Analysis Player Ratings

[Kildonan]

After each match with the player performance fresh in my mind, I look over the stats and assess what I think is a fair rating for each player before I indicate who were our best and fairest.

Player     Rd 1   Rd 2   Rd 3   Rd 4   Rd 5   Rd 6   Rd 7   Rd 8   Rd 9
           Port    WB    Coll   Haw    GWS   Melb    NM     WCE    Ess
Steven      7      6      9      8      7      8      5      7     10
Riewoldt    3      7      7      8      8      8     10      5      8
Dempster    5      7      8      8      7      5      7      8      7
Fisher      8      7      8      5      6      7      7             7
Hickey     10      5      7      6      7      8      6      7      5
Montagna    6      6      9      7      6      5      8      7      7
Armitage    9      7      7      8      6      6      6      5      7
Ross        6      6      5      6      7      6      7      8     10
Savage      5      6      6      7      8      5      7      7      5
Newnes      6      7      8      6      7      6      5      4      7
Dunstan     5      5      7             7      7      7      4      7
Lee                              5      7               
Weller      8      5      7      7      4      5      6      6      6
Gilbert     7      4      7      8      6      5      8      4      4
Bruce       5      5      5      5      6      5      5      5      9
Geary       6      5      5      7      5      5      6      6      4
Acres       6                   5              8      5      3   
Webster     5      5      6             6      5      5      7      4
Membrey                                        7      5      3      6
Billings    4      4      7      8      2      6      6      5      5
McCartin           5      4      6      4                           7
McKenzie                                                            5
Sinclair           3      5      4      7      7             3   
Minchington               5      6      4      5      4       
Roberton    5      5      5                                  4      3
Gresham     4      4                           5      4      4      4
Lonie       6      4      4      5      2             4      4   
Templeton   3                    4

Understand that these are my opinion only - the ratings on here do not marry very well with the ratings in the papers
Also note that a rating of 10 is my saying that is the best we can expect given the conditions and the pressure etc

 

[dewah07]

dam i thought ross would have been better than that

also maybe do an overall average column?

 

[gringo2011]

I sat behind the goals and thought Geary was fantastic, he was often left with three opponents as McKenzie and Webster ran forward trying to get touches up the ground, a few times he held up three players or chose the right option to go to to defend out of the three, he also intercepted a few ball coming in and drove us forward. Roberton had possibly his worst game in our colours. Also loved Membreys game, was fantastic.

 

[The Jack]

Thought Robbo was in our top 4 or 5 in the Eagles game.

Sent from my SM-T210 using Tapatalk

 

[Greg1853]

Firstly, I commend you on your work, and in the main I think you have assessed players contributions quite well.
I do want to point out though that I think Jack Billings is judged very harshly. Each to their own, but I think Jack has played his designated role very well so far this year, and has made a real contribution bringing quality ball inside our 50. ie. In Rd 1 I loved his work, yet you have rated him =19th best for us.

He appears to get judged on total possessions alone at times, and then compared to genuine mid-fielder returns, when his I50 count, and quality of these disposals is generally a better indicator.

 

[Kildonan]

Player     Rd 1   Rd 2   Rd 3   Rd 4   Rd 5   Rd 6   Rd 7   Rd 8   Rd 9  Rd 10  Rd 11
           Port    WB    Coll   Haw    GWS   Melb    NM     WCE    Ess   Freo    Ade
Steven      7      6      9      8      7      8      5      7     10      9      7
Armitage    9      7      7      8      6      6      6      5      7     10      6
Fisher      8      7      8      5      6      7      7             7      8
Riewoldt    3      7      7      8      8      8     10      5      8      8      3
Ross        6      6      5      6      7      6      7      8     10      7      5
Hickey     10      5      7      6      7      8      6      7      5      6      6
Dempster    5      7      8      8      7      5      7      8      7      6      4
Savage      5      6      6      7      8      5      7      7      5      6      8
Montagna    6      6      9      7      6      5      8      7      7      6      3
Newnes      6      7      8      6      7      6      5      4      7      7      5
Lee                              5      7            
Dunstan     5      5      7             7      7      7      4      7      6      4
Membrey                                        7      5      3      6      8      6
Weller      8      5      7      7      4      5      6      6      6      5      5
Gilbert     7      4      7      8      6      5      8      4      4      6      5
Geary       6      5      5      7      5      5      6      6      4      6      8
Bruce       5      5      5      5      6      5      5      5      9      5      6
Acres       6                   5              8      5      3
Webster     5      5      6             6      5      5      7      4             6
McCartin           5      4      6      4                           7      7      4
Billings    4      4      7      8      2      6      6      5      5             5
Roberton    5      5      5                                  4      3
Minchington               5      6      4      5      4   
Sinclair           3      5      4      7      7             3
McKenzie                                                            5
Gresham     4      4                           5      4      4      4      6      5
Lonie       6      4      4      5      2             4      4
Murdoch                                                                    5      2
Templeton   3                    4                
Goddard                                                                           2

 

[12Chill]

Reckon Weller is stiff to just get a 5/10. Stats aren't anything amazing (although I think he went at 100% from 15 touches? IIRC) but his attack on the ball was second to none on the day whenever it was in his area in my opinion, on a day where so many were soft and didn't give it a crack Weller was one of few who looked like he gave a shit, so maybe I'm giving him extra points for that. Just my opinion, nice work mate.

 

[Kildonan]

Player     Rd 1   Rd 2   Rd 3   Rd 4   Rd 5   Rd 6   Rd 7   Rd 8   Rd 9  Rd 10  Rd 11  Rd 12  Rd 13  Rd 14  Rd 15  Rd 16
           Port    WB    Coll   Haw    GWS   Melb    NM     WCE    Ess   Freo    Ade    Car    Bye    Gee    GC     Ess
Steven      7      6      9      8      7      8      5      7     10      9      7     10             7      4     10
Fisher      8      7      8      5      6      7      7             7      8
Armitage    9      7      7      8      6      6      6      5      7     10      6      7             6      6      7
Hickey     10      5      7      6      7      8      6      7      5      6      6      9             7      6      8
Ross        6      6      5      6      7      6      7      8     10      7      5      7             9      5      9
Riewoldt    3      7      7      8      8      8     10      5      8      8      3                    8      5      7
Newnes      6      7      8      6      7      6      5      4      7      7      5      7             8      8      7
Dempster    5      7      8      8      7      5      7      8      7      6      4                                  4
Montagna    6      6      9      7      6      5      8      7      7      6      3      7             7      4      6
Savage      5      6      6      7      8      5      7      7      5      6      8      7             5      7      4
Membrey                                        7      5      3      6      8      6      8             6      5      8
Dunstan     5      5      7             7      7      7      4      7      6      4      7             6      6      6
Geary       6      5      5      7      5      5      6      6      4      6      8      6             7      6      7

Weller      8      5      7      7      4      5      6      6      6      5      5      6             8      5      6
Gilbert     7      4      7      8      6      5      8      4      4      6      5      6             7      7      5
Roberton    5      5      5                                  4      3      8      4      7             7      7      6
Bruce       5      5      5      5      6      5      5      5      9      5      6      5             6      4      6
Delaney                                                                                  5             7      5      5
Webster     5      5      6             6      5      5      7      4             6      6             5
Acres       6                    5             8      5      3                           5             7      6      3
Billings    4      4      7      8      2      6      6      5      5             5
Minchington               5      6      4      5      4                                  5             7      5      5
Lee                              5      7                                                4                    4
Pierce                                                                                   5
Gresham     4      4                           5      4      4      4      6      5      5             7      6      5
McCartin           5      4      6      4                           7      7      4                    5      2
Sinclair           3      5      4      7      7             3
Wright                                                                                   4             5             5
McKenzie                                                            5
Lonie       6      4      4      5      2             4      4                                                6
Murdoch                                                                    5      2
Templeton   3                    4              
Goddard                                                                           2