Prediction Predict the Top 5 in the B&F

[thomas_m18]

Steven
Riewoldt
Hickey
Ross
Newnes

Hard to call with Hickey, been one of the top rucks in the comp but might not translate well to B&F, Milney came 12th in 2011 when he made AA or something like that. Riewoldt will be coming big time late.

 

[puppy_dog7]

1. Steven
2. Roo
3. Ross
4. Gears
5. Hickey
6. Newnes
7. Joey
8. Dempster
9. Armo
10. Membrey

Mav could easily be in there for Armo or Membrey

 

[joop]

1 Steven
2 Riewoldt
3 Ross
4 Hickey
5 Membrey

 

[Hubnester]

Sorry to invade a semi-relevant thread, but is the B&F being live streamed? Can't seem to find any info on it.
I did my votes just to fit in. It was tough, but I wouldn't see Gears, Riewoldt, Ross, Steven, and Weller to place. But then there's Newnes. And Hickey. Not enough votes...

 

[Choomah]

what times it start?

 

[George]

what times it start?

7pm but will drag on as usual till about 10.30-11 I'd say.

Want your thoughts on the top 5 best campaigners?

 

[Choomah]

7pm but will drag on as usual till about 10.30-11 I'd say.

Want your thoughts on the top 5 best campaigners?

steven
rosco
sticky hickey
roooo
skunk fart lock it in edwardo

 

[George]

steven
rosco
sticky hickey
roooo
skunk fart lock it in edwardo

Geez would've thought Webster, Wright and Weller would've got a look in...they've campaigned hard all year

 

[Jack Stevens]

I voted Steven, Ross, Riewoldt, Hickey and Geary, more or less in that order. Any of Mav, Dempster, Member, Joey and Newnes could be top 5, though.

 

[Choomah]

Geez would've thought Webster, Wright and Weller would've got a look in...they've campaigned hard all year

forgot about cement chin i think webster will win for bowling ball those carlton spuds

 

[George]

forgot about cement chin i think webster will win for bowling ball those carlton spuds

Weller reminds me of Buzz Lightyear in a way

 

[Glen Buterol]

Steven
Geary
Roo
Hickey
Ross

 

[Phoenix_9]

1. Steven
2. Riewoldt
3. Ross
4. Geary
5. Hickey
6. Montagna
7. Roberton
8. Newnes
9. Dempster
10. Weller
11. Membrey

 

[Hayes4PM]

Roo
Steven
Newnes
Hickey
Geary

 

[bergholt]

So according to our votes it's:

1st: Steven
2nd: Riewoldt
3rd: Ross
4th: Hickey
5th: Geary
6th: Montagna
7th: Membrey
8th: Weller
9th: Dempster, Newnes
Others: Acres, Roberton, Gresham, Savage

Looks pretty reasonable.

Interesting that last year's 2nd placegetter (Armo) and 8th, 9th, 10th placegetters (Bruce, Fisher, Webster) don't appear at all in our votes.

 

[CursingFijian]

1. Steven
2. Ross
3. Riewoldt
4. Geary
5. Newnes


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[Shred]

My top 5 from 5-1 votes each round
1. Steven (54 votes)
2. Riewoldt (51 votes)
3. Ross (36 votes, x3 1st)
4. Montagna (36 votes, x2 1st)
5. Membrey (25 votes)

 

[bergholt]

1st: Steven
2nd: Riewoldt
3rd: Ross
4th: Hickey
5th: Geary
6th: Montagna
7th: Membrey
8th: Weller
9th: Dempster, Newnes
Others: Acres, Roberton, Gresham, Savage

So based on that, we underestimated Geary (2nd not 5th), Montagna (4th not 6th), Newnes (5th not 9th), Armo (10th not unplaced).

And we overestimated Ross (6th not 3rd), Hickey (8th not 4th), Membrey (9th not 7th).

Interesting that the three we overestimated were the three who took another step this year, and those we underestimated were more experienced. Looks like the coaches mark the kids harder than we do!