Player Ratings Weeks 1 - 7

[Kildonan]

w1 w2 w3 w4 w5 w6 w7[b] Player[/B]
[COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="Green"]GD[/COLOR] Lenny Hayes
[COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] FR Leigh Montagna
[COLOR="blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] FR [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] Nick Dal Santo
[COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="Green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] Sam Fisher
[COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] FR [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] Luke Ball
[COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] -- Max Hudghton
[B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B] [COLOR="blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Green"]GD[/COLOR] Brendon Goddard
[COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] -- -- Steven King
[COLOR="blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] FR Nick Riewoldt
[B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Green"]GD[/COLOR] Shane Birss
[COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] FR [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] Robert Harvey
FR [COLOR="Red"]PR[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Green"]GD[/COLOR] Justin Koschitzke
[COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] FR [COLOR="Green"]GD[/COLOR] Charlie Gardiner
FR [COLOR="blue"]VG[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] FR FR [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] FR Jason Gram
FR FR [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B] [COLOR="Green"]GD[/COLOR] Raphael Clarke
[B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] FR Steven Baker
[COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="blue"]VG[/COLOR] FR [COLOR="Red"]PR[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] FR FR Xavier Clarke
[B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] FR FR David Armitage
[B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] FR FR Sean Dempster
FR [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B] FR Adam Schneider
FR [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] FR FR [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Red"]PR[/COLOR] [COLOR="Blue"]VG[/COLOR] Stephen Milne
[COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] FR [COLOR="Red"]PR[/COLOR] [B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B] -- Jarryn Geary
[COLOR="Green"]GD[/COLOR] FR [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] FR -- -- Sam Gilbert
[COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] FR FR [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Red"]PR[/COLOR] -- Leigh Fisher
[COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B] [COLOR="Red"]PR[/COLOR] Michael Gardiner
[B]--[/B] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] FR FR FR FR -- Jason Blake
FR [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Red"]PR[/COLOR] [B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B] -- Aaron Fiora
[B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B] FR -- Michael Rix
[B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B] [B]--[/B] FR FR [COLOR="Red"]PR[/COLOR] FR Matt Maguire
[B]--[/B] [COLOR="Green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Red"]PR[/COLOR] FR [B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B] [COLOR="Red"]PR[/COLOR] Fraser Gehrig
FR [B]--[/B][COLOR="White"]w[/COLOR][B]--[/B] [COLOR="green"]GD[/COLOR] [COLOR="Red"]PR[/COLOR] -- -- Clinton Jones

 

[bluejay]

I find it amazing that with 9 FAIR and 2 POOR performances (statistically speaking) we still managed to win that game.

 

[mick13]

On all accounts, we should have lost.

Luckiest win evar me thinks.

 

[Squizz]

Any time you have Ball, Dal, Harvs and Milve with VG ratings you must be half a chance. Helped a bit that the Tigers kept wanting to give it back to us in the first half.

Raph gave away too many frees and had a number of clangers (to get a VG rating). In fact, I had to check my adult nappies were secured tightly every time he had the ball.

As Clint Eastwood said "A man's gots to know his limitations".

 

[TassieSaint]

Sam Fisher very good? Come on Richo dominated him. Not his worst game but far from his best. I'd also contend that Riewoldt was good up until he got injured. But otherwise spot on I reckon.

 

[Goedy]

I dont think Dal Santo has been our 3rd best player he has struggled all season.

 

[bluejay]

I dont think Dal Santo has been our 3rd best player he has struggled all season.

Actually, I think Kildonan messed it up a bit, I think he's the 5th, not the 3rd. Anyway, it shows how the team is struggling if a struggling player is yet the 5th best player in this kind of stats ranking.

 

[bluejay]

Sam Fisher very good? Come on Richo dominated him. Not his worst game but far from his best. I'd also contend that Riewoldt was good up until he got injured. But otherwise spot on I reckon.

Sam only played in Richo when Richo move up forward, which only happened late in the game. The rest, he was loose in the backline, waiting for Richo to come up to attack. I think at least 3 of Richo's goals, Sam couldn't do a damn thing because some Richmond player kicked it to him in the 50 while in rebound after we had just turned the ball over. I reckong you're being a bit unfair with Fisher.

 

[TassieSaint]

Sam only played in Richo when Richo move up forward, which only happened late in the game. The rest, he was loose in the backline, waiting for Richo to come up to attack. I think at least 3 of Richo's goals, Sam couldn't do a damn thing because some Richmond player kicked it to him in the 50 while in rebound after we had just turned the ball over. I reckong you're being a bit unfair with Fisher.

Don't get me wrong, I love Sammy and I reckon it was a Good game. But Very Good being the best rating, I don't think Sam had the best game he could. Richo out-marked him 3 times (I think?) that resulted in a goal, now there's no shame in being out-marked by Richo but playing at his very best I think he would have beaten Richo. I also thought Fishers rebound work was good, but not as good as it could have been. But yeah good performance no doubt, but just not very good in my eyes.

 

[Kildonan]

But Very Good being the best rating,

Actually EX (excellent) is the best rating. Just that no-one's got it yet !

 

[TassieSaint]

Actually EX (excellent) is the best rating. Just that no-one's got it yet !

Ah ok fair enough. I definitely agree with you there though, other than Max's game against Essendon (top marks IMO) none of our players have produced their very best football as yet. In some ways though that's a good sign though, if we're 5th at the moment imagine if we got some Excellent games out of Dal Santo or Kozi etc! (Unfortunately we don't look like getting it together any time soon )

 

[HoldenMCaulfield]

Actually EX (excellent) is the best rating. Just that no-one's got it yet !

I always thought that there must be room above the many VG for a say Harvey in the 2005 Adelaide final performance.

But I never dared to ask...

(my mum told me not to question wise old men with a long white hair and beard)

 

[makemytime]

I can't wait until the good old days when our players are in form and we'd average 100pts+ a game, ahhh the good old days

 

[mick13]

I still believe we can bring back those days...

Not sure if we can do it under Lyon though.

 

[ChrisFooty]

Actually EX (excellent) is the best rating. Just that no-one's got it yet !

Milne would of been close. Won the game for us.

 

[CHBench]

Nice Effort

Just a quick question, whats FR?

 

[Kildonan]

FR = Fair effort (not good, not poor) - often reflects a patchy game