Hot Topic POLL: Who does Carlton draft with pick 9 & 11?

[ctwenty1]

The only question is how Kemp returns I think he’s more of legit third tall now.
Or was pace big leap found his home forward before his injury he was taking contested pack marks.
Moir looks a beauty but plays a bit smaller slower not as explosive but better kick more mercurial.
Be intresting see how they play together.
Not sure on tactics but would be nice if we could limit Harry’s opportunity for head knocks maybe more like the way Cameron plays

yeah - this is a concern for me too

 

[Bamboo Harvester]

Hypothetically, if we end up trading up with Essendon to land pick 6, who's the player we should take?

Assumes the players earmarked by 'experts' to go top 5 in the open draft are gone; ie
WCE: Duursma
WCE: CDT
Rich: Robey
Rich: Grlj
Ess: Sharp

Who do we go for?

 

[JJBagger]

Hypothetically, if we end up trading up with Essendon to land pick 6, who's the player we should take?

Assumes the players earmarked by 'experts' to go top 5 in the open draft are gone; ie
WCE: Duursma
WCE: CDT
Rich: Robey
Rich: Grlj
Ess: Sharp

Who do we go for?

Cumming, Lindsay or Dovaston?

 

[ctwenty1]

Hypothetically, if we end up trading up with Essendon to land pick 6, who's the player we should take?

Assumes the players earmarked by 'experts' to go top 5 in the open draft are gone; ie
WCE: Duursma
WCE: CDT
Rich: Robey
Rich: Grlj
Ess: Sharp

Who do we go for?

Maybe we take dean for shits and giggles

 

[Gw2_James]

Pick 6 has historically been a bad pick to have hasn't it? Pretty sure we got sps with that... No thanks!

 

[ctwenty1]

Pick 6 has historically been a bad pick to have hasn't it? Pretty sure we got sps with that... No thanks!

wont be pick 6 with the bid matching

likely 9

 

[JJBagger]

Pick 6 has historically been a bad pick to have hasn't it? Pretty sure we got sps with that... No thanks!

So you’re saying we shouldn’t get pick 6 because of superstition?

 

[ctwenty1]

So you’re saying we shouldn’t get pick 6 because of superstition?

societies are built on superstition

surely could apply to draft stratgey trading too

 

[RPCB]

Pick 6 has historically been a bad pick to have hasn't it? Pretty sure we got sps with that... No thanks!

Unless SPS is in this draft, there is no risk of drafting him again.

 

[Bamboo Harvester]

Maybe we take dean for shits and giggles

We should place a bid on him and then not match it. Poor ol' Shifter would be completely flummoxed

 

[reubsblues]

I'm trading out of this yrs draft get enough points for Dean and Ison try and get WC, Melb or essendon 26 first I want I live pick before walker bid Malady and Walker combo next yr works for me

 

[Stamos]

I'm trading out of this yrs draft get enough points for Dean and Ison try and get WC, Melb or essendon 26 first I want I live pick before walker bid Malady and Walker combo next yr works for me

None of those clubs are giving us a 2026 1st

 

[JJBagger]

I'm trading out of this yrs draft get enough points for Dean and Ison try and get WC, Melb or essendon 26 first I want I live pick before walker bid Malady and Walker combo next yr works for me

No point getting a pick to try get a player before Walker when Walker is currently rated a top 2 prospect…

 

[reubsblues]

No point getting a pick to try get a player before Walker when Walker is currently rated a top 2 prospect…

Exactly get pick 1 or 2

 

[GT619]

Cumming, Lindsay or Dovaston?

in that order

 

[pressurepoint]

We want to get ahead of the Dean bid, Essendon want CDT, WCE want to continue a rebuild. So:

Ess trade 6,21+30 to Carl for 9+11
Ess trade 5, 11 to WCE for 2
(Agreement between the 3 that there’s no FS/academy bids)

The result

Bombers have 2, 9, 27
WCE have 1, 5, 11, 13
Carl have 6, 21, 30

Do picks 21, 30, 43, 54, 67, 72, 87, 105 suffice for a Dean and Ison bid?

 

[Stamos]

We want to get ahead of the Dean bid, Essendon want CDT, WCE want to continue a rebuild. So:

Ess trade 6,21+30 to Carl for 9+11
Ess trade 5, 11 to WCE for 2
(Agreement between the 3 that there’s no FS/academy bids)

The result

Bombers have 2, 9, 27
WCE have 1, 5, 11, 13
Carl have 6, 21, 30

Do picks 21, 30, 43, 54, 67, 72, 87, 105 suffice for a Dean and Ison bid?

1. We can't afford to trade at the time of pick 2 because it leaves us open to a Richmond bid on Dean.

2. Those last 4 supposed picks have no points attached, but will also be taken off us prior to the draft due to list spots, we'll hit the draft with only 4 picks.

3. If we can do the Essendon trade (at the time of pick 6 which will then be 9), we would take pick 27 rather than 30. We get more points, but it makes no difference to Essendon, because it along with Gold Coast's 28 + 29 will all disappear.

 

[TENACIOUS]

I too voted for Dean and Schubert. If I had to guess Dean gets bid on by Melbourne’s pick 8.

Though would be happy with a slider or Dovaston or splitting our pick for Emmett or Pickett.

I do worry if we have enough points for Ison

 

[BlueTongue]

I too voted for Dean and Schubert. If I had to guess Dean gets bid on by Melbourne’s pick 8.

Though would be happy with a slider or Dovaston or splitting our pick for Emmett or Pickett.

I do worry if we have enough points for Ison

We'll be right for Ison, even if we use 9 & 11 (which probably end up 12 & 14) the dilution of points due to Acadamy players leaves Ison (let's say 1st pick of 2nd round at around 27 = 533 points),
So Hypothetically, if * Bid with 6 (now 9 after acad bids), thats 1355 -10% = 1220. Our pick 9 (now 12) is worth 1140, and we make up the addtional 80 poins with our next pick (now 14) which slides us back to Pick 16 at 944 remaining points.

I'd say Grlj will be gone (Tiges/*/Dees/Hawks) then we are squarely in the frame for Lindsay at 16 for 924 points and 20 leftover + Pick 43 (still 43 as GCS will have moved their picks fwd) and we have to make up around 300 pts which means go into deficit.

^ I figure that's worst case