Rate Dale Thomas..

[mightymightyblues]

I think he is very overrated. Rated only a month by Mark Robinson and Mark Sheehan as a big chance for the AA HFF position.

I am so sick of Collingwood supporters raving on how good he is when his best and flashy qtrs in games each week are when Collingwood are well down. You only have to look at last week. In the first qtr when the pies got smashed, he had 11 touches. He was ok all together in the first half but the pies were still well held. Then when Collingwood very close in the second half, he went totally missing.

He could be something but at the moment he still has more ground to make up than Buddy does with his goal kicking. When will the day come when Magpie fans hit earth and realize he is nowhere near the player he is made out to be?

 

[Hodgepodge]

He's better than marc murphy anway.

 

[mightymightyblues]

He's better than marc murphy anway.

Ye probably. Murphy should be dropped immediately.

 

[Hodgepodge]

Ye probably. Murphy should be dropped immediately.

No he's good enough to play for carlton, but a shocking No.1 . . .

 

[mightymightyblues]

No he's good enough to play for carlton, but a shocking No.1 . . .

Fair enough. So you're point is, Murphy wouldn't get a game at any other club? I'm not gonna bother..
Leave this unintellegent debacle for another thread and focus on the topic mate.

 

[Hodgepodge]

Fair enough. So you're point is, Murphy wouldn't get a game at any other club? I'm not gonna bother..
Leave this unintellegent debacle for another thread and focus on the topic mate.

Nono, he would get a game, but not ahead of Dale Thomas.

 

[hellfire]

Rated according to whom?

Bigfooty? Underrated.

The media? Overrated.

So I'll say neither.

 

[mightymightyblues]

Rated according to whom?

Bigfooty? Underrated.

The media? Overrated.

So I'll say neither.

I'm talking in general. From your personal point of view where you think Thomas stands.

 

[mightymightyblues]

Nono, he would get a game, but not ahead of Dale Thomas.

I very much doubt that..

 

[parrot]

As a small opportunistic forward 7/10 - garden variety. As a midfielder 3/10 - hopeless.

 

[hellfire]

I'm talking in general. From your personal point of view where you think Thomas stands.

Well then your options are wrong. Because I can't think my own view of him is over or underrated, I would obviously believe I rate him accordingly.

If you mean how I rate the general perception of him, then I'll reiterate my first point - on Bigfooty he is underrated, because every week there are threads about what a dud he is, when in reality he's progressing just as well as any other forward-flank player his age, in some cases better. And given that Bigfooty is probably a good sample population of football fans, I'd say the general public underrates him. But with the media, he is overrated, as they hype him up to be a superstar, when he only has superstar potential.

 

[CrazyQ]

At the moment, he is definitely overrated, but he is a spark player though in this stage of his career.

No doubt in the future, he will be a 20 possie 1.5 goal a game footballer.

 

[Blueboy43]

He's better than marc murphy anway.

Is there anyone you rate at Carlton

 

[fryingpan]

I rate his thighs 10/10 in terms of femininity

 

[Blueboy43]

No he's good enough to play for carlton, but a shocking No.1 . . .

Hodgepodge you are a ****wit.

You stated in the Ellis/gibbs thread that Gibbs is the worst Number since dale thomas.

You have no ****ing idea. You are a hypocrite.

Do us all a favor and **** off.

 

[Heater39]

This is what, the 10th thread saying he is overrated? One seems to come out every week. The reason he was quiet in the 2nd half was that he was dragged to the goal square and Malthouse let him stay there, taking away any chance he had to influence the game. Compare him to others from the draft and I'm sure he would still be comfortably top 10. Once he develops his tank so that he can become a permanent midfielder he will be very good.

 

[Hodgepodge]

Hodgepodge you are a ****wit.

You stated in the Ellis/gibbs thread that Gibbs is the worst Number since dale thomas.

You have no ****ing idea. You are a hypocrite.

Do us all a favor and **** off.

Yup he is, but again, Dalethomas> marcmurphy
Are you going to have an episode everytime i think a player from another club is better than a player from your club?

 

[CrazyQ]

Marc averages 22, Thomas 14.

Hmm.

 

[Hodgepodge]

That's great, but again, dalethomas>marcmurphy, maybe not this year, but he's the better player and will have a better career than murphy.

Over their careers murphy averages 19 and thomas 15.

 

[mightymightyblues]

Yup he is, but again, Dalethomas> marcmurphy
Are you going to have an episode everytime i think a player from another club is better than a player from your club?

Fair enough.
I think a player like Nathan Jones sh*ts all over Sam Mitchell.
Don't have an episode where I think a player from another club is better than a player from your club.

 

[Blueboy43]

Yup he is, but again, Dalethomas> marcmurphy
Are you going to have an episode everytime i think a player from another club is better than a player from your club?

Luke hodge is not a big time player and is not judds arseh*le.

Dont have an episode man.

 

[Dave The Man]

I think he is very overrated. Rated only a month by Mark Robinson and Mark Sheehan as a big chance for the AA HFF position.

I am so sick of Collingwood supporters raving on how good he is when his best and flashy qtrs in games each week are when Collingwood are well down. You only have to look at last week. In the first qtr when the pies got smashed, he had 11 touches. He was ok all together in the first half but the pies were still well held. Then when Collingwood very close in the second half, he went totally missing.

He could be something but at the moment he still has more ground to make up than Buddy does with his goal kicking. When will the day come when Magpie fans hit earth and realize he is nowhere near the player he is made out to be?

Why I am not surprised at Carlton Supporter did this

 

[makethat2]

Luke hodge is not a big time player and is not judds arseh*le.

Dont have an episode man.

Your a tosser like many on this site. You take a recent game then label that over his whole career. Hodge is gun, has torn Collingwood apart in Big games and him along with Franklin won them the final against adelaide last year. All while being injured from that game.

 

[murph#3]

Your a tosser like many on this site. You take a recent game then label that over his whole career. Hodge is gun, has torn Collingwood apart in Big games and him along with Franklin won them the final against adelaide last year. All while being injured from that game.

sorry, but if they were playing collingwood how could it be a big game? who do you think you are??

 

[Alpha1]

He is going to be a good player for the Pies in the top 20 in the future. Not is the same class as Gibbs and Murphy though.