possible trades for Tyson Stenglien?

[Blue Red and Gold]

As an Adelaide supporter and with Tyson Stenglien more than likely wanting to head West at the end of the year I was wondering what trade you would be willing to accept for him?

 

[larrikin]

Trent Carroll and a sack of potatoes.

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

haha Pass

 

[HATS]

umm not sure
who would u want?
a defensive midfielder would be quite handy to our team...

 

[theorangeapple]

ive said it many times; 2nd round pick is really the only option. we dont have a third round and their is no way he is worth a first rounder. or u could have some guy not playing a part in our side atm (which u wont want). have your pick of guys like chambers, green, johnson??.

oh yeh, and adelaide and port for that matter can keep their dirty mits off butler and waters. they will not be traded.

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

Originally posted by theorangeapple


oh yeh, and adelaide and port for that matter can keep their dirty mits off butler and waters. they will not be traded.

haha i was just about to ask what would it take to get Beau

 

[larrikin]

Originally posted by theorangeapple

oh yeh, and adelaide and port for that matter can keep their dirty mits off butler and waters. they will not be traded.

They're safe. You can't touch players the first year after they are drafted.

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

Originally posted by HATS
umm not sure
who would u want?
a defensive midfielder would be quite handy to our team...

Im not too sure about your list, but yes we do need a quality young midfielder.

I think Stenglien and a player would be worth a 1st round draft pick.

 

[larrikin]

Originally posted by tatts00
Im not too sure about your list, but yes we do need a quality young midfielder.

I think Stenglien and a player would be worth a 1st round draft pick.

It would be worth us looking at offers for our first round pick if they were REALLY GOOD (not necesarily this one) as Morton is that sort of calibre.

 

[coasting]

Originally posted by larrikin
It would be worth us looking at offers for our first round pick if they were REALLY GOOD (not necesarily this one) as Morton is that sort of calibre.

The fact we got Morton for a 3rd rounder has nothing to do with trading for Stenglein.

 

[larrikin]

Originally posted by coasting
The fact we got Morton for a 3rd rounder has nothing to do with trading for Stenglein.

No, but as I said, if the offer for our first rounder was really good we'd have to consider it. It's not like we're going to have a pick in the top 5 or anything.

 

[coasting]

Originally posted by larrikin
No, but as I said, if the offer for our first rounder was really good we'd have to consider it. It's not like we're going to have a pick in the top 5 or anything.

Yeah well we got Beau Waters with pick 11. I wouldn't so quickly discount our recruiting staff getting another gun at about the same pick, probably earlier.

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

is Tyson Stenglien (in your eyes) a really good player?

Personally i think he is worth it, Im spewing he is leaving Adelaide.

He is a ready made midfielder for you guys, can do a negating/run with role and he has great leadership skills as he was touted as possibly our next captain.

let me know your thoughts.

 

[coasting]

Originally posted by tatts00
is Tyson Stenglien (in your eyes) a really good player?

Personally i think he is worth it, Im spewing he is leaving Adelaide.

He is a ready made midfielder for you guys, can do a negating/run with role and he has great leadership skills as he was touted as possibly our next captain.

let me know your thoughts.

To be honest I think that, as a midfielder, he is a bit of a plodder. Certainly when compared to our current midfielders he isn't that quick. I watched him very closely against the Roos and I thought he was very ordinary. Poor finishing. What he has going for him is his height and his ability to negate taller midfielders like Pavlich... is what makes him attractive. He certainly plays an important role but he aint no star. Players like Stenglein can be more easily developed than star players recruited, and Selwood was showing promise in this role until he got injured. Thats why I think he isn't worth a first rounder.

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

Originally posted by coasting
I watched him very closely against the Roos and I thought he was very ordinary. Poor finishing. What he has going for him is his height and his ability to negate taller midfielders like Pavlich... is what makes him attractive.

You make good points, but dont let the Roo's game fool you, nobody was able to finish anything in that game.
Stenglien is a very tough player, I watched him during the Showdown and he was awesome, he is very in and under, he is also very handy across the HBF too.
He is not a star but he is highly underrated IMO

 

[coasting]

Originally posted by tatts00
You make good points, but dont let the Roo's game fool you, nobody was able to finish anything in that game.
Stenglien is a very tough player, I watched him during the Showdown and he was awesome, he is very in and under, he is also very handy across the HBF too.
He is not a star but he is highly underrated IMO

I'm not saying he isn't tough or underrated I'm just saying he has his limitations. Still while he would be very handy for us in certain situations I think the crows need him much more than we do. He would leave a gaping hole in the crows midfield.

 

[noodle]

if adelaide are after quick midfielders how about chambers? i'm not just trying to flog off unwanted cattle. i really think this guy has talent he just can't break into our midfield cause we are chocka with running midfielders.

 

[F-U]

I think Chambers and our 2nd rounder sounds like a very fair trade to me. Chambers is a fairly solid player when he is given his chance. He is a hell of a kick too. I think the amount Adelaide gets for Stenglein will depend on Josh Carr and if he decides to leave and whether Fremantle want to make a decent crack at Stenglein.

Personally i think Stenglein would want to join Eagles rather then Fremantle and i would expect Adelaide will not get anymore then a 2nd round pick and a okay player for him. If not Chambers maybe a player like Rowan Jones would be better suited or Kasey Green..

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

Originally posted by coasting
I'm not saying he isn't tough or underrated I'm just saying he has his limitations. Still while he would be very handy for us in certain situations I think the crows need him much more than we do. He would leave a gaping hole in the crows midfield.

I dont disagree with you there, i dont want him to go, he is an outstanding player and will leave a huge hole in our midfield.

Dont really know much about Chambers to make a decent comment on him. We might be better off just going for draft picks so we can hand pick who we want.

The Carr won will be interesting, i wonder if Freo are prepared to play hard ball with Carr after what happened last year at Port!

 

[theorangeapple]

Originally posted by noodle
if adelaide are after quick midfielders how about chambers? i'm not just trying to flog off unwanted cattle. i really think this guy has talent he just can't break into our midfield cause we are chocka with running midfielders.

i agree. it may look like we are flogging off a no-hoper but every chance he has, he proves himself at afl. he's dominating wafl atm. he may not be worth much by himself but i think when packaged with the second round pick is fair.

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

Originally posted by theorangeapple
i agree. it may look like we are flogging off a no-hoper but every chance he has, he proves himself at afl. he's dominating wafl atm. he may not be worth much by himself but i think when packaged with the second round pick is fair.

Its going to be an interesting trade because of highly the Crows rate Tyson. I dont think the Crows will be too keen on getting rid of someone touted as the next captain for a player who cant find a regular spot in the 22 and a second rounder.
Personally I'd rather give you Tyson and Burton/Perrie/biglands for a 1st rounder.

 

[larrikin]

Originally posted by coasting
Yeah well we got Beau Waters with pick 11. I wouldn't so quickly discount our recruiting staff getting another gun at about the same pick, probably earlier.

Haven't discounted anything, but we won't get any of this year's guns at 10. I'm talking the possibility of a really good player becoming available - say Daniel Wells, and we had to give player(s) + pick(s) to do it I think the options should be left open.

Having said all of that, in the past we have never really gone after big namer players (the last real big name we went after was probably Glendinning), and that probably won't change in the near future.

All very hypothetical really........

 

[theorangeapple]

i think we could find a role for burton. personally, i would take stenglien and burton for our first round pick. others i suspect wont.

 

[larrikin]

Originally posted by tatts00
Burton/Perrie/biglands

No thanks

 

[larrikin]

Originally posted by theorangeapple
i think we could find a role for burton. personally, i would take stenglien and burton for our first round pick. others i suspect wont.

I don't rate him that highly to be honest. I know he's quick and can really jump, but he's very inconsistent.