Rate my Super Coach team part II

[CaptainChardonnay]

Hi everyone, Just wondering if anyone would have some advice on my team below.

Backs: C.Enright, R.Hargrave, L.Hodge, Carrazzo, C.Pearce, N.Malceski, R.Ladson
Emg: P.Davis & J.Webberley

Mids: G.Ablett, S.Pedlebury, S.Mitchell, S.Hill, M.Robinson, D.Martin
Emg:L.Jetta & R.Bastinac

Rucks: D.Hille, N.Naitanui
Emg: R.Warnock & M.Lobbe

Forwards: A.Goodes, A.Didak, S.Higgins, K.Tippett, R.Murphy, P.Dangerfield, S.Wright
Emg: J.Posiadly & T.Rockliff

$9,800 in bank...

Thanks alot in advance for any replys they are very much appreciated...

Very unique team. Nothing wrong with that.

My two cents:
Not a fan of Carrazzo but perhaps he could be a smokey. Pearce?? Isn't he on the rookie list??? Will he get promoted?? Will he score/get picked? Webberley won't be promoted I'm told.

You think Hill is up for a big year??? Could be but you'd want your 4th mid to score pretty heavily. Isn't robinson more of a negating player???

Rucks are OK.

Your 2 premium fwds are over priced. Better value with less risk out there for that sort of money IMO. Think Higgins will keep going this year?? Is Wright going to get a regular game?

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

I think I have finally got every thing pretty even as long as rookies get upgraded.

Backs : Drummond,Enright,Hodge, Harbrow,Malceski,Hunt,Greenwood ( Maguire ,Trengove)

Mids : Ablett,Selwood,Mitchell,Vince,Martin,Barlow ( Banner, Moles )

Rucks : Sandilands, Naitanui ( Warnock, Skipper)

Forwards : Riewoldt,Pavlich,Brown,Franklin,Hall,Mayne, Rockliff ( Hitchcock, Podsiadly )

Spare cash a whopping $100

Don't think there's much to say. Hall is a risk but you know that. Anything I say is just personal opinion. You have yours and a pretty handy team because of it.

 

[dopeh]

Hi everyone, Just wondering if anyone would have some advice on my team below.

Backs: C.Enright, R.Hargrave, L.Hodge, Carrazzo, C.Pearce, N.Malceski, R.Ladson
Emg: P.Davis & J.Webberley

Mids: G.Ablett, S.Pedlebury, S.Mitchell, S.Hill, M.Robinson, D.Martin
Emg:L.Jetta & R.Bastinac

Rucks: D.Hille, N.Naitanui
Emg: R.Warnock & M.Lobbe

Forwards: A.Goodes, A.Didak, S.Higgins, K.Tippett, R.Murphy, P.Dangerfield, S.Wright
Emg: J.Posiadly & T.Rockliff

$9,800 in bank...

Thanks alot in advance for any replys they are very much appreciated...

Backs are solid without being great have concerns with Hargrave, will he score similar to last year? Not sure his price tag is worth it. Also Carrazzo's role is very unknown, could be used as a defensive player limiting his scoring.

Mids are good, will Hill step it up this year? Robbo is in for a cracker year based on pre season form could be a great pickup.

Rucks are risky, hille returning from injury, and nicnat has unknown scoring potential could be limited by cox.

Forwards are good and unqie although didak can be annoying, with 140 one week and 30 the next, if he gets tagged regularly could lose alot of value.

Now for my team...


Backs: B.Goddard,C.Enright, H.Shaw, L.Hodge, N.Malceski, J.Hunt, L.Greenwood
Emg: P.Davis & J.Trengrove

Mids: G.Ablett, N.Dal Santo, S.Mitchell, S.Pendlebury, D.Martin, L.Shuey
Emg:M.Banner & M.Barlow

Rucks: A.Sandilands, B.McEvoy
Emg: R.Warnock & M.Lobbe

Forwards: N.Riewoldt, B.Harvey, S.Higgins, B.Hall, J.Zieball, P.Dangerfield, T.Rockliff
Emg: J.Posiadly & S.Gumbleton

 

[AFLROCKS]

Hi everyone, Just wondering if anyone would have some advice on my team below.

Backs: C.Enright, R.Hargrave, L.Hodge, Carrazzo, C.Pearce, N.Malceski, R.Ladson
Emg: P.Davis & J.Webberley

Mids: G.Ablett, S.Pedlebury, S.Mitchell, S.Hill, M.Robinson, D.Martin
Emg:L.Jetta & R.Bastinac

Rucks: D.Hille, N.Naitanui
Emg: R.Warnock & M.Lobbe

Forwards: A.Goodes, A.Didak, S.Higgins, K.Tippett, R.Murphy, P.Dangerfield, S.Wright
Emg: J.Posiadly & T.Rockliff

$9,800 in bank...

Thanks alot in advance for any replys they are very much appreciated...

Very unique team. Nothing wrong with that.

My two cents:
Not a fan of Carrazzo but perhaps he could be a smokey. Pearce?? Isn't he on the rookie list??? Will he get promoted?? Will he score/get picked? Webberley won't be promoted I'm told.

You think Hill is up for a big year??? Could be but you'd want your 4th mid to score pretty heavily. Isn't robinson more of a negating player???

Rucks are OK.

Your 2 premium fwds are over priced. Better value with less risk out there for that sort of money IMO. Think Higgins will keep going this year?? Is Wright going to get a regular game?

I do think Carrazzo is in for a good season. Pearce I am not usre if he will be promoted off the rookie list does anyone know? If he does I thought he would be a unique pick that would earn me some $$. As for Webberley, may have to look for someone else, any suggestions?

Hill is definately up for a big year IMO, he has put on alot of bulk and is a gun, agian IMO, but will probably look at upgrading him during the season.

Higgins will be fine, and Wright will be a good player IMO.

Thanks for your oppinion. Anyone elso wanna chuck in their two cents?

 

[rundennisrun]

have already said a team but have changed vastly and would like opinion

Backs: Drummond, Enright, Lake, Hodge, Waite, Ladson, Greenwood (Trengrove P.A, Carlisle)

Mids: Ablett, Montagna, Boyd, A Walker, J Trengrove, Martin (Morabito, Sinclair)

Rucks: Macintosh, Leunberger/Charman selection depending (Warnock, Fitzpatrick)

Fwds: Reiwoldt, Pavlich, Higgins, Dangerfield, Ziebell, Mayne, T Walker (Dennis-lane, Tapscott)

I've got an extra $125k and thinking about upgrading T Walker but not sure on anyone considerably better for $365k any help greatly appreciated,
cheers, Matt

 

[Bomber4ever]

have already said a team but have changed vastly and would like opinion

Backs: Drummond, Enright, Lake, Hodge, Waite, Ladson, Greenwood (Trengrove P.A, Carlisle)

Mids: Ablett, Montagna, Boyd, A Walker, J Trengrove, Martin (Morabito, Sinclair)

Rucks: Macintosh, Leunberger/Charman selection depending (Warnock, Fitzpatrick)

Fwds: Reiwoldt, Pavlich, Higgins, Dangerfield, Ziebell, Mayne, T Walker (Dennis-lane, Tapscott)

I've got an extra $125k and thinking about upgrading T Walker but not sure on anyone considerably better for $365k any help greatly appreciated,
cheers, Matt

Def: Very strong defence. I like it. Quite a few injury prones players but most of us have them.

Mid: Ablett is a no brainer. Boyd is a unique pick but that is a good thing! I've been looking closely at him. Whilst Walker looks might like pretty good value i wouldn't pick him because I think midfield players are so valuable you need to take advantage of every one of them and get them spot on. Whilst his value will rise i think you'll be losing points early on to many other teams.

Ruck: McIntosh is a good pick up. Charman is injured and i wouldn't count on Luey to score high enough to justify being your second ruck.

Fwd: Lots of mid priced players here. I think you could downgrade one of them and use the extra cash to boost another position.

I'd look at downgrading T.Walker to a cheaper option and then upgrade your second.

 

[russea]

have already said a team but have changed vastly and would like opinion

Backs: Drummond, Enright, Lake, Hodge, Waite, Ladson, Greenwood (Trengrove P.A, Carlisle)

Mids: Ablett, Montagna, Boyd, A Walker, J Trengrove, Martin (Morabito, Sinclair)

Rucks: Macintosh, Leunberger/Charman selection depending (Warnock, Fitzpatrick)

Fwds: Reiwoldt, Pavlich, Higgins, Dangerfield, Ziebell, Mayne, T Walker (Dennis-lane, Tapscott)

I've got an extra $125k and thinking about upgrading T Walker but not sure on anyone considerably better for $365k any help greatly appreciated,
cheers, Matt

Backs look alright waite could be a risk but could turn out to be a very handy 1. I perfer hunt over ladson personally but like Greenwood
Mids are good but im not sure on A walker but u being a blues man probly no more.

Rucks alright Hmac good, Charman is injured so it leunberger

Fwds no bad but a little weak ur hoping for alot from ur mid priced players and BTW T walker is a spud so stay away if u were going to upgrade Big bad Barry Hall could be a good option

So not a bad side but improvements could be made 7/10 from me

 

[spidermanbatman]

i have downgraded my foward line:

DEF Enright Fisher Hodge Adcock Malceski Nash Waters (Carlisle Silvagni)
MID Ablett Pendlebury Mithcell Boyd Trengrove Martin (Banner Moles)
RUCK Sandilands Hille (Lobbe Mcnamara)
FWD Riewoldt Pavlich Harvey Higgins Porplyzia? Medhurst Rockliff (Tapscott Podsiadly)
not sure about porpylzia though

 

[masterblaster94]

Hey guyz, this is my 3rd draft for my team.
Plz comment on any weaknesses!
btw i made the premium players in bold.

DEFENSE: B.Goddard, C.Enright, H.Shaw, L.Hodge, N.Malceski, Hunt, B.Waters (M.Maguire, Z.Tuohy)

MIDFIELD: L.Hayes, M.Murphy, S.Mitchell, B.Vince, B.Harvey, D.Martin (A.Morabito, Kayler)

RUCK: D.Hille, N.Naitanui
(J.Roughead, E.Prato)

FORWARD: N.Riewoldt, M.Pavlich, J.Brown, L.Franklin, C.Mayne, J.Neagle, S.Gumbleton. (T.Lynch, J.Gunsten)

 

[Agetigers]

have already said a team but have changed vastly and would like opinion

Backs: Drummond, Enright, Lake, Hodge, Waite, Ladson, Greenwood (Trengrove P.A, Carlisle)

Mids: Ablett, Montagna, Boyd, A Walker, J Trengrove, Martin (Morabito, Sinclair)

Rucks: Macintosh, Leunberger/Charman selection depending (Warnock, Fitzpatrick)

Fwds: Reiwoldt, Pavlich, Higgins, Dangerfield, Ziebell, Mayne, T Walker (Dennis-lane, Tapscott)

I've got an extra $125k and thinking about upgrading T Walker but not sure on anyone considerably better for $365k any help greatly appreciated,
cheers, Matt

Backs look fine!
Midfield is a little suspect with Walker in there could probablly downgrade him to a Burgouyne, Cotchin, Mastin or another rookie. Also Morabito hasnt set the world on fire in the NAB so you might wanna look a swapping him for someone who has (Banner)

Like The forwards maybe need one more quality player in there!! But i love the selection of T.Walker.

Heres mine:

Backs: Newman Shaw Hodge Gram Firrito Hunt Shoenmakers
(Maguire, Trengove)

Mids: Ablett Mitchell Gibbs Watson Martin Barlow
(Jetta, Banner)

Rucks: Tippett Naitanui
(Warnock Mcnamara)

Forwards: Reiwoldt Pav Harvey Franklin Hall Dangerfield Rockliff
(Hitchcock Fyfe)

 

[rundennisrun]

Def: Very strong defence. I like it. Quite a few injury prones players but most of us have them.

Mid: Ablett is a no brainer. Boyd is a unique pick but that is a good thing! I've been looking closely at him. Whilst Walker looks might like pretty good value i wouldn't pick him because I think midfield players are so valuable you need to take advantage of every one of them and get them spot on. Whilst his value will rise i think you'll be losing points early on to many other teams.

Ruck: McIntosh is a good pick up. Charman is injured and i wouldn't count on Luey to score high enough to justify being your second ruck.

Fwd: Lots of mid priced players here. I think you could downgrade one of them and use the extra cash to boost another position.

I'd look at downgrading T.Walker to a cheaper option and then upgrade your second.

Thanks mate,
I changed T Walker - Hall but decided to keep luenberger as I couldn't free up enough money without making major changes. Am going to keep A Walker as his club exile has made him fitter than ever and should keep a spot like his early career form only thing I can see going wrong with him is if Ratten changes the role he does

 

[thomas_m18]

Backs look fine!
Midfield is a little suspect with Walker in there could probablly downgrade him to a Burgouyne, Cotchin, Mastin or another rookie. Also Morabito hasnt set the world on fire in the NAB so you might wanna look a swapping him for someone who has (Banner)

Like The forwards maybe need one more quality player in there!! But i love the selection of T.Walker.

Heres mine:

Backs: Newman Shaw Hodge Gram Firrito Hunt Shoenmakers
(Maguire, Trengove)

Mids: Ablett Mitchell Gibbs Watson Martin Barlow
(Jetta, Banner)

Rucks: Tippett Naitanui
(Warnock Mcnamara)

Forwards: Reiwoldt Pav Harvey Franklin Hall Dangerfield Rockliff
(Hitchcock Fyfe)

I'll be short. Backs are iffy. Newman is fine, Shaw may get tagged, dunno how he'd deal with it. I'm thinking Fisher or Hurn (who will probably get tagged as well) for that spot. Hodge = Lock, trade Gram for Macdonald.

Firrito doesn't seem a terrific pick. Dunno bout a replacement though? Maybe Ellis?

Hunt good. Shoey is unusual, dunno if he's better than Waters.

Mids good. Watson is different, good different.

Rucks alright, can;t decide between NicNat and Hille.

Forwards are exactly the same as mine (barring reserves).

Pretty solid overall, not much to say.


My Team

DEF: Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Macdonald, Malceski (think he’s good to go), Hunt, Waters
RES: Maguire, Davis (considering Silvagni)

MID: Ablett, Swan, Selwood, Cooney, Barlow, Martin
RES: Bastinac, Shuey (or Jetta)

RUCK: Sandilands, Hille
RES: Skipper, McCauley (don’t give a crap about 4th ruck, useless to me)

FWD: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Franklin, Harvey, Hall, Dangerfield, Rockliff
RES: Gumbleton (will probably start round 1 unless Pods impresses before then), Podsiadly
Looking almost there to me, but tips anyone?

Really iffy between Davis and Silvagni, and not sure between Shuey and Jetta.


Rate anyone?

 

[russea]

Hey guyz, this is my 3rd draft for my team.
Plz comment on any weaknesses!
btw i made the premium players in bold.

DEFENSE: B.Goddard, C.Enright, H.Shaw, L.Hodge, N.Malceski, Hunt, B.Waters (M.Maguire, Z.Tuohy)

MIDFIELD: L.Hayes, M.Murphy, S.Mitchell, B.Vince, B.Harvey, D.Martin (A.Morabito, Kayler)

RUCK: D.Hille, N.Naitanui
(J.Roughead, E.Prato)

FORWARD: N.Riewoldt, M.Pavlich, J.Brown, L.Franklin, C.Mayne, J.Neagle, S.Gumbleton. (T.Lynch, J.Gunsten)

Like ur backs very nice no weakness there
Mids are packed just a heads up murphs is coming off injury and a interupted preseson so mabye find a replacement, what u could do is down grade mabye harvey for a rookie to free up a ton of cash and moribito really hasnt impresses pre season so go for some who has ie. banner or barlow

Rucks an obvious weakness mabye use some of that cash to upgrade one of them

Fwds not bad neagle is not a SC player find a replacement mabye ballantyne. and for a bench tip podsialsy looks like a bargin at only 84k a mature aged rookie and bomber thompson says hes going to play

hope this all helps

 

[Hawks92]

Hey guys, posted a new team every few weeks, this is one i came up with after this weeks NAB performances

Backs: Goodwin, Enright, Fisher, Hodge, Malceski, Hunt, Ladson (Maguire, Webberly)

Mids: Ablett, Mitchell, Boyd, Armitage, Martin, Barlow (Kayler-Thompson, Banner)

Rucks: Jolly, Naitanui, (Skipper, Warnock)

Forwards: Riewoldt, Brown, Giansiracusa, Hall, Ziebell, Medhurst, Rohan (Rockliff, Hitchcock)

234,000 left over - thinking about upgrading a forward, but so much value!

 

[Mirsin]

Hey guyz, this is my 3rd draft for my team.
Plz comment on any weaknesses!
btw i made the premium players in bold.

DEFENSE: B.Goddard, C.Enright, H.Shaw, L.Hodge, N.Malceski, Hunt, B.Waters (M.Maguire, Z.Tuohy)

MIDFIELD: L.Hayes, M.Murphy, S.Mitchell, B.Vince, B.Harvey, D.Martin (A.Morabito, Kayler)

RUCK: D.Hille, N.Naitanui
(J.Roughead, E.Prato)

FORWARD: N.Riewoldt, M.Pavlich, J.Brown, L.Franklin, C.Mayne, J.Neagle, S.Gumbleton. (T.Lynch, J.Gunsten)

Getting there! Get rid of Mayne and put Harvey there. Look for another rookie like Jetta, Shuey, Bastinac or Moles to fill the midfield.

 

[Mirsin]

Hey guys, posted a new team every few weeks, this is one i came up with after this weeks NAB performances

Backs: Goodwin, Enright, Fisher, Hodge, Malceski, Hunt, Ladson (Maguire, Webberly)

Mids: Ablett, Mitchell, Boyd, Armitage, Martin, Barlow (Kayler-Thompson, Banner)

Rucks: Jolly, Naitanui, (Skipper, Warnock)

Forwards: Riewoldt, Brown, Giansiracusa, Hall, Ziebell, Medhurst, Rohan (Rockliff, Hitchcock)

234,000 left over - thinking about upgrading a forward, but so much value!

A Hawthorn supporter with no Franklin in the forward line. Sacreligeous! Im sure you have a good reason though. You have a lot of cash laying around so it all depends on who you want to upgrade from and to.

Backs look solid enough. If you want to spend you extra cash, upgrade Fisher to Goddard. Best pick is to upgrade the midfield. Upgrade Armitage to a Selwood, Judd (Available round 5) type player. Rucks are good, Skipper is a good pick with Taylor injured for 4 months.

Forwards a good enough in a missing Franklin sorta way. . .

 

[russea]

Hey guys, posted a new team every few weeks, this is one i came up with after this weeks NAB performances

Backs: Goodwin, Enright, Fisher, Hodge, Malceski, Hunt, Ladson (Maguire, Webberly)

Mids: Ablett, Mitchell, Boyd, Armitage, Martin, Barlow (Kayler-Thompson, Banner)

Rucks: Jolly, Naitanui, (Skipper, Warnock)

Forwards: Riewoldt, Brown, Giansiracusa, Hall, Ziebell, Medhurst, Rohan (Rockliff, Hitchcock)

234,000 left over - thinking about upgrading a forward, but so much value!

Hmm thats a fair bit of cash
Ur backs look good bar Goodwin hes 33 this year do u really think he can continue my opinion upgrade to goodard with some of that cash

Mids are good armitage u could always upgrade to ball

Rucks are good

fwds are good mabye upgrade hall to tippet??

So thats something u could with the cash just my opinion. just play around with some upgrade till u are happy

 

[Hawks92]

A Hawthorn supporter with no Franklin in the forward line. Sacreligeous! Im sure you have a good reason though. You have a lot of cash laying around so it all depends on who you want to upgrade from and to.

Backs look solid enough. If you want to spend you extra cash, upgrade Fisher to Goddard. Best pick is to upgrade the midfield. Upgrade Armitage to a Selwood, Judd (Available round 5) type player. Rucks are good, Skipper is a good pick with Taylor injured for 4 months.

Forwards a good enough in a missing Franklin sorta way. . .

Buddy is a God and i love him as much as you do haha. Had him in my team from day 1, but decided to give him a miss, think he's a bit of a slow starter - will definitely have him in there by the end of the season

Hmm thats a fair bit of cash
Ur backs look good bar Goodwin hes 33 this year do u really think he can continue my opinion upgrade to goodard with some of that cash

Mids are good armitage u could always upgrade to ball

Rucks are good

fwds are good mabye upgrade hall to tippet??

So thats something u could with the cash just my opinion. just play around with some upgrade till u are happy

Thanks very much for your opinions guys.Hall represents too much value, need to keep him for a while. Considering Tippet in the ruck.

Goodwin just keeps on keeping on, will probably play 18-10 games but is very capable of scoring over 100 (show that also in NAB). Still got a few weeks to go so we will see

 

[Purrfect Pussies]

How you feeling Russea? Fingers getting itchy? Having withdrawals from not posting side #1224?

Great work, pumping out the ratings & opinions but!

Cheers.

 

[thomas_m18]

How you feeling Russea? Fingers getting itchy? Having withdrawals from not posting side #1224?

Great work, pumping out the ratings & opinions but!

Cheers.

Purrfect, he's not the only one whose getting anxious. I posted yet another revision just before.

My Team

DEF: Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Macdonald, Malceski (think he’s good to go), Hunt, Waters
RES: Maguire, Davis (considering Silvagni)

MID: Ablett, Swan, Selwood, Cooney, Barlow, Martin
RES: Bastinac, Shuey (or Jetta)

RUCK: Sandilands, Hille
RES: Skipper, McCauley (don’t give a crap about 4th ruck, useless to me)

FWD: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Franklin, Harvey, Hall, Dangerfield, Rockliff
RES: Gumbleton (will probably start round 1 unless Pods impresses before then), Podsiadly
Looking almost there to me, but tips anyone?

Really iffy between Davis and Silvagni, and not sure between Shuey and Jetta.


Rate anyone?

I can't help it.

By the way, did you get my rate on your team? I think I sent it a couple of weeks ago.

 

[russea]

Originally Posted by Purrfect Pussies
How you feeling Russea? Fingers getting itchy? Having withdrawals from not posting side #1224?

Great work, pumping out the ratings & opinions but!

Cheers.

Purrfect, he's not the only one whose getting anxious. I posted yet another revision just before.



I can't help it.

By the way, did you get my rate on your team? I think I sent it a couple of weeks ago.

hey im not anxious ur the only one cause ur worried about how my good my team is and how ur teams going to get smash

 

[thomas_m18]

Originally Posted by Purrfect Pussies
How you feeling Russea? Fingers getting itchy? Having withdrawals from not posting side #1224?

Great work, pumping out the ratings & opinions but!

Cheers.



hey im not anxious ur the only one cause ur worried about how my good my team is and how ur teams going to get smash

Very funny, very funny, let our teams do the talking, eh?

 

[russea]

Very funny, very funny, let our teams do the talking, eh?

Ur teams not gonna be saying much being on the floor after my teams had a go at it
Nah jokes it will probly beg for mercy 1st

 

[larrikan]

Would love some criticism of my team...thanks....

Goddard, Enright, H.Shaw, Hodge, Malceski, Ladson, Greenwood
(B. Waters, Macguire)

Ablett(C), Pendlebury, Vince, Ball, Barlow, Jetta
(Banner, Bastinac)

Cox, Naitanui
(Warnock, Skipper)

Reiwoldt, Higgins, Giansiracusa, Gray, Dangerfield, Medhurst, Rohan
(Rockliff, Podsiadly)

some decisions such as leaving out Martin and Trengove are based purely on being different

 

[russea]

Would love some criticism of my team...thanks....

Goddard, Enright, H.Shaw, Hodge, Malceski, Ladson, Greenwood
(B. Waters, Macguire)

Ablett(C), Pendlebury, Vince, Ball, Barlow, Jetta
(Banner, Bastinac)

Cox, Naitanui
(Warnock, Skipper)

Reiwoldt, Higgins, Giansiracusa, Gray, Dangerfield, Medhurst, Rohan
(Rockliff, Podsiadly)

some decisions such as leaving out Martin and Trengove are based purely on being different

Backs are all good pretty much standard
Mids are good but u have to i repeat HAVE TO HAVE MARTIN he is all ready in richmonds top 10 players without playing a game.

Rucks are ok not confident on Cox i much prefer sandi

Fwds not bad Higgins injury prone, Gia i like, gray i like, Danger is good, like medhurst a lot my one of my bargin picks of 2010 looks ready to fire

so not a bad side but please get martin for the good of ur side