Menadue
24GWS Jack Steele Academy
25North Melbourne Paul Ahearn
26Western Bulldogs Damien Cavka
27Western Bulldogs Brayden Maynand
28Carlton Alex Neal-Bullen
29Gold Coast Oscar McDonald
30Collingwood Dean Gore
31Hawthorn Peter Bampton
31West Coast Nathan Drummond
33Richmond Touk Miller
34Fremantle Matthew Hammelmann
35Adelaide Daniel McKenzie
36North Melbourne Jack Lonie
37Sydney Ed Longdon
38Sydney Jack Hiscox Academy
39Western Bulldogs Daniel Capiron
40Melbourne Dillon Viojo-Rainbow

Round 3

41St Kilda Keenan Ramsey
42Melbourne Billy Stretch - Father Son
43Adelaide Harrison Wigg
44Brisbane Liam Dawson - Academy
45Western Bulldogs Daniel Nielson
46Western Bulldogs Jack Redpath - Rookie Elevation (FWD)
47Geelong Aidan Anderson
48Collingwood Josh Glenn
49Hawthorn Caleb Daniel
50Hawthorn Dallas Willsmore - Rookie Elevation
51West Coast Jaden McGrath
52Richmond Matt Goodyear
53Melbourne Neville Jetta - Rookie Elevation
54Fremantle Sam Bevan
55Geelong Toby McLean
56North Melbourne Joel Tippett - Rookie Elevation
57Port Adelaide Tyler Keitel
58Sydney Sean McLaren
59Adelaide Lucas Webb

Round 4

60Geelong Oleg Markov
61Carlton Ed Vickers-Willis
62Essendon Patrick Ambrose - Rookie Elevation
63Brisbane Harris Andrews - Academy
64Western Bulldogs Zaine Cordy - Father Son
65Carlton Jack Lonie
66Gold Coast Teia Miles
67Brisbane Pass
68Hawthorn Zac Webster - Rookie Elevation
69West Coast Declan Hamilton
70Richmond Pass
71EssendonThomas Wilkinson
72Fremanlte Bailey Dale
73Geelong Pass
74North Melbourne Billy Gowers
75Port adelaide Francis Watson
76Sydney Pass
77HawthornPass

 

[Stylo]

Appreciate the effort but that's terrible for Richmond. We need mids desperately, particularly speedy ones, not utilities and KPPs. We'd likely take any of De Goey, Duggan or Ellis ahead of Langford and I can't see us taking a KPD at 33. Best available mid there too.

You've actually got Ramsay going twice too.

 

[james95]

So you don't think Corey Ellis will get drafted?

 

[PieMan!]

So you don't think Corey Ellis will get drafted?

Opps, sorry forgot about him haha, fixed now

 

[MightyDons4]

Duggan is listed as KPD/KPF, can't find Ellis or Menadue and Wilkinson is listed twice (40&61. I'd rather Menadue than Garlett and someone with fwd/mid ability rather than Blakely, other than that it looks good.

 

[12Chill]

Good effort. But Saints taking 3 KPPS? Don't see that happening (McKenzie/McDonald/Ramsey)...

 

[Hagla]

Opps, sorry forgot about him haha, fixed now

Do you really think Waylen Manson will be drafted this year mate? I'd be excited if we got him but I'm not sure if he'll ever make it. He gave up easily in the recruit but was also a loveable character and a good guy.

 

[borderbarry]

Cant see Paul Ahearn anywhere. Give him to the Saints at 21.

 

[PieMan!]

Duggan is listed as KPD/KPF, can't find Ellis or Menadue and Wilkinson is listed twice (40&61. I'd rather Menadue than Garlett and someone with fwd/mid ability rather than Blakely, other than that it looks good.

Thanks for that will fix up

and i find that blakely is very underated,avg 17 touches at 76% in the Champions and at the right club will be a star, i feel that Garlett adds some speed to your midfield and even more dangerous. Garlett is someone who will likely be placed wing/half foward and very able to kick 15 -20 goals.

Do you really think Waylen Manson will be drafted this year mate? I'd be excited if we got him but I'm not sure if he'll ever make it. He gave up easily in the recruit but was also a loveable character and a good guy.

I know that we were/are very into Waylen and i hope/think we should take the risk, and on the recrult he showed that even if he didnt want to a challenge that fought though it.

 

[PieMan!]

Good effort. But Saints taking 3 KPPS? Don't see that happening (McKenzie/McDonald/Ramsey)...

That is now changed, but with McKenzie and Ramsey. Both have huge ceiling, and if developed right you can really build your forward line around them after Riewoldt goes. and with your young and building midfield which i really rate. it's a good developing side

 

[PowerDrafter]

Good effort, I like how you've stuck to what you believed and not followed trend with a few things. Personally I really like Blakely at Freo and think all the hype around them needing key possi players is rubbish especially if they take Goddard as he will take 3-4 years to develop

 

[mattyc75]

got markov at 54 and 60

 

[wills doggies]

Hey all, This year i have watched nearly all TAC games and the champing game and studied them closely often read all the phanton drafts and i thought i would have a go at, i will not be putting a bio of the player up, because there is already many around, but will answer any questions about a certain player.





1. St Kilda Christian Petracca (MID)
2.Melbourne Angus Brayshaw (MID)
3. Melbourne Patrick McCartin (KPF)
4.GWS Jake Lever (KPD)
5 Collingwood Jayden Laverde (UTIL)
6.GWS Peter Wright (KPF/RUCK)
7.GWS Sam Durdin (KPD/KPF)
8.Gold Coast Lachie Weller (MID)
9.Collingwood Darcy Moore - Father Son (KPD/KPF)
10.Geelong Jarrod Pickett (MID/FWD)
11.West Coast Nakia Cockatoo (MID)
12.Richmond Corey Ellis (MID/FWD)
13.Fremantle Hugh Goddard (KPD)
14.Adelaide Caleb Marchbank(KPD)
15.Gold Coast Jordan De Goey(MID/FWD)
16.North Melbourne Liam Duggan (KPD/KPF)
17.Essendon Jarrod Garlett (MID/FWD)
18.Sydney Isaac Heeney - Academy (MID)
19.Carlton Kyle Langford (UTIL)
20.Essendon Connon Blakely (MID)
21.St Kilda Reece McKenzie (KPF)
22.St Kilda Paul Ahearn(MID/FWD)
23GWS Tom Lamb (FWD/MID)
24GWS Jack Steele Academy (MID/FWD)
25North Melbourne Brayden Maynard (UTIL)
26Western Bulldogs Daniel McKenzie(FWD)
27Western Bulldogs Touk Miller (MID)
28Carlton Alex Neal-Bullen(MID)
29Gold Coast Oscar McDonald(KPD)
30Collingwood Dean Gore (MID)
31Hawthorn Peter Bampton(MID)
31West Coast Nathan Drummond (MID/DEF)
33Richmond Taylor Grace (MID/FWD)
34Fremantle James Rose (FWD/DEF)
35Adelaide Daniel Capiron (DEF/MID)
36North Melbourne Matthew Hammelmann (KPF)
37Sydney Ed Longdon (FWD)
38Sydney Jack Hiscox Academy (UTIL)
39Western Bulldogs Harrison Wigg(MID/DEF)
40Melbourne Dillon Viojo-Rainbow(DEF)
41St Kilda Keenan Ramsey (KPF)
42Melbourne Billy Stretch - Father Son (MID/FWD)
43Adelaide Daniel Capiron(MID/DEF)
44Brisbane Liam Dawson - Academy (UTIL)
45Western Bulldogs Lin Jong- Rookie Elevation (MID/DEF)
46Western Bulldogs Jack Redpath - Rookie Elevation (FWD)
47Geelong Aidan Anderson (FWD/MID)
48Collingwood Waylen Manson (FWD)
49Hawthorn Caleb Daniel (MID)
50Hawthorn Dallas Willsmore - Rookie Elevation (MID/FWD)
51West Coast Jaden McGrath(MID/FWD)
52Richmond Matt Goodyear (MID)
53Melbourne Neville Jetta - Rookie Elevation (DEF)
54Fremantle Oleg Markov (FWD)
55Geelong Toby McLean (FWD)
56North Melbourne Joel Tippett - Rookie Elevation (DEF)
57Port Adelaide Josh Glenn
58Sydney Sean McLaren
59Adelaide Lucas Webb(FWD/DEF)
60Geelong Oleg Markov (FWD)
61Carlton Thomas Wilkinson
62Essendon Patrick Ambrose - Rookie Elevation (FWD)
63Brisbane Harris Andrews - Academy (KPF/KPD)
64Western Bulldogs Zaine Cordy - Father Son (KPD)
65Carlton Pass
66Gold Coast Teia Miles (MID)
67Brisbane Pass
68Hawthorn Zac Webster - Rookie Elevation
69West Coast Declan Hamilton
70Richmond Pass
71Geelong Mark Blicavs - Rookie Elevation (RUCK/FWD)
72North Melbourne Kayne Turner - Rookie Elevation (MID/FWD)
73Port Adelaide Pass
74Sydney Abaina Davis - Academy (MID/FWD)
75St Kilda Darren Minchington - Rookie Elevation
76Carlton Pass
77GWS Pass
78Brisbane Pass
79Gold Coast Pass
80Collingwood Jack Frost -Rookie Elevation
81Adelaide Charlie Cameron - Rookie Elevation
82West Coast Callum Sinclair - Rookie Elevation
83Richmond Pass
84Port Adelaide Pass
85Sydney Pass
86St Kilda Cameron Shenton - Rookie Elevation
87GWS Pass
88Brisbane Pass
89Carlton Pass
90Gold Coast Josh Hall - Rookie Elevation
91West Coast Alec Waterman - Father Son (MID/FWD)
92Richmond Anthony Miles - Rookie Elevation
93Port Adelaide Pass
94Sydney Xavier Richards - Rookie Elevation
95St Kilda Eli Templeton - Rookie Elevation
96GWS Jeremy Finlayson - Academy
97Brisbane Josh Clayton - Father Son (MID)
98Carlton Pass
99Gold Coast Andrew Boston - Rookie Elevation
100Port Adelaide Kane Mitchell - Rookie Elevation
101Sydney Jake Lloyd - Rookie Elevation
102St Kilda Maverick Weller - Rookie Elevation
103Sydney Daniel Robinson - Rookie Elevation

What are you talking about the bulldogs don't have to use pick 45 and 46 on Jong and redpath when the can use 82 100 and 118 I'm pretty sure. ??

 

[BoydOHboyd]

What are you talking about the bulldogs don't have to use pick 45 and 46 on Jong and redpath when the can use 82 100 and 118 I'm pretty sure. ??

Dogs are definitely using 45 (at least) in the draft, taking Hamling means we'll need another delisting to use 46 but I'd be disappointed if we didn't go with both, especially in a deep draft. 45/46 will be live most likely.

 

[BoydOHboyd]

got markov at 54 and 60

Capiron is in there twice, too.

 

[PieMan!]

What are you talking about the bulldogs don't have to use pick 45 and 46 on Jong and redpath when the can use 82 100 and 118 I'm pretty sure. ??

Dogs are definitely using 45 (at least) in the draft, taking Hamling means we'll need another delisting to use 46 but I'd be disappointed if we didn't go with both, especially in a deep draft. 45/46 will be live most likely.

Yes, you are correct and i have changed pick 45, but due to the dogs having to delist another player to use pick 46 i have left Redpath on pick 46 untill they have.

 

[scooter600x]

Can I swap Touk Miller for Jackson Nelson seeing as no-one else has him?

 

[RustySpike]

Duggan is listed as KPD/KPF, can't find Ellis or Menadue and Wilkinson is listed twice (40&61. I'd rather Menadue than Garlett and someone with fwd/mid ability rather than Blakely, other than that it looks good.

I love The look of Blakley for the Bombers. Tough inside mid that wins the ball. These are the sorts of players you can rely on in games. Agree that we need some outside speed and goal kicking ability from our other pick though. Maybe a Tom Lamb. What do you reckon?

 

[x_les_x]

Surely port won't just pick up glenn ken has said he wanted "two or three talls" sure a couple of these could be on the rookie list but surely we won't only use one pick, our recruiting team has found a gem extremely late a few times in the past I would back them to do it again even though we start so late in the draft. Maybe a pittonet, creeper, Frampton or tester type player

 

[MightyDons4]

Thanks for that will fix up

and i find that blakely is very underated,avg 17 touches at 76% in the Champions and at the right club will be a star, i feel that Garlett adds some speed to your midfield and even more dangerous. Garlett is someone who will likely be placed wing/half foward and very able to kick 15 -20 goals.

I feel like we have enough inside midfielders at the moment and should be focusing on outside pace and fwd/mid's. Garlett would be a good addition, but I feel like his potential is limited to being an outside runner only (Brad Hill/Lewis Jetta). However, Menadue at the very worst would become a decent outside runner. At the moment he's a twig, but over time I can see him turning into a Ryan Griffen'esque player judging by his clearance work, explosiveness and goal kicking ability. At 20 I can see us going for a Ahern/De Goey/McLean and even Langdon because we need another small/medium forward with good goal sense that can do a shift in the midfield to cover for Chappy's departure.

 

[MightyDons4]

I love The look of Blakley for the Bombers. Tough inside mid that wins the ball. These are the sorts of players you can rely on in games. Agree that we need some outside speed and goal kicking ability from our other pick though. Maybe a Tom Lamb. What do you reckon?

I'd much rather Menadue than Lamb, I just get the feeling he's going to dominate in a few years time. Lamb would be a good pickup, has a poor mans Goddard feel about him, not a fan of his forward line word and we already have enough rebounding defenders. As for Blakely, I definitely rate him highly however I don't feel like we need a pure inside mid and since he doesn't have much forward/defensive ability we would be better suited to a De Goey/Ahern/McLean/Duggan/Ellis.

 

[RustySpike]

I'd much rather Menadue than Lamb, I just get the feeling he's going to dominate in a few years time. Lamb would be a good pickup, has a poor mans Goddard feel about him, not a fan of his forward line word and we already have enough rebounding defenders. As for Blakely, I definitely rate him highly however I don't feel like we need a pure inside mid and since he doesn't have much forward/defensive ability we would be better suited to a De Goey/Ahern/McLean/Duggan/Ellis.

Fair enough. Suppose some breakaway speed is definitely needed.

 

[94_Eagles]

Is it Connon or Connor Blakely?

 

[PieMan!]

Is it Connon or Connor Blakely?

connor Blakely

 

[PieMan!]

Surely port won't just pick up glenn ken has said he wanted "two or three talls" sure a couple of these could be on the rookie list but surely we won't only use one pick, our recruiting team has found a gem extremely late a few times in the past I would back them to do it again even though we start so late in the draft. Maybe a pittonet, creeper, Frampton or tester type player

The only thing is that at your pick 57 there isnt much players left, but there is always a gem left till late so you never know