Rate our...

[Tristagi]

Rate our team in comparison to the rest of the AFL. Split the sections of the ground up (Putting in your best 7 defenders - 6 Midfielders - 7 Forwards - 2 Ruckman) Then rank it out of 16. 1 being the best and 16 the worst.


Backline: 5/16
Scarlett, Harley, Egan, J. Hunt, Milburn, Rooke and D. Johnson

Midfield: 8/16
Ablett, Bartel, Corey, Ling, Kelly and Enright

Forward: 11/16
Ottens, Mooney, Chapman, Stokes, N. Ablett, Mackie and S. Johnson

Ruckman: 14/16
King and Blake

 

[Big Nasty]

Backline-(1/16)

Midfield-(9/16)

Forward-(8/16)

Ruck-(13/16)

 

[Metallica_Man]

Backline - 1
Midfield - 7
Forward - 8
Ruck - 12

 

[Claude Balls]

Rate our team in comparison to the rest of the AFL. Split the sections of the ground up (Putting in your best 7 defenders - 6 Midfielders - 7 Forwards - 2 Ruckman) Then rank it out of 16. 1 being the best and 16 the worst.


Backline: 5/16
Scarlett, Harley, Egan, J. Hunt, Milburn, Rooke and D. Johnson

Midfield: 8/16
Ablett, Bartel, Corey, Ling , Kelly and Enright

Forward: 11/16
Ottens, Mooney, Chapman, Stokes, N. Ablett, Mackie and S. Johnson

Ruckman: 14/16
King and Blake

While those players are running around we would be 16th and 16th for backline and midfield. Those players should not be in the team.

Sub in David Wojcinski to defence and Chapman/Prismall into the midfield and I think it would follow as such:

Defence - 4th

Ruck/Midfield - 10th

Attack - 8th

 

[crosby123]

Defence - 4
Midfield/Ruck - 12
Forward - 7

If the midfield has its act together, its easily top 8.

 

[DanA]

Defence - 2 (Adelaide ahead)
Midfeild - 11 (Car, Ess, Coll, Bris, Rich, Nth behind)
Forward - 7 (Ade, Bull, Car, Coll, Haw Nth, Port, Rich, WC Behind)
Ruck - 9 (Ade, StK, WB, Haw, Coll, Car, Syd Behind)

That is how I rate it with the Forwardline potentially being Top 3 if Ottens & Mooney play to potential.

Backline:
Egan, Scarlett, J.Hunt, Milburn, Harley, Wojcinski

Midfeild: Bartel, Corey, Rooke, Enright, Prismall, Mackie, Ling (Ablett, Chapman, Stokes part time)

Forward: Ottens, Mooney, Ablett, Chapman, N.Ablett, S.Johnson, Stokes

Ruck: King, Blake, (Ottens part time).

 

[martyk]

While those players are running around we would be 16th and 16th for backline and midfield. Those players should not be in the team.

Sub in David Wojcinski to defence and Chapman/Prismall into the midfield and I think it would follow as such:

Defence - 4th

Ruck/Midfield - 10th

Attack - 8th

Why is Wojcinski so important? He may look great prancing around with the ball but he is not accountable enough for his man, which is the primary job of a defender... He doesn't even hurt the opposition with his disposal either?? Why is this guy rated highly by some of you?? I'd really like to know???

 

[martyk]

Defence - 2 (Adelaide ahead)
Midfeild - 11 (Car, Ess, Coll, Bris, Rich, Nth behind)
Forward - 7 (Ade, Bull, Car, Coll, Haw Nth, Port, Rich, WC Behind)
Ruck - 9 (Ade, StK, WB, Haw, Coll, Car, Syd Behind)

That is how I rate it with the Forwardline potentially being Top 3 if Ottens & Mooney play to potential.

Backline:
Egan, Scarlett, J.Hunt, Milburn, Harley, Wojcinski

Midfeild: Bartel, Corey, Rooke, Enright, Prismall, Mackie, Ling (Ablett, Chapman, Stokes part time)

Forward: Ottens, Mooney, Ablett, Chapman, N.Ablett, S.Johnson, Stokes

Ruck: King, Blake, (Ottens part time).

I reckon that looks about right....

 

[year of the cat]

Why is Wojcinski so important? He may look great prancing around with the ball but he is not accountable enough for his man, which is the primary job of a defender... He doesn't even hurt the opposition with his disposal either?? Why is this guy rated highly by some of you?? I'd really like to know???

I don't know about rating him highly - but he is the only one with genuine leg speed in defense. You are right in that his disposal could be better and he could be more accountable. But on the positive side he provides a lot of run out of defense - with Egan, Milburn and Harley we are a little slow down back and don't initiate much attack from these players. Woja at least can "run through the lines" and catch the opposing teams defense out as they haven't had opportunity to organise themselves. That is one of my gripes with Ling. He stops the flow of play and gives the opposing team time to flood back or at least get themselves better organised. It is predictable and it is crap football.

 

[samd]

pretty much all duds backline 5/16 midfield 9/16 and fowardline 16/16

 

[tin can sam]

pretty much all duds backline 5/16 midfield 9/16 and fowardline 16/16

your not that funny.

 

[samd]

your not that funny.

oh yeah iam because all your team is bunch of misfits that never make the eight

 

[tin can sam]

oh yeah iam because all your team is bunch of misfits that never make the eight

I'm guessing your about 13?

 

[samd]

I'm guessing your about 13?

yeah

 

[Kittenish]

yeah

Oh go find a Playboy and j*** off you little idiot.
You wouldn't know what we're talking about here.

 

[cat_fanatic]

Youth - 1st (Selwood, Prismall, Hawkins, N. Ablett, Gamble, Djerrkura, Varcoe, Egan, Stokes)

 

[Big Nasty]

pretty much all duds backline 5/16 midfield 9/16 and fowardline 16/16

C'mon It must take guts giving other teams **** when your teams best Forward is Anthony Rocca, and your teams future star is Dale thomas. LMFAO

 

[Big Nasty]

Youth - 1st (Selwood, Prismall, Hawkins, N. Ablett, Gamble, Djerrkura, Varcoe, Egan, Stokes)

you could add Bartel and Gazza to that list as they are only 22, man we are gonna be a killer outfit in 3 years time.

 

[cat_fanatic]

you could add Bartel and Gazza to that list as they are only 22, man we are gonna be a killer outfit in 3 years time.

Yeah, but what about Scarlett, Harley and Milburn? They will all be past it and we will be relying on Egan, S. Hunt and Grima. IMO we will have one of the best midfields (Prismall, Selwood, Bartel, Ablett, Stokes) and forward lines (Hawkins, N. Ablett, Chapman, SJ, Varcoe, Djerrkura) but our backline will struggle.

 

[Kittenish]

Dazza'll keep going for at least another 2 years.
And Mattie's just reaching peak now, so we may just be alright on that front. Maybe we could pick up more defence newbies next draft?

 

[Big Nasty]

Dazza'll keep going for at least another 2 years.
And Mattie's just reaching peak now, so we may just be alright on that front. Maybe we could pick up more defence newbies next draft?

Yeah I reckon defenders and Ruckmen will be in need of a close look in this years draft.

 

[Kittenish]

Yeah I reckon defenders and Ruckmen will be in need of a close look in this years draft.

We need to think about putting King out to pasture. He's old now.... OLD I TELLS YA!
Maybe sniff around the defenders more. We may be in need to replace Harley soon..ish.

 

[Big Nasty]

With the recruiters we had last year I say we retire King, play Blake and West and take an awesome ruckman in our 1ST ROUND and then look for promising defenders in the rest of the picks.

 

[Kittenish]

With the recruiters we had last year I say we retire King, play Blake and West and take an awesome ruckman in our 1ST ROUND and then look for promising defenders in the rest of the picks.

Sounds like a plan there.
Now if only we could get someone in the picks pickers.....