Player X or Player Y (Part II)

[LemmingMaster]

please continue.

 

[GUMBLETRON]

Judd or Judd_Magic? LOL!

 

[September 27 2008]

From the limited action we've seen from these so far

Mitch Banner v Brodie Moles v Luke Shuey v Lewis Jetta v Ryan Bastinac

And definately Judd Magic. Judd will miss the first 3 games. LOL!

 

[thomas_m18]

Judd or Judd_Magic? LOL!

Uhhh, Judd?

Montagna, Hall and Rockliff or Tippett, Hayes and Dennis-Lane?

 

[G.F.C]

Higgins or Cassisi for a spot if the MF.

 

[thomas_m18]

From the limited action we've seen from these so far

Mitch Banner v Brodie Moles v Luke Shuey v Lewis Jetta v Ryan Bastinac

And definately Judd Magic. Judd will miss the first 3 games. LOL!

If you don't have Barlow, he's first. If you do, probably Jetta, but consider Banner. See what he does tonight.

Montagna, Hall and Rockliff or Tippett, Hayes and Dennis-Lane?

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

From the limited action we've seen from these so far

Mitch Banner v Brodie Moles v Luke Shuey v Lewis Jetta v Ryan Bastinac

And definately Judd Magic. Judd will miss the first 3 games. LOL!

As has been said, Barlow by a mile then banner, Shuey, Jetta, Bastinac, Moles. Mind you, this is all on the basis of who will be playing. If it's just on SC ability alone (Regardless of whether or not they play), I'd be going Barlow, Jetta, Moles, Bastinac, Shuey.

Uhhh, Judd?

Montagna, Hall and Rockliff or Tippett, Hayes and Dennis-Lane?

The first. But oonly because I think TDL will be in and out of the team. can't see him playing more than 12-14 games this year. Swap Hall for tippet and you'll smash 'em..

Higgins or Cassisi for a spot if the MF.

Higgins.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Judd or Judd_Magic? LOL!

If I could I would pick myself and make myself captain. LOL!

 

[Judd_Magic]

and definately judd magic. Judd will miss the first 3 games. Lol!

ROFL!

 

[WOTTAMACHINE]

Shaun Higgins or Boomer Harvey?

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Shaun Higgins or Boomer Harvey?

Equal... I have them both.....

 

[Impromptu]

Judd or Judd_Magic? LOL!

And definately Judd Magic. Judd will miss the first 3 games. LOL!

Judd as whilst Judd will miss the first 3 games....

Judd_Magic may have some off field incidents (on BF)...

 

[Impromptu]

Shaun Higgins or Boomer Harvey?

Boomer!!

Carrazzo v Waite v Mattner v J.MacDonald v Chadwick v any 450K (except Gilbee, Hodge)

Carrazzo - tagging role?
Waite - injury?
Mattner - tricky with Shaw, Kennelly, Malceski
MacDonald - smokey?
Chadwick - oldie but a goodie

or do I just pay an extra $70K and get Newman

 

[Judd_Magic]

Carrazzo v Waite v Mattner v J.MacDonald v Chadwick v any 450K (except Gilbee, Hodge)

Carrazzo - tagging role?
Waite - injury?
Mattner - tricky with Shaw, Kennelly, Malceski
MacDonald - smokey?
Chadwick - oldie but a goodie

or do I just pay an extra $70K and get Newman

I'm a big Newman fan Prompts and have had him gthe last couple of seasons, rarely lets you down. Am going to be drafting him in agt some point during the season.

See how Waite goes the next couple of practice games. Could be a steal at just over $400,000 and a cheap 4th back in defence.

I can see Mcdonald doing well and I still think Chadwick has a bit of life in him yet.

Tough call though as Carrzzo and Mattner aren't hacks either.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Judd as whilst Judd will miss the first 3 games....

Judd_Magic may have some off field incidents (on BF)...

LOL! So your saying I'm the Fevola of Bigfooty? Whoose photo can I take with my camera phone and distribute around to all the supercoaches on here?

 

[Baker_for_PM]

Schoenmakers vs Ladson

Who is the better Hawk??

 

[September 27 2008]

Schoenmakers vs Ladson

Who is the better Hawk??

It all depends on whether or not Ladson can get back to his best or not. And from what i've seen so far, i'm not so sure. Having said that i'm not sure Schoenmakers is the answer either. He has a bigger frame this year, but last week against the dogs I think he had 18 touches and scored 60. Can't see him having 18 touches much this year, so can't see him scoring 60 too often. Look elsewhere. Maybe Josh Hunt if you don't have him. Will play 22 games barring injury and should average close to 80

 

[carn dees]

Goldstein or mumford?

 

[Hot Tiges]

Goldstein or mumford?

Neither, to be honest.. I'd rather Leunberger.

 

[carn dees]

fair enough, do you recon leunberger will get a constant run.

I think mumford is most likely to be one of swannys game day ruckman.

 

[Ed_Gein]

Gilbee + Cooney + Ryder

or

Newman + Cross + Hille

I have question marks over Hille? But i think if he stays fit i could be laughing as the money i save on Ryder gets a better mid + def IMO in Newman + Cross.

 

[Hot Tiges]

fair enough, do you recon leunberger will get a constant run.

I think mumford is most likely to be one of swannys game day ruckman.

Seaby maybe a better bet. Muumford is good at the 1 percenters.. No disposoal though..

Leunberger will get a run now that Charman is injured yet again..

my issue is Pratt vs Macdonald for the 4th spot in defence.

 

[soho]

out of pratt and macdonald, id take luke hodge...

armitage vs masten

armitage is 70k more, and may lose a fair few stats to other saint ball magnets... i see a bit more value in masten, but not sure he will have a stand out year...

 

[Impromptu]

Gilbee + Cooney + Ryder
or
Newman + Cross + Hille

Pretty much even, but Hille is tricky...Go Newman + Cross + Hille (for Mr Reliable Newman)? Can you go Newman+Cooney+Ottens?

A.Walker v Malceski v J.Hunt v Cruize Garlett (exclude Greenwood/Ladson)

Walker - best 22?
Malceski - hot form pre-season but this guy always teases me
J.Hunt - is he in the mighty Cats' best 22?
Cruize Garlett - any good?

 

[Ed_Gein]

Pretty much even, but Hille is tricky...Go Newman + Cross + Hille (for Mr Reliable Newman)? Can you go Newman+Cooney+Ottens?

A.Walker v Malceski v J.Hunt v Cruize Garlett (exclude Greenwood/Ladson)

Walker - best 22?
Malceski - hot form pre-season but this guy always teases me
J.Hunt - is he in the mighty Cats' best 22?
Cruize Garlett - any good?

Yup, could definitely go Newman + Cooney + Ottens. But i'm not so sure, Cross avg'd over 100 for the last 5 years, Cooney only broke an avg of 100 once. Bit like your assessment of Malceski, Cooney always teases me. Will def keep Newman, just wonder how Ottens has been so far in pre-season?

I can help ya out with Malceski. Think i mentioned in another thread, i think he is set for a big one just looking at him vs St Kilda. Seems to be well over the knee injury and i reckon we'll see him avg around the 90-95 mark i think, which is where he was pre-knee injury in 2007.