Ranking The Tigers Squad

[Crow_Sting]

Saw this on another teams board and thought it would be a good idea to rate our own side. From A-D graders right through to YTD (yet to be determined)

David Astbury
Andrew Browne
Jake Batchelor
Reece Conca
Daniel Connors
Pat Contin (rookie)
Trent Cotchin
Matt Dea
Brett Deledio
Tom Derickx
Shane Edwards
Mitch Farmer
Nathan Foley
David Gourdis
Angus Graham
Ben Griffiths
Shaun Grigg
Dylan Grimes
Brad Helbig
Robert Hicks (rookie)
Tom Hislop (rookie)
Bachar Houli
Daniel Jackson
Ben Jakobi (rookie)
Jake King
Dean MacDonald
Dustin Martin
Luke McGuane
Brad Miller (upgraded rookie)
Kelvin Moore
Mitch Morton
Robin Nahas
Ben Nason
Chris Newman
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie)
Jayden Post
Alex Rance
Jack Riewoldt
Troy Taylor
Will Thursfield
Shane Tuck
Tyrone Vickery
Jeromey Webberley
Nick Westhoff (rookie)
Matthew White

 

[Crow_Sting]

David Astbury--------C
Andrew Browne------C
Jake Batchelor-------B
Reece Conca---------B
Daniel Connors-------B
Pat Contin (rookie)---YTD
Trent Cotchin--------A
Matt Dea------------C
Brett Deledio---------A
Tom Derickx---------YTD
Shane Edwards------B
Mitch Farmer---------C
Nathan Foley--------A
David Gourdis--------B
Angus Graham-------B
Ben Griffiths----------C
Shaun Grigg---------B
Dylan Grimes--------B
Brad Helbig----------C
Robert Hicks (rookie)-D
Tom Hislop (rookie)---C
Bachar Houli---------B
Daniel Jackson-------B
Ben Jakobi (rookie)--YTD
Jake King------------B
Dean MacDonald----YTD
Dustin Martin--------A
Luke McGuane-------B
Brad Miller-----------C
Kelvin Moore--------B
Mitch Morton--------B
Robin Nahas---------B
Ben Nason----------C
Chris Newman-------A
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie)-C
Jayden Post---------C
Alex Rance----------B
Jack Riewoldt-------A
Troy Taylor---------C
Will Thursfield-------C
Shane Tuck---------B
Tyrone Vickery------B
Jeromey Webberley-B-
Nick Westhoff (rookie)YTD
Matthew White------B

Looking over it again i was probably a bit generous with a few players but made up for it by being harsh on a few as well.

 

[Bazzar]

1- Newman > The best.
2- Reiwoldt
3- Deledio
4- Cotchin
5- Vickery
6- Martin
7- King
8- Jackson
9- Nahas
10- McGuane
11- Foley
12- Houli
13- Conca
14- Rance
15- Edwards
16- Grimes
17- Grigg
18- Graham
19- White
20- Miller
21- Batchelor


22- Cant separate any thats left in the best as they are all...

 

[Dr Rockso]

David Astbury--------C
Andrew Browne------C+
Jake Batchelor-------B+
Reece Conca---------A
Daniel Connors-------C
Pat Contin (rookie)---YTD
Trent Cotchin--------A+
Matt Dea------------C
Brett Deledio---------A
Tom Derickx---------YTD
Shane Edwards------B-
Mitch Farmer---------C
Nathan Foley--------A
David Gourdis--------C-
Angus Graham-------C+
Ben Griffiths----------YTD (want to see him fit)
Shaun Grigg---------C+
Dylan Grimes--------A
Brad Helbig----------B+
Robert Hicks (rookie)-C-
Tom Hislop (rookie)---C-
Bachar Houli---------B
Daniel Jackson-------B
Ben Jakobi (rookie)--YTD
Jake King------------A
Dean MacDonald----YTD
Dustin Martin--------A
Luke McGuane-------D+
Brad Miller-----------C
Kelvin Moore--------C+
Mitch Morton--------C
Robin Nahas---------A+
Ben Nason----------C+
Chris Newman-------A+
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie)-YTD
Jayden Post---------C
Alex Rance----------C+
Jack Riewoldt-------A
Troy Taylor---------E-
Will Thursfield-------C
Shane Tuck---------C+
Tyrone Vickery------B
Jeromey Webberley-C
Nick Westhoff (rookie)YTD
Matthew White------C-

based purely on what their performance vs their expectations. I'm sure each player has set tasks which will be reflected in B&F votes. Nahas way ahead of the rest in this regard, although players with plenty of natural ability like Cotch, Lids and Dusty are obviously top performers too.

 

[Gentlemen]

David Astbury - C+
Andrew Browne - C
Jake Batchelor - B-
Reece Conca - B+
Daniel Connors - B-
Pat Contin (rookie) YTD
Trent Cotchin - A+
Matt Dea - C-
Brett Deledio - A+
Tom Derickx - YTD
Shane Edwards - B-
Mitch Farmer - C+
Nathan Foley - A-
David Gourdis - C
Angus Graham - C+
Ben Griffiths C+
Shaun Grigg - B+
Dylan Grimes - B-
Brad Helbig - C+
Robert Hicks (rookie) - C-
Tom Hislop (rookie) - C
Bachar Houli - B+
Daniel Jackson - B+
Ben Jakobi (rookie) - YTD
Jake King - A- (Being serious here, very important player
Dean MacDonald - YTD
Dustin Martin - A+
Luke McGuane - B-
Brad Miller (upgraded rookie) - C+
Kelvin Moore - B
Mitch Morton - B
Robin Nahas - B+ almost A-
Ben Nason - B-
Chris Newman A+
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie) C
Jayden Post - C+
Alex Rance - B
Jack Riewoldt - A+
Troy Taylor - F
Will Thursfield - C+
Shane Tuck B-
Tyrone Vickery B+ almost A-
Jeromey Webberley C+
Nick Westhoff (rookie) YTD
Matthew White B-

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

David Astbury - YTD
Andrew Browne - YTD
Jake Batchelor - YTD
Reece Conca - YTD
Daniel Connors - C-
Pat Contin (rookie) YTD
Trent Cotchin - A+
Matt Dea - YTD
Brett Deledio - A-
Tom Derickx - YTD
Shane Edwards - C+
Mitch Farmer - C+
Nathan Foley - B
David Gourdis - YTD
Angus Graham - YTD
Ben Griffiths YTD
Shaun Grigg - C
Dylan Grimes - YTD
Brad Helbig - YTD
Robert Hicks (rookie) - YTD
Tom Hislop (rookie) - D
Bachar Houli - C
Daniel Jackson - B+
Ben Jakobi (rookie) - YTD
Jake King - B
Dean MacDonald - YTD
Dustin Martin - YTD , A or B
Luke McGuane - C
Brad Miller (upgraded rookie) - C
Kelvin Moore - B
Mitch Morton - B
Robin Nahas - YTD A- to C-
Ben Nason - YTD
Chris Newman A
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie) YTD
Jayden Post - YTD
Alex Rance - YTD
Jack Riewoldt - A
Troy Taylor - YTD
Will Thursfield - C
Shane Tuck C
Tyrone Vickery YTD
Jeromey Webberley YTD
Nick Westhoff (rookie) YTD
Matthew White C

 

[DerpWerls]

David Astbury - C
Andrew Browne - C
Jake Batchelor - C
Reece Conca - C
Daniel Connors - C
Pat Contin (rookie) N/A
Trent Cotchin - A
Matt Dea N/A
Brett Deledio - A
Tom Derickx N/A
Shane Edwards - B
Mitch Farmer - D
Nathan Foley - B
David Gourdis - D
Angus Graham - C
Ben Griffiths - C
Shaun Grigg - B
Dylan Grimes - B
Brad Helbig - C
Robert Hicks (rookie) N/A
Tom Hislop (rookie) - F
Bachar Houli - B
Daniel Jackson - B
Ben Jakobi (rookie) N/A
Jake King - B
Dean MacDonald N/A
Dustin Martin - A
Luke McGuane - C
Brad Miller (upgraded rookie) - D
Kelvin Moore - B
Mitch Morton - C
Robin Nahas - B
Ben Nason - C
Chris Newman - A
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie) N/A
Jayden Post - C
Alex Rance - C
Jack Riewoldt - A
Troy Taylor - F
Will Thursfield - C
Shane Tuck - B
Tyrone Vickery - C
Jeromey Webberley - C
Nick Westhoff (rookie) N/A
Matthew White - C

The job is to turn the C graders into B graders and so on.

 

[doddy87]

David Astbury--------C
Andrew Browne------C
Jake Batchelor-------B
Reece Conca---------B
Daniel Connors-------B
Pat Contin (rookie)---YTD
Trent Cotchin--------A
Matt Dea------------C
Brett Deledio---------A
Tom Derickx---------YTD
Shane Edwards------B
Mitch Farmer---------C
Nathan Foley--------A
David Gourdis--------B
Angus Graham-------B
Ben Griffiths----------C
Shaun Grigg---------B
Dylan Grimes--------B
Brad Helbig----------C
Robert Hicks (rookie)-D
Tom Hislop (rookie)---C
Bachar Houli---------B
Daniel Jackson-------B
Ben Jakobi (rookie)--YTD
Jake King------------B
Dean MacDonald----YTD
Dustin Martin--------A
Luke McGuane-------B
Brad Miller-----------C
Kelvin Moore--------B
Mitch Morton--------B
Robin Nahas---------B
Ben Nason----------C
Chris Newman-------A
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie)-C
Jayden Post---------C
Alex Rance----------B
Jack Riewoldt-------A
Troy Taylor---------C
Will Thursfield-------C
Shane Tuck---------B
Tyrone Vickery------B
Jeromey Webberley-B-
Nick Westhoff (rookie)YTD
Matthew White------B

Looking over it again i was probably a bit generous with a few players but made up for it by being harsh on a few as well.

You saying we have no D graders? cmon...

 

[DerpWerls]

You saying we have no D graders? cmon...

The first 3 posters rated Tom Hislop a C Grader!
This is a guy who has been delisted twice!!!

 

[Truetiger]

David Astbury - C
Andrew Browne- C
Jake Batchelor- B
Reece Conca -B
Daniel Connors -C
Pat Contin (rookie)- YTD
Trent Cotchin- A
Matt Dea -YTD
Brett Deledio -A
Tom Derickx -YTD
Shane Edwards- B
Mitch Farmer -C
Nathan Foley -A
David Gourdis- C
Angus Graham -C
Ben Griffiths -C
Shaun Grigg -B
Dylan Grimes -B
Brad Helbig- B
Robert Hicks (rookie) -C
Tom Hislop (rookie) -C
Bachar Houli -B
Daniel Jackson -B
Ben Jakobi (rookie) -YTD
Jake King -B
Dean MacDonald -YTD
Dustin Martin -B
Luke McGuane -B
Brad Miller (upgraded rookie) -C
Kelvin Moore -B
Mitch Morton -D
Robin Nahas -B
Ben Nason- C
Chris Newman -A
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie) -YTD
Jayden Post -D
Alex Rance - C
Jack Riewoldt -A
Troy Taylor -D (Should delist) Dont care how he plays anymore
Will Thursfield -D
Shane Tuck- C
Tyrone Vickery -C
Jeromey Webberley -C
Nick Westhoff (rookie) TYD
Matthew White YTD

 

[Wallaby]

The first 3 posters rated Tom Hislop a C Grader!
This is a guy who has been delisted twice!!!

But he's playing really well for Coburg!


I actually like bazzar's idea of ranking the players from best to ..... not-best. I'll give it a go. I'm going off form they have shown, and assuming full fitness. It's not based on potential.

**** A Graders**** (get a game in all teams)
1. Riewoldt
2. Deledio
3. Cotchin

**** B Graders**** (as good as similar players in most teams)
4. Martin
5. Newman
6. Foley
7. Jackson
8. Moore
9. Nahas
10. Vickery
11. Morton
12. McGuane
13. King
14. Graham
15. Tuck

**** C Graders**** (only get a game in other teams if they had a glaring vacancy)
16. Edwards
17. Conca
18. Rance
19. Batchelor
20. Houli
21. White
22. Grigg

That was actually quite tough.

EDIT: Left out Grimes! How's that - one week off, and he's forgotten! Put him about 14-15.

The rest are fillers - at the moment. I would like to include Thursfield, but it looks like his time is up. Astbury, Browne, Nason, Griffiths, Post, all need to become regular players before I can rate them.

Please remember my list is based on actual form shown - I don't think Conca fully deserves a spot at the moment, but as an 18-year old he gets the games and would be getting them in most teams . If he was 28 and playing like he is, he would be a fringe player. But he's going to be really good. Just not yet.

 

[Rodney Dangerfield]

David Astbury. D
Andrew Browne. D
Jake Batchelor. C
Reece Conca. C+
Daniel Connors. C
Pat Contin (rookie) YTD
Trent Cotchin. B+
Matt Dea. YTD
Brett Deledio. A
Tom Derickx. YTD
Shane Edwards. C
Mitch Farmer. D
Nathan Foley. B
David Gourdis. YTD
Angus Graham. C
Ben Griffiths. YTD
Shaun Grigg. C
Dylan Grimes. C+
Brad Helbig. C
Robert Hicks (rookie)YTD
Tom Hislop (rookie) D
Bachar Houli. B-
Daniel Jackson. B+
Ben Jakobi (rookie) YTD
Jake King. B
Dean MacDonald. YTD
Dustin Martin. A-
Luke McGuane. B-
Brad Miller (upgraded rookie) C
Kelvin Moore. B-
Mitch Morton. C
Robin Nahas. B
Ben Nason. C
Chris Newman. B+
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie) YTD
Jayden Post. D+
Alex Rance. B-
Jack Riewoldt. A
Troy Taylor. N/A
Will Thursfield. C
Shane Tuck. B
Tyrone Vickery. B
Jeromey Webberley. C
Nick Westhoff (rookie) YTD
Matthew White. C+

 

[delediofan3]

David Astbury - C+
Andrew Browne - C-
Jake Batchelor - B
Reece Conca - B
Daniel Connors - C
Pat Contin (rookie) - C-
Trent Cotchin - A
Matt Dea - C-
Brett Deledio - A
Tom Derickx - C-
Shane Edwards B
Mitch Farmer - C
Nathan Foley - A
David Gourdis - C
Angus Graham - B
Ben Griffiths - B
Shaun Grigg - C+
Dylan Grimes - A-
Brad Helbig - C
Robert Hicks (rookie) - D
Tom Hislop (rookie) - B+
Bachar Houli - A-
Daniel Jackson - A
Ben Jakobi (rookie) - D
Jake King - A-
Dean MacDonald -C-
Dustin Martin - A
Luke McGuane - C+
Brad Miller (upgraded rookie) - B-
Kelvin Moore - B+
Mitch Morton - B-
Robin Nahas - B+
Ben Nason - C+
Chris Newman - A
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie) - C
Jayden Post - C
Alex Rance - B-
Jack Riewoldt - A
Troy Taylor - Z
Will Thursfield - B
Shane Tuck - A-
Tyrone Vickery - A-
Jeromey Webberley - B
Nick Westhoff (rookie) - D
Matthew White - B

I have not given anyone an A+ because although we've got some great talent I do believe that we've got room for improvement, i.e. Cotchin, Martin, Nahas, Foley getting rid of a tag.
Deledio and Newman bringing himself into the game.
Jack Riewoldt getting ahead of himself.
Tuck's disposal efficiency.
Rance having some consistency etc...

 

[Richo- true champion]

David Astbury: C+
Andrew Browne: C
Jake Batchelor: C+
Reece Conca: B-
Daniel Connors: B-
Pat Contin (rookie): YTD
Trent Cotchin: A
Matt Dea: YTD
Brett Deledio: A
Tom Derickx: YTD
Shane Edwards:B-/C+
Mitch Farmer: C
Nathan Foley: A- (will be A towards the end of the season)
David Gourdis: C
Angus Graham: C+
Ben Griffiths YTD
Shaun Grigg: B-
Dylan Grimes: C+
Brad Helbig: C
Robert Hicks (rookie): YTD
Tom Hislop (rookie): D
Bachar Houli: B/B-
Daniel Jackson: B+
Ben Jakobi (rookie): YTD
Jake King: B
Dean MacDonald: YTD
Dustin Martin: A/A-
Luke McGuane: B
Brad Miller (upgraded rookie): C+
Kelvin Moore: B+
Mitch Morton: B-
Robin Nahas: B
Ben Nason: C+
Chris Newman: A-
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie): YTD
Jayden Post: C
Alex Rance: B-
Jack Riewoldt: A
Troy Taylor: C
Will Thursfield: C+
Shane Tuck: B
Tyrone Vickery: B
Jeromey Webberley: C+
Nick Westhoff (rookie): YTD
Matthew White: C+

 

[TOOs_Finest]

David Astbury. C-
Andrew Browne. D
Jake Batchelor. C
Reece Conca. B-
Daniel Connors. C-
Pat Contin (rookie) YTD
Trent Cotchin. A
Matt Dea. YTD
Brett Deledio. A
Tom Derickx. YTD
Shane Edwards. C
Mitch Farmer. D+
Nathan Foley. B+
David Gourdis. YTD
Angus Graham. C-
Ben Griffiths. YTD
Shaun Grigg. B-
Dylan Grimes. C+
Brad Helbig. D+
Robert Hicks (rookie)YTD
Tom Hislop (rookie) D
Bachar Houli. B-
Daniel Jackson. B+
Ben Jakobi (rookie) YTD
Jake King. B
Dean MacDonald. YTD
Dustin Martin. B+
Luke McGuane. C
Brad Miller (upgraded rookie) C-
Kelvin Moore. B
Mitch Morton. C
Robin Nahas. B
Ben Nason. D+
Chris Newman. B+
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie) YTD
Jayden Post. D
Alex Rance. B-
Jack Riewoldt. A
Troy Taylor. N/A
Will Thursfield. D+
Shane Tuck. B
Tyrone Vickery. B-
Jeromey Webberley. D+
Nick Westhoff (rookie) YTD
Matthew White. C+

 

[Jade's]

A

Reiwoldt
Martin
Deledio
Cotchin

B

Newman
Foley
King
Nahas
Grigg
Houli
McGuane
Tuck
Moore

C

Jackson
White
Edwards
Vickery
Grahame
Morton
Thursfield

D

Rance
Post
Miller
Farmer
Connors
Browne

E

Gourdis
Hislop

The rest far too early to call.

 

[kingy46]

David Astbury: D Second year blues!
Andrew Browne: C tries his guts out
Jake Batchelor C+ will be a very good player
Reece Conca B seen enough to know he will be classy
Daniel Connors C Has the talent we know that
Pat Contin (rookie) D will be one who will debut late year.
Trent Cotchin A+ Doctor smooth and all class
Matt Dea YTD still undecided... looks lost
Brett Deledio A+ skills of a champion
Tom Derickx YTD have no seen enough of him
Shane Edwards B think he has natural ability to be good!
Mitch Farmer C getting upto speed with the game after injury
Nathan Foley B+ Amazes me how he finds so much of it
David Gourdis D after few games in10 let himself down
Angus Graham C just got tired i think. will be no1 second half yr
Ben Griffiths C will be a very very good player
Shaun Grigg C+ finds footy... skills a let down
Dylan Grimes C+ will become a very handy defender
Brad Helbig C not ready for the big time yet
Robert Hicks (rookie) FAIL---- Attitude towards AFL football sucks
Tom Hislop (rookie) C Twos form been good. good on him
Bachar Houli B Very solid form shown and has talent
Daniel Jackson A is vital for Richmond to win games!!
Ben Jakobi (rookie) YTD havent seen enough
Jake King B amazing turnaround. love kingy!
Dean MacDonald YTD is a small forward and quick
Dustin Martin A+ genuine star
Luke McGuane C not sold on lukey yet. skills worry me
Brad Miller (upgraded rookie) B has been good and gives options
Kelvin Moore B+ Key part of the team. need him!
Mitch Morton C Lost his form and dont know where too?
Robin Nahas B+ great story! works harder than anyone
Ben Nason D second year blues... dont get too comfy
Chris Newman B+ Rock solid week in week out. LEADER!
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie) YTD ahhh the irish...
Jayden Post D one game... need to do more
Alex Rance B for the effort! needs to touch up decision making
Jack Riewoldt A+ a star and love his passion
Troy Taylor D not done yet... will be a feel good story just wait
Will Thursfield D dont know what happened to will....
Shane Tuck C trys his guts out but has the game caught up?
Tyrone Vickery B has gots some moves young TY!
Jeromey Webberley D would love to see him in
Nick Westhoff (rookie) YTD looked lost even at VFL level
Matthew White C+ love his passion also!

 

[acr2751]

David Astbury c-
Andrew Browne c
Jake Batchelor c+
Reece Conca C+
Daniel Connors D
Pat Contin (rookie) ??
Trent Cotchin A
Matt Dea D
Brett Deledio A+
Tom Derickx ??
Shane Edwards c-
Mitch Farmer c-
Nathan Foley B+
David Gourdis D
Angus Graham C-
Ben Griffiths D
Shaun Grigg C+
Dylan Grimes C+
Brad Helbig D+
Robert Hicks (rookie)??
Tom Hislop (rookie) D
Bachar Houli B-
Daniel Jackson B
Ben Jakobi (rookie)??
Jake King B
Dean MacDonald ??
Dustin Martin A
Luke McGuane C
Brad Miller (upgraded rookie) C-
Kelvin Moore B
Mitch Morton C-
Robin Nahas B-
Ben Nason D
Chris Newman B
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie)??
Jayden Post D
Alex Rance C+
Jack Riewoldt A
Troy Taylor D-
Will Thursfield D
Shane Tuck C+
Tyrone Vickery B-
Jeromey Webberley D
Nick Westhoff (rookie)??
Matthew White[/quote]C-

 

[Rancid_Beasties]

Rankings - (This Year), (Career to date), (range of rankings I think we can expect over next 2-3 years)

F - should be delisted
E - struggling to stay on the list
D - outside of a good senior team
C - fringe of a good senior team
B - best 22 player in a good senior team
A - star in a good team

David Astbury - D, C, D to B+
Andrew Browne - D+, D, F to C+
Jake Batchelor - B, B, B to A
Reece Conca - B, B, B to A+
Daniel Connors - F, C, F to C
Pat Contin (rookie) - E, E, E to C
Trent Cotchin - A+, B+, B+ to A+
Matt Dea - E, D, F to C
Brett Deledio - A, A, B+ to A+
Tom Derickx - E, E, F to C+
Shane Edwards - C, C+, D to B+
Mitch Farmer - D, D, F to C+
Nathan Foley - A, A, B+ to A+
David Gourdis - D, D, F to B
Angus Graham - C, C+, E to B+
Ben Griffiths - D, D+, D to A+
Shaun Grigg - B, C+, C to A
Dylan Grimes - B, B, C to A
Brad Helbig - C, C, E to B+
Robert Hicks (rookie) - F, D, F to C
Tom Hislop (rookie) - D, E, F to B
Bachar Houli - B+, C+, C to A
Daniel Jackson - B, B, C+ to B+
Ben Jakobi (rookie) - E, E, F to C
Jake King - A, C, D to A
Dean MacDonald - E, E, E to B
Dustin Martin - A+, A, B+ to A+
Luke McGuane - B-, C+, D to B+
Brad Miller (upgraded rookie) - C, C, F to C+
Kelvin Moore - D, B, D to A
Mitch Morton - F, B, F to B+
Robin Nahas - A+, C+, C to A+
Ben Nason - C+, C+, D to B+
Chris Newman - B+, A, B to A+
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie) - D, D+, F to C+
Jayden Post - D, D, E to A
Alex Rance - B, C, D to B+
Jack Riewoldt - B+, A, B to A+
Troy Taylor - F, E, F
Will Thursfield - F, C+, F to D
Shane Tuck - C+, B+, C to A
Tyrone Vickery - B, C, C to A+
Jeromey Webberley - D, D, E to C+
Nick Westhoff (rookie) - E, E, F to C
Matthew White - B, C, D to B+

 

[Dr Rockso]

David Astbury: D Second year blues!
Andrew Browne: C tries his guts out
Jake Batchelor C+ will be a very good player
Reece Conca B seen enough to know he will be classy
Daniel Connors C Has the talent we know that
Pat Contin (rookie) D will be one who will debut late year.
Trent Cotchin A+ Doctor smooth and all class
Matt Dea YTD still undecided... looks lost
Brett Deledio A+ skills of a champion
Tom Derickx YTD have no seen enough of him
Shane Edwards B think he has natural ability to be good!
Mitch Farmer C getting upto speed with the game after injury
Nathan Foley B+ Amazes me how he finds so much of it
David Gourdis D after few games in10 let himself down
Angus Graham C just got tired i think. will be no1 second half yr
Ben Griffiths C will be a very very good player
Shaun Grigg C+ finds footy... skills a let down
Dylan Grimes C+ will become a very handy defender
Brad Helbig C not ready for the big time yet
Robert Hicks (rookie) FAIL---- Attitude towards AFL football sucks
Tom Hislop (rookie) C Twos form been good. good on him
Bachar Houli B Very solid form shown and has talent
Daniel Jackson A is vital for Richmond to win games!!
Ben Jakobi (rookie) YTD havent seen enough
Jake King B amazing turnaround. love kingy!
Dean MacDonald YTD is a small forward and quick
Dustin Martin A+ genuine star
Luke McGuane C not sold on lukey yet. skills worry me
Brad Miller (upgraded rookie) B has been good and gives options
Kelvin Moore B+ Key part of the team. need him!
Mitch Morton C Lost his form and dont know where too?
Robin Nahas B+ great story! works harder than anyone
Ben Nason D second year blues... dont get too comfy
Chris Newman B+ Rock solid week in week out. LEADER!
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie) YTD ahhh the irish...
Jayden Post D one game... need to do more
Alex Rance B for the effort! needs to touch up decision making
Jack Riewoldt A+ a star and love his passion
Troy Taylor D not done yet... will be a feel good story just wait
Will Thursfield D dont know what happened to will....
Shane Tuck C trys his guts out but has the game caught up?
Tyrone Vickery B has gots some moves young TY!
Jeromey Webberley D would love to see him in
Nick Westhoff (rookie) YTD looked lost even at VFL level
Matthew White C+ love his passion also!

good post, i agree!

 

[santa claws]

i go about it a little differently.
A = elite. B = very good. C = core list or solid citizen. D = development. F = below standard.
before people get their knickers all twisted just because a player is given a rating it does not mean that they wont climb the scale. eg cotchin B but should prove himself an A. HE DOES THIS BY HAVING A FEW TOP NOTCH SEASONS AND BECOMES A GAME BREAKER. HE BECOMES CONSISTENTLY ELITE.

Whoops sorry caps on but it highlights the point anyway.
okay here goes.

Astbury - D or early development. what he may end up is hard to call atm. has some good attributes
Browne - D early days but deficiencies point to likely F.
Batchelor - D shows good signs would think at least a future C likely better,
Conca - D see batchelor.
Connors - 5 yrs is enough for me. has talent but does lack in areas to make it. F
Contin - D a rookie hard to say where he may end up liked him a lot as a junior.has he done enough to even keep his spot.
Cotchin - B or very good. has not done enough consistently for mine to be called A yet.
Dea - D only second yr had injury probs has some time on his side think if he can get a decent run at it we will have at least a core list player.
Deledio - B i can hear it now. fact is hes a very good player but still hasnt taken games regularly by the scruff of the neck and still struggl;es with tags.
Derickx - D but only for a short while at 24 he needs to take a step up quickly. was worth taking a punt on but the question remains will he wont he make it.
Edwards - C at best would like to upgrade on him has many weaknesses.
Farmer - F has had long enough done very little in his 4 seasons of afl footy.
Foley - B/C has been injury hampered has played some excellent footy but weaknesses in his game will never see him become elite.
Gourdis - D yep hes at the tail end of development hasnt done a lot in his 3 and a bit seasons likely F because of chronic deficiencies. who knows.
Graham - simply put hes below standard and as such F.
Griffiths - D a lot of love arond for this bloke. fact is hes done nothing and has had serious injury problems where will he end up geez hopefully at least a C.
Grigg - C solid citizen obviously has deficiencies to get this rating.
Grimes - D think he will become a B.
Helbig - D shows promise hard to make a call where he will end up.
Hicks - F just my opinion but hes just too small.
Hislop - F has critical deficiency for his type at afl.
Houli - C solid player with kicking his strong point is very deficient in other areas. may improve his rating.
Jackson - C just a player performs a role for us but im adamant we could do better.
Jakobi - D we will have to wait and see has neat skills and looks like he will be a decent size.
King - C a very limited player. like jackson he currently performs a role personally would be looking for an upgrade.
Macdonald - D again too early to call. what ive seen im not impressed.
Martin atm B/C am hopeful he will end up an A
Mcguane - simply put F.
Miller - F
Moore - C has been nothing more than this rating.
Morton -C/ F has talent seems it is not his skills that is the problem.
Nahas - C/ F yep hes played some good footy this yr i just cant see him sustaining it. has deficiencies that little blokes shouldnt.some will say harsh.
Nason - F very ordinary in all areas.
Newman - B/C seems you like him as a player or you dont.
Orielly - D irish experiment i actually like the look of him may become C.
Post - D has stagnated has deficiencies 50/50 prospect.
Rance - F sorry just too many weaknesses in important areas.
Riewoldt - B yep hes been very good in fact when it comes to kicking a goal week in week out hes been an A. its other areas that hes been ordinary thus the low rating.
Taylor - F just does not have the mind set to make it.
Thursfield- F just doesnt give enough apart from a fist.
Tuck - C has always been a solid player but his skill set always remains the same.
Vickery - D may become a decent player has much to do.
Webberley F very average in all areaqs sort of says it all.
Westhoff - D a rookie in yr two will they re rookie him hmm.
White - F very ordinary player.

 

[Dr Rockso]

santa claws are you claw from PRE? lol

regardless, most of what you say is true. i disagree on Nahas and Connors, but the way you have categorised it protects your opinion so i can't really argue.

 

[santa claws]

santa claws are you claw from PRE? lol

regardless, most of what you say is true. i disagree on Nahas and Connors, but the way you have categorised it protects your opinion so i can't really argue.

yep the one and the same. still banned from over there will probably end up the same here.
think people are looking for the right excuse.

 

[Infamy]

I think given the age of our kids, most of our list are still YTD

 

[SteveoTheTiger]

I have based my ratings on how i feel the player has gone compared to what is expected of them this year. I have used YTD for players that are injured or who i am not sure how they are going at Coburg.

David Astbury - D - Was given a chance and wasnt able to kick on from last year.
Andrew Browne - B - Hasnt dominated but has won his way into the seniors.
Jake Batchelor - B - Fitting into the team like he has been there for years.
Reece Conca - A - Couldnt ask for much more from a kid that some here didnt want.
Daniel Connors - D - Injury has cost him his place in the side.
Pat Contin (rookie) - YTD
Trent Cotchin - A - Has really stepped up this year and is showing what he is capable of.
Matt Dea - YTD
Brett Deledio - A - All class
Tom Derickx - YTD
Shane Edwards - C - Has played one or two ok games but the rest have been shockers.
Mitch Farmer - C - Injured early but has made his way back into the seniors.
Nathan Foley - A - Not back to his best but a lot of people had already wrote the bloke off.
David Gourdis - F - Has totally lost his spot in the side. Needs to really lift.
Angus Graham - B - Has performed hard but cant do everything himself.
Ben Griffiths - YTD
Shaun Grigg - B - Has slotted into the side nicely, form has dropped a bit lately though.
Dylan Grimes - B - This kid came from nowhere to cement a spot. Has to fight back from injury now.
Brad Helbig - C - Has been ok for a new kid.
Robert Hicks (rookie) - D - Probably not an AFL player.
Tom Hislop (rookie) - YTD
Bachar Houli - B - Started slowly but has since played some nice games for us.
Daniel Jackson - B - Keeps kicking along doing his job well.
Ben Jakobi (rookie) - YTD
Jake King - A - Has kicked on from his form from last year.
Dean MacDonald - YTD
Dustin Martin - A - Started the season with a bang, needs to keep up the intensity.
Luke McGuane - C - Hasnt really improved this year, i still havent written him off though.
Brad Miller (upgraded rookie) - B - Came into the side early and done well, needs to convert his goals though.
Kelvin Moore - YTD
Mitch Morton - F - Totally lost the plot from where he was at late last year.
Robin Nahas - A - Came back from almost being delisted, could be a superstar.
Ben Nason - D - Hasnt make the most of his opportunities.
Chris Newman - B - Hasnt dominated as much as last year but still going well.
Jamie O'Reilly (rookie) - YTD
Jayden Post - D - Still hasnt shown too much. Give him time.
Alex Rance - A - From a bit of a journeyman of the team to a solid full back. Excellent effort.
Jack Riewoldt - A - Eventhough he hasnt dominated he is still winning the Coleman and more of our players are kicking goals. What more do people want from the kid?
Troy Taylor - F - Gone walkabout.
Will Thursfield - F - Overtaken by Grimes. Needs to prove himeself in the 2nd half or will be gone.
Shane Tuck - C - Missed the start of the year and hasnt really dominated games like last year.
Tyrone Vickery - B - Is making his mark as a key forward, needs to back his abilities a bit more.
Jeromey Webberley - C - Is playing well in the seconds but just cant crack the seniors at the moment.
Nick Westhoff (rookie) - D - Still kicking goals in the reserves but cant crack the seconds. Too small?
Matthew White - B - Started the season very well.